Select Committee on Public Accounts Minutes of Evidence


Supplementary memorandum submitted by the Department for Innovation, Universities and Skills

Questions 110 (Mr Philip Dunne):   School/ College Expenditure on Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) subjects

  The Government's headline objectives for schools' science and mathematics are to increase enjoyment of, and attainment in, these subjects during secondary education so that more young people continue to study them post-16 through to first degree level and beyond. Challenging public targets have been set for recruiting and retaining subject specialist teachers and for improvements in attainment levels at Key Stage 3 and GCSEs and the number of young people taking science and mathematics A-levels.

  Colleagues from the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF), with whom DIUS works closely on these issues, have advised that, in order to meet these targets, they are undertaking a wide range of programme activity: recruitment and retention of specialist teachers; improving quality of teaching through Continuing Professional Development (CPD); boosting post-16 take up through communications and careers guidance; improving the learning experience through engagement and enrichment; qualification and curriculum reform; co-ordinating STEM support to make access easier for schools; and aligning and targeting public, private and third sector investment in support for schools and colleges. Spending plans reflect key priorities in each of these work strands and the amounts for each element are set out in the table below:

School/College expenditure on STEM subjects

Interventions 2006-07 (£000s)2007-08 (£000s)
CPD—Schools
Secondary National Strategies75,200 81,460
Science Learning Centres2,900 2,900
Training and Development Agency for Schools accredited enhanced subject knowledge in physics, mathematics, chemistry 50740
National Centre for Excellence in the Teaching of Mathematics 4,7004,700
Other smaller initiatives eg Triple Science Support Programme; Girls into Physics 2,1003,500
CPD—Further Education
Teaching and Learning Change Programme and Maths4Life 9,00010,000
Widening Participation
Aim Higher and supporting strategically important subjects programmes eg Stimulating Physics 6,2405,100
Enhancement and Enrichment
STEMNET4,8005,300
After-schools Science and Engineering Clubs 2,5002,500
Further Mathematics Network2,100 1,900
Other smaller initiatives eg Bowland initiative; Computer Clubs for Girls etc 3,6004,000
SUB-TOTAL113,190 122,100
School Workforce
Mainstream Initial Teacher Training (ITT) 34,00036,400
Employment based ITT eg Graduate Teacher Programme; Teach First etc 15,40016,000
Golden Hellos and Training Bursaries54,800 58800
Pre-ITT subject enhancement; Specialist maths and science Higher Level Teaching Assistant programme; Secondary Shortage subject Scheme 10,50013,400
Student Associate Scheme7,925 5,588
TOTAL122,625 130,188

RETURN FOR INVESTMENT

  The schools National Strategies are continuing to spread effective teaching and learning in both mathematics and science through subject leader training and teaching materials. This year-on-year focus on improving standards in every classroom is reflected by the test results—in 2007, 73% of pupils achieved at least the expected level of attainment at key stage 3 in science and 41% achieve better—this is the highest ever level of achievement. In mathematics 76% of pupils are achieving at or above the expected level of attainment—up 16 percentage points from 1997.

  At GCSE, DCSF are seeing improvements in attainment with 55% of students achieving A*-C in mathematics (a rise of 12 percentage points since 1997) and 51% of students in science (a rise of seven percentage points since 1997).

  Entries at AS level in mathematics and further mathematics saw a significant increase this year. In mathematics there were 5,209 more entries in 2007 than in 2006, bringing the number of young people taking the subject this year to 62,856. There were 4,874 entries for further mathematics, a rise of 796 since 2006. In addition entries for biology, chemistry and physics all rose.

  In 2007, for the first time in 10 years, there was an increase in the number of entries to A-Level physics. Entries in mathematics continued to rise significantly after a significant drop in 2002 and a levelling off over the next three years. DCSF have created a network of further mathematics centres to increase the number of young people taking further mathematics A level. The signs are encouraging with 7,241 taking the a level in 2007 compared with 5,192 in 2005.

  According to data from the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service (UCAS), there has also been an increase in undergraduates accepted to begin study in STEM subjects in 2007:

    —  Physics up 10.3%

    —  Chemistry up 8.8%

    —  Biology up 3.3%

    —  Mathematics up 9.2%

SCHOOL WORKFORCE

  Increased incentives for mathematics and science Postgraduate certificate in education (PGCE) students have also reaped rewards. Mathematics and science PGCE students have received a £9,000 training bursary since September 2006. In addition, a Golden Hello of £5,000 is available to new mathematics and science teachers on completion of their induction in schools and starting a permanent teaching job.

  Mathematics recruitment statistics (both conventional and employment-based routes) from 1997-98 to 2006-07 show a 56% increase in mathematics recruitment over the period. Figures released on 12 November show that the number of trainee science teachers recruited has reached more than 3,000 for the first time with increases in the number choosing physics, chemistry and biology initial teacher training courses for 2007-08.

PLANS TO ENSURE FUTURE RETURN FOR THE INVESTMENT

  To ensure value for money and a return for this investment DCSF will be implementing the actions from the STEM Programme Report (published by the Department for Education and Science (DfES) and the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) in October 2006). This work is overseen by a High Level Strategy group chaired jointly by Ruth Thompson (Director General, Higher Education at DIUS) and Ralph Tabberer (Director General, Schools, in DCSF). The aim is to maximise the impact of investment by Government, private organisations and third sector organisations, by agreeing priorities and aligning funding streams with partners, helping them to target activities better at schools, colleges and universities that will benefit most. DCSF are planning to co-ordinate CPD and enhancement and enrichment activities, sign-posting where schools can go to get the support they need. DCSF are agreeing an evaluation framework so that everything will be measured.

  Success in the longer term will be defined in terms of students' attainment and engagement in STEM subjects. In the shorter term, success will be measured in terms of the range of schools, colleges and students engaged in STEM support, and the commitment of funders and other stakeholders to working within the proposed STEM framework. It is proposed that an evaluation should be carried out of the overall STEM package.

Question 134 (Mr Ian Davidson):   Decline of the relative proportion—from 2002-03 to 2005-06—of socio-economic groups 4 to 7 as a proportion of the whole population

  The table below shows that the percentage of the working population who are in employment from lower socio-economic groups has decreased from 48.4% in 2001 to 45.6% in 2006.

Percentage of the working population from lower socio-economic groups1

ENGLAND
Year2001 200220032004 20052006
48.447.7 47.346.846.5 45.6


Source: Labour Force Survey.

1  The percentage is the number of people in the working population from National Statistics Socio-Economic Classification (NS-SEC) Classes 4-7 expressed as a percentage of the number from NS-SEC Classes 1-7; People classed as unemployed/never worked are not considered.

  The percentage decreased by 2.8 percentage points over the period 2001-06.

  Table 30 in the NAO report contains the percentages of the relevant student population (of UK domiciled entrants of all ages to full-time first degree courses) from NS-SEC 4-7 ie the number of students from NS-SEC 4-7 expressed as a percentage of students from NS-SEC 1-7.

  The percentages of the working population and the student population are not directly comparable and for the student population, the percentages are often limited to young (aged under 21) entrants to full-time first degree courses from NS-SEC 4-7.

  The percentages are limited in this way for several reasons, including the following:

    —  Almost all of the young entrants to full-time first degree courses applied through UCAS, where information on parental occupation is recorded and subsequently used for NS-SEC, so coverage of these students is reasonably good.

    —  Many mature students do not apply through UCAS, and even if they do the applicants are not asked about parental occupation.

    —  NS-SEC for students under 21 is based on their parental occupation, while NS-SEC for mature students is based on their own occupation.

  Because of the mixture of definitions used, the figures in Table 30 are not easily interpreted. DfES Research Report 806 provides estimates of both student entrants, and the populations they come from by NS-SEC, with definitions that restrict entrants and populations to those young people for whom parental occupation is known.

Question 140 (Mr Ian Davidson):   Percentage of university entrants from public schools and state schools

  The available information on state school entrants to higher education comes from the Performance Indicators in Higher Education, published by the Higher Education Statistics Agency (HESA). This shows the proportion of UK-domiciled young (under 21) full-time first degree entrants who are from state schools. (Independent school proportions are not published, but can be taken as the remaining proportion of this student population.)

  The information is shown in the table below for UK institutions and for English institutions.

Percentage of UK-domiciled young entrants to full-time first degree courses who are from state schools


1998-99 1999-20002000-01 2001-022002-03 2003-042004-05 2005-06
UK85.0 84.985.7 86.087.2 86.886.7 87.4
England84.4 84.185.0 85.286.4 86.185.9 86.9


School type is taken from previous institution attended. All schools or colleges that are not denoted "independent" are assumed to be state schools. This means that students from sixth-form or further education colleges, for example, are included as being from state schools—Source: "Performance Indicators in Higher Education", published by HESA.

  The proportion of the 18 year old population attending different types of school is shown in the table below. Because each of these figures represent a single cohort of students, they are not directly comparable to the state school performance indicator above, which covers entrants whose ages range up to 20 years.

18 year old population who attended school, split by school type
Age 18 as at JanuaryEntering HE in State secondaryIndependent CTCAll % independent
19991999-2000129,120 34,5651,395165,080 20.9
20002000-01129,990 33,3851,640165,015 20.2
20012001-02134,395 33,5501,670169,615 19.8
20022002-03133,805 33,6551,420168,880 19.9
20032003-04137,765 34,8701,795174,435 20.0
20042004-05140,970 35,3201,940178,230 19.8


CTC: City Technology College.

Figures cover England only.

Numbers are rounded to the nearest 5.

Source: "Statistics of Education, Schools in England", published by DfES.

Question 160 (Mr Alan Williams):   Graduate Premium

  The graduate earnings premium reflects the relative earnings position of graduates compared to other workers in the economy, and is a measure of the financial reward of a degree. Currently calculations of the graduate premium tend to show the extra earnings that a graduate gets over their working life as compared with what they would have earned had they not gone into higher education and stopped their education at A-levels. It can be presented net of tax, or gross. It is usually discounted to be in today's valuation, which is the normal practice for investment decisions which will yield a return in the future; this is done by using a HM Treasury discount factor of 3.5%, which gives a present value in today's terms. The main data source used for calculations of the graduate premium is the Labour Force Survey.

  Some initial calculations (around 2001) gave the lifetime earnings benefits of doing a degree for graduates as around £400,000. However, this compared the earnings of graduates with the population as a whole (which included graduates as well as those with lower level or no qualifications) and it was not discounted. Whilst the methodology underpinning the £400,000 figure was valid and robust on its own terms, it was felt a better comparison would be to look at the earnings of graduates compared with those who stop their education at A-levels—ie those at the next "level" down who could have probably gone on to higher education but do not. This is normally taken as those with two or more A-levels (ie NQF Level 3) which is the general entrance requirement for higher education.

  On this basis the former DfES did some further analysis (around 2002) which led to an estimate of the graduate premium of £120,000. The analysis underpinning the £120,000 figure was more advanced than the £400,000 estimate as it used econometric analysis to control for a range of background factors that affect earnings, independently of the qualification itself. This £120,000 figure remained the most up-to-date estimate at the time Mr Williams asked the PQ referred to in the discussion (PQ 140797, Official Report, 8 December 2003, column 285W).

  In 2005, the Class of 99 report indicated that increases in graduate salaries may have been slowing slightly—this was comparing their findings for a cohort of 1999 graduates with those from a similar exercise a few years earlier for a cohort of 1995 graduates. Whilst this research did not entail a calculation of the graduate premium (it just looked at the increase in graduate earnings) it raised the possibility (albeit only tentatively) that the premium may have fallen slightly.

  At the same time, there were other calculations of the graduate premium in use which used different datasets and/or slightly different methods. For example, in July 2005 O'Leary and Sloane—in a study entitled: The return to a university education in Great Britain—found the lifetime earnings premium (net of taxes) was £141,539 for males and £157,928 for females.

  Having a range of sources all coming to similar conclusions was helpful, but meant that citing a single figure was not the best approach and could give a spurious impression of accuracy—eg the estimate could vary slightly simply by using different time periods for the data. The Department remains confident that there is a significant graduate premium, but felt it would be more appropriate to express it in the form of a range or as being above a certain value. This led the Department to change its standard line on the graduate premium, which explains the move from "£120,000" to "comfortably over £100,000".

  Most recent research has confirmed the persistence and the scale of the graduate premium, so DIUS have maintained the current line. The latest external report published on the subject was by PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) in early 2007, in a report for Universities UK: The economic benefits of a degree. This gave the graduate premium as being around £160,000 gross. Other work by PwC has noted that this equates to around £110,000 after tax.

  None of the figures in play have netted off National Insurance contributions.

  DIUS is currently doing some analysis to up-date the estimate of the graduate premium using some more recent Labour Force Survey data, and making some refinements to the methodology to reflect current academic practice and thinking.

Question 161 (Mr Richard Bacon):   Applications by individual subjects (independent and state school entrants)

  The following tables show applications for higher education places, sorted by the applications from independent schools and by the applications from maintained schools.

UCAS applications from UK domiciled students by subject (2006 entry)

LISTED BY PERCENTAGE OF APPLICATIONS FROM INDEPENDENT SCHOOLS

Subject
Previous school type
Percentage of known applications from:
Independent MaintainedTotal known Unknown Total Independent Maintained
Q6—Latin studies 2518 431 4458.1 41.2
Q8—Classical studies 2,8952,256 5,151163 5,31456.2 43.8
Q7—Classical Greek studies 22 4 450.0 50.0
R0—European Languages Literature and related: any area 713942 1,65542 1,69743.1 56.9
V3—History by Topic 2,1732,927 5,100304 5,40442.6 57.4
T1—Chinese studies 267365 63255 68742.2 57.8
Q4—Ancient Language studies 1628 443 4736.4 63.6
T9—Others in non-European Languages and related 1,0941,997 3,09171 3,16235.4 64.6
R7—Russian and East European studies 78158 23658 29433.0 67.0
R4—Spanish studies 5591,230 1,78986 1,87531.2 68.8
R3—Italian studies 85201 28622 30829.7 70.3
L0—Social Studies: any area of study 6571,589 2,246116 2,36229.2 70.8
J2—Metallurgy 820 281 2928.6 71.4
L7—Human and Social Geography 3,90210,025 13,927336 14,26328.0 72.0
RR—Combinations within European Languages, Literature and related 2,6497,155 9,804328 10,13227.0 73.0
L6—Anthropology 7952,206 3,001188 318926.5 73.5
V5—Philosophy 2,0745,844 7,918448 8,36626.2 73.8
L1—Economics 6,02717,044 23,0711,113 24,18426.1 73.9
A1—Pre-clinical Medicine 12,68036,510 49,19011,043 60,23325.8 74.2
V6—Theology and Religious studies 1,3213,993 5,314435 5,74924.9 75.1
Q9—Others in Linguistics, Classics and related 67205 27252 32424.6 75.4
Y—Combinations of languages 1,6755,487 7,162407 7,56923.4 76.6
A2—Pre-clinical Dentistry 1,8976,239 8,1361,072 9,20823.3 76.7
TT—Combinations within non-European Languages and related 36119 15520 17523.2 76.8
G0—Mathematical & Computer Science: any area 76253 3299 33823.1 76.9
D1—Pre-clinical Veterinary Medicine 8883,075 3,963477 4,44022.4 77.6
D9—Others in Veterinary Science, Agriculture and related subjects 2587 1124 11622.3 77.7
T6—Modern Middle-Eastern studies 95346 441107 54821.5 78.5
N0—Business and Administrative studies: any area 50183 23310 24321.5 78.5
J1—Minerals Technology 1452 661 6721.2 78.8
LL—Combinations within Social Studies 2,3768,927 11,303824 12,12721.0 79.0
L2—Politics3,770 14,35818,128 1,27319,401 20.879.2
V1—History by Period 8,80933,683 42,4921,657 44,14920.7 79.3
T2—Japanese studies 128490 61874 69220.7 79.3
Y—Combinations of social studies/business/law with languages 2,3879,274 11,661768 12,42920.5 79.5
H5—Naval Architecture 46184 23023 25320.0 80.0
D7—Agricultural Sciences 2498 1228 13019.7 80.3
R1—French studies 7403,063 3,803158 3,96119.5 80.5
R9—Others in European Languages, Literature and related 4641,983 2,447189 2,63619.0 81.0
Z—Combinations of 3 subjects, or other general courses 2,62311,298 13,9211,299 15,22018.8 81.2
Y—Combinations of engineering/technology/building studies 93405 49834 53218.7 81.3
VV—Combinations within History and Philosophical studies 1,2595,535 6,794311 7,10518.5 81.5
K4—Planning (Urban, Rural and Regional) 6152,809 3,424242 3,66618.0 82.0
H7—Production and Manufacturing Engineering 6282,883 3,511160 3,67117.9 82.1
V0—History and Philosophical studies: any area 92426 51840 55817.8 82.2
J6—Maritime Technology 67311 37833 41117.7 82.3
H8—Chemical, Process and Energy Engineering 7533,526 4,279200 4,47917.6 82.4
R2—German studies 2171,027 1,24443 1,28717.4 82.6
T5—African studies 1678 9412 10617.0 83.0
J5—Materials Technology not otherwise spec 80397 47742 51916.8 83.2
D6—Food and Beverage studies 2171,078 1,295103 1,39816.8 83.2
Y—Combinations of engineering/technology 105524 62937 66616.7 83.3
D2—Clinical Veterinary Medicine and Dentistry 735 426 4816.7 83.3
J0—Technologies: any area of study 15 6 616.7 83.3
K1—Architecture 2,90514,578 17,4831,166 18,64916.6 83.4
H1—General Engineering 1,2926,623 7,915612 8,52716.3 83.7
F8—Physical and Terrestrial Geography, and Environmental Science 2,89915,001 17,900673 18,57316.2 83.8
N2—Management studies 8,11142,806 50,9173,739 54,65615.9 84.1
H3—Mechanical Engineering 2,79714,790 17,587982 18,56915.9 84.1
C7—Molecular Biology, Biophysics and Biochemistry 1,5388,148 9,686446 10,13215.9 84.1
V9—Others in History and Philosophical studies 41224 26527 29215.5 84.5
F2—Materials Science 211 131 1415.4 84.6
F6—Geology859 4,7835,642 2225,864 15.284.8
Y—Combinations of social studies/business/law with arts/humanities 5,41630,963 36,3792,624 39,00314.9 85.1
Q3—English studies 7,46542,718 50,1832,517 52,70014.9 85.1
T7—American studies 3902,254 2,644120 2,76414.7 85.3
Y—Combinations of social studies/law with business 1,97711,524 13,501903 14,40414.6 85.4
C1—Biology3,064 17,86620,930 94821,878 14.685.4
F1—Chemistry 2,52215,166 17,688531 18,21914.3 85.7
C3—Zoology762 4,6035,365 2825,647 14.285.8
J7—Industrial Biotechnology 28170 19818 21614.1 85.9
B5—Ophthalmics 6033,756 4,359384 4,74313.8 86.2
F3—Physics2,142 13,34515,487 38415,871 13.886.2
H2—Civil Engineering 1,79711,319 13,116886 14,00213.7 86.3
QQ—Combinations within Linguistics, Classics and related 3952,522 2,917169 3,08613.5 86.5
Y—Combinations of languages with arts/humanities 4,72330,933 35,6562,138 37,79413.2 86.8
V4—Archaeology 3392,306 2,645198 2,84312.8 87.2
C4—Genetics243 1,6791,922 1132,035 12.687.4
FF—Combinations within Physical Sciences 3062,145 2,45195 2,54612.5 87.5
G3—Statistics 56397 45336 48912.4 87.6
D4—Agriculture 3992,849 3,248452 3,70012.3 87.7
R6—Scandinavian studies 536 414 4512.2 87.8
A9—Others in Medicine and Dentistry 429 335 3812.1 87.9
H0—Engineering: any area of study 25182 20739 24612.1 87.9
H9—Others in Engineering 215 173 2011.8 88.2
H4—Aerospace Engineering 8906,792 7,682671 8,35311.6 88.4
G1—Mathematics 3,06923,525 26,594868 27,46211.5 88.5
F7—Ocean Sciences 83640 72353 77611.5 88.5
K3—Landscape Design 64495 55967 62611.4 88.6
W3—Music2,411 18,65421,065 1,85322,918 11.488.6
B2—Pharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmacy 2,10916,618 18,7272,113 20,84011.3 88.7
HH—Combinations within Engineering 2171,750 1,967149 2,11611.0 89.0
N3—Finance340 2,7953,135 3513,486 10.889.2
B1—Anatomy, Physiology and Pathology 2,84423,385 26,2292,764 28,99310.8 89.2
M1—Law by Area 7,24861,724 68,9724,286 73,25810.5 89.5
NN—Combinations within Business and Administrative Studies 3,08926,879 29,9682,338 32,30610.3 89.7
D0—Veterinary Science,Agriculture and related: any area of study 19 10 1010.0 90.0
Y—Combinations of medical/biological/agricultural sciences 1,0759,844 10,919738 11,6579.8 90.2
P1—Information Services 34313 34729 3769.8 90.2
Y—Combinations of physics/mathematical sciences 2622,572 2,834106 2,9409.2 90.8
Y—Combinations of physics/mathematical science with social studies/business/law 1,31212,927 14,239916 15,1559.2 90.8
N1—Business studies 4,10640,697 44,8033,205 48,0089.2 90.8
F9—Others in Physical Sciences 2762,765 3,041223 3,2649.1 90.9
N5—Marketing 1,26112,707 13,9681,055 15,0239.0 91.0
DD—Combinations within Veterinary Science, Agriculture and related subjects 991 10012 1129.0 91.0
KK—Combinations within Architecture, Building and Planning 62633 69561 7568.9 91.1
CC—Combinations within Biological Sciences 2312,371 2,602133 2,7358.9 91.1
Q1—Linguistics 2332,407 2,640164 2,8048.8 91.2
K2—Building1,069 11,13712,206 1,36013,566 8.891.2
Q2—Comparative Literary studies 52550 60254 6568.6 91.4
C8—Psychology 5,92263,427 69,3494,153 73,5028.5 91.5
X9—Others in Education 26285 31177 3888.4 91.6
Y—Combs of science/engineering with social studies/business/law 2,19724,087 26,2842,017 28,3018.4 91.6
Y—Combs of sciences with engineering/technology 4234,693 5,116417 5,5338.3 91.7
C9—Others in Biological Sciences 1431,597 1,740142 1,8828.2 91.8
F5—Astronomy 55621 67640 7168.1 91.9
L3—Sociology 1,53517,607 19,1421,578 20,7208.0 92.0
B9—Others in Subjects allied to Medicine 2,16625,023 27,1893,504 30,6938.0 92.0
C5—Microbiology 1151,331 1,446102 1,5487.9 92.1
W4—Drama3,014 35,82838,842 4,18043,022 7.892.2
JJ—Combinations within Technology 112 131 147.7 92.3
B6—Aural and Oral Sciences 4535,444 5,897810 6,7077.7 92.3
Y—Combinations of medical/biological/agricultural sciences with physics/mathematical sciences 3945,168 5,562416 5,9787.1 92.9
Y—Combinations of social studies/law 6538,581 9,234666 9,9007.1 92.9
V2—History by Area 29386 41535 4507.0 93.0
H6—Electronic and Electrical Engineering 94812,814 13,7621,318 15,0806.9 93.1
Y—Combinations of science/engineering with arts/humanities/languages 1,85825,813 27,6711,976 29,6476.7 93.3
N9—Others in Business and Administrative Studies 1101,546 1,656154 1,8106.6 93.4
Y—Combinations of physics/mathematical science with arts/humanities/languages 7019,929 10,630826 11,4566.6 93.4
D3—Animal Science 3034,315 4,618452 5,0706.6 93.4
T3—South Asian studies 458 6213 756.4 93.6
G7—Artificial Intelligence 23335 35829 3876.4 93.6
P4—Publishing 25372 39737 4346.3 93.7
K9—Others in Architecture, Building and Planning 8121 12912 1416.2 93.8
C6—Sports Science 2,62141,060 43,6812,300 45,9816.0 94.0
P9—Others in Mass Communications and Documentation 1933,025 3,218241 3,4596.0 94.0
G9—Others in Mathematical and Computer Sciences 18283 30117 3186.0 94.0
N7—Office Skills 232 347 415.9 94.1
B4—Nutrition 2433,893 4,136578 4,7145.9 94.1
BB—Combinations within Subjects allied to Medicine 58931 989109 1,0985.9 94.1
G2—Operational Research 697 1039 1125.8 94.2
L9—Others in Social Studies 57930 987146 1,1335.8 94.2
GG—Combinations within Mathematical and Computer Science 3325,482 5,814350 6,1645.7 94.3
WW—Combinations within Creative Arts and Design 68611,354 12,0401,120 13,1605.7 94.3
D5—Forestry12 200212 55267 5.794.3
N4—Accounting 1,31122,013 23,3241,622 24,9465.6 94.4
MM—Combinations within Law 1031,819 1,922104 2,0265.4 94.6
N6—Human Resource Management 1402,611 2,751255 3,0065.1 94.9
T4—Other Asian studies 119 203 235.0 95.0
W1—Fine Art764 14,88415,648 1,31516,963 4.995.1
N8—Tourism, Transport and Travel 56511,055 11,6201,137 12,7574.9 95.1
J9—Others in Technology 2494,947 5,196543 5,7394.8 95.2
J4—Polymers and Textiles 701,391 1,461135 1,5964.8 95.2
C0—Biological Sciences: any area of study 120 210 214.8 95.2
Y—Combinations of arts/humanities 75715,889 16,6461,352 17,9984.5 95.5
P2—Publicity studies 861,887 1,973155 2,1284.4 95.6
F4—Forensic and Archaeological Science 3307,372 7,702442 8,1444.3 95.7
L4—Social Policy 1483,359 3,507432 3,9394.2 95.8
F0—Physical Sciences: any area of study 18431 44964 5134.0 96.0
M9—Others in Law 3568,784 9,140587 9,7273.9 96.1
B3—Complementary Medicine 551,381 1,436438 1,8743.8 96.2
P3—Media studies 81720,546 21,3631,468 22,8313.8 96.2
PP—Combinations within Mass Communications and Documentation 1964,934 5,130427 5,5573.8 96.2
G4—Computer Science 1,65142,630 44,2813,170 47,4513.7 96.3
W6—Cinematics and Photography 87322,888 23,7612,199 25,9603.7 96.3
G5—Information Systems 47012,506 12,9761,091 14,0673.6 96.4
W2—Design studies 1,98453,947 55,9314,391 60,3223.5 96.5
P5—Journalism 3329,102 9,434606 10,0403.5 96.5
X1—Training Teachers 1,53442,815 44,3493,887 4,82363.5 96.5
M2—Law by Topic 1734,848 5,021410 5,4313.4 96.6
W9—Others in Creative Arts and Design 371,038 1,075123 1,1983.4 96.6
X3—Academic studies in Education 58417,067 17,6511,975 19,6263.3 96.7
W8—Imaginative Writing 481,645 1,693209 1,9022.8 97.2
B7—Nursing1,282 47,06548,347 8,64756,994 2.697.4
B8—Medical Technology 2298,697 8,9261,619 10,5452.6 97.4
G6—Software Engineering 1275,086 5,213341 5,5542.4 97.5
W0—Creative Arts and Design: any area 9371 38032 4122.4 97.6
Q5—Celtic studies 16686 70259 7612.3 97.7
W5—Dance127 5,5785,705 4316,136 2.297.8
C2—Botany2 107109 4113 1.898.2
W7—Crafts23 1,6941,717 1971,914 1.398.7
L5—Social Work 50737,805 38,31213,646 51,9581.3 98.7
XX—Combinations within Education 10793 80377 8801.2 98.8
J3—Ceramics and Glass 03 33 60 100.0
K0—Architecture, Building and Planning: any area 021 212 230 100.0
R5—Portuguese studies 012 128 200 100.0
Z—Other courses not elsewhere classified 01 10 10 100.0
X2—Research and Study Skills in Education 00 04 40 0
GRAND TOTAL 195,1331,555,401 1,750,534150,291 1,900,82511.15 88.85

Each applicant can submit up to six applications to UCAS.

"Maintained schools" include comprehensive, grammar, sixth form centres, other maintained schools, sixth form colleges and FE/HE colleges.

UCAS applications from UK domiciled students by subject (2006 entry)

LISTED BY PERCENTAGE OF APPLICATIONS FROM MAINTAINED SCHOOLS
Subject
Previous school type
Percentage f known applications from:
Independent MaintainedTotal known Unknown Total Independent Maintained
K0—Architecture, Building and Planning: any area 021 212 230 100.0
R5—Portuguese studies 012 128 200 100.0
J3—Ceramics and Glass 03 33 60 100.0
Z—Other courses not elsewhere classified 01 10 10 100.0
XX—Combinations within Education 10793 80377 8801.2 98.8
L5—Social Work 50737,805 38,31213,646 51,9581.3 98.7
W7—Crafts23 1,69417,17 1971,914 1.398.7
C2—Botany2 107109 4113 1.898.2
W5—Dance127 5,5785,705 4316,136 2.297.8
Q5—Celtic studies 16686 70259 7612.3 97.7
W0—Creative Arts and Design: any area 9371 38032 4122.4 97.6
G6—Software Engineering 1275,086 5,213341 5,5542.4 97.6
B8—Medical Technology 2298,697 8,9261,619 10,5452.6 97.4
B7—Nursing1,282 47,06548,347 8,64756,994 2.697.4
W8—Imaginative Writing 481,645 1,693209 1,9022.8 97.2
X3—Academic studies in Education 58417,067 17,6511,975 19,6263.3 96.7
W9—Others in Creative Arts and Design 371,038 1,075123 1,1983.4 96.6
M2—Law by Topic 1734,848 5,021410 5,4313.4 96.6
X1—Training Teachers 1,53442,815 44,3493,887 48,2363.5 96.4
P5—Journalism 3329,102 9,434606 10,0403.5 96.5
W2—Design studies 1,98453,947 55,9314,391 60,3223.5 96.5
G5—Information Systems 47012,506 12,9761,091 14,0673.6 96.4
W6—Cinematics and Photography 87322,888 23,7612,199 25,9603.7 96.3
G4—Computer Science 1,65142,630 44,2813,170 47,4513.7 96.3
PP—Combinations within Mass Communications and Documentation 1964,934 5,130427 5,5573.8 96.2
P3—Media studies 81720,546 21,3631,468 22,8313.8 96.2
B3—Complementary Medicine 551,381 1,436438 1,8743.8 96.2
M9—Others in Law 3568,784 9,140587 9,7273.9 96.1
F0—Physical Sciences: any area of study 18431 44964 5134.0 96.0
L4—Social Policy 1483,359 3,507432 3,9394.2 95.8
F4—Forensic and Archaeological Science 3307,372 7,702442 8,1444.3 95.7
P2—Publicity studies 861,887 1,973155 2,1284.4 95.6
Y—Combinations of arts/humanities 75715,889 16,6461,352 17,9984.5 95.5
C0—Biological Sciences: any area of study 120 210 214.8 95.2
J4—Polymers and Textiles 701,391 1,461135 1,5964.8 95.2
J9—Others in Technology 2494,947 5,196543 5,7394.8 95.2
N8—Tourism, Transport and Travel 56511,055 11,6201,137 12,7574.9 95.1
W1—Fine Art764 14,88415,648 1,31516,963 4.995.1
T4—Other Asian studies 119 203 235.0 95.0
N6—Human Resource Management 1402,611 2,751255 3,0065.1 94.9
MM—Combinations within Law 1031,819 1,922104 2,0265.4 94.6
N4—Accounting 1,31122,013 23,3241,622 24,9465.6 94.4
D5—Forestry12 200212 55267 5.794.3
WW—Combinations within Creative Arts and Design 68611,354 12,0401,120 13,1605.7 94.3
GG—Combinations within Mathematical and Computer Science 3325,482 5,814350 6,1645.7 94.3
L9—Others in Social Studies 57930 987146 1,1335.8 94.2
G2—Operational Research 697 1039 1125.8 94.2
BB—Combinations within Subjects allied to Medicine 58931 989109 1,0985.9 94.1
B4—Nutrition 2433,893 4,136578 4,7145.9 94.1
N7—Office Skills 232 347 415.9 94.1
G9—Others in Mathematical and Computer Science 18283 30117 3186.0 94.0
P9—Others in Mass Communications and Documentation 1933,025 3,218241 3,4596.0 94.0
C6—Sports Science 2,62141,060 43,6812,300 45,9816.0 94.0
K9—Others in Architecture, Building and Planning 8121 12912 1416.2 93.8
P4—Publishing 25372 39737 4346.3 93.7
G7—Artificial Intelligence 23335 35829 3876.4 93.6
T3—South Asian studies 458 6213 756.4 93.6
D3—Animal Science 3034,315 4,618452 5,0706.6 93.4
Y—Combinations of physics /mathematical science with arts/humanities/languages 7019,929 10,630826 11,4566.6 93.4
N9—Others in Business and Administrative Studies 1101,546 1,656154 1,8106.6 93.4
Y—Combinations of science/engineering with arts/humanities/languages 1,85825,813 27,6711,976 29,6476.7 93.3
H6—Electronic and Electrical Engineering 94812,814 13,7621,318 15,0806.9 93.1
V2—History by Area 29386 41535 4507.0 93.0
Y—Combinations of social studies/law 6538,581 9,234666 9,9007.1 92.9
Y—Combinations of medical/biological/agricultural sciences with physics/mathematical sciences 3945,168 5,562416 5,9787.1 92.9
B6—Aural and Oral Sciences 4535,444 5,897810 6,7077.7 92.3
JJ—Combinations within Technology 112 131 147.7 92.3
W4—Drama30,14 35,82838,842 4,18043,022 7.892.2
C5—Microbiology 1151,331 1,446102 1,5487.9 92.1
B9—Others in Subjects allied to Medicine 2,16625,023 27,1893,504 30,6938.0 92.0
L3—Sociology 1,53517,607 19,1421,578 20,7208.0 92.0
F5—Astronomy 55621 67640 7168.1 91.9
C9—Others in Biological Sciences 1431,597 1,740142 1,8828.2 91.8
Y—Combinations of sciences with engineering/technology 4234,693 5,116417 5,5338.3 91.7
Y—Combinations of science/engineering with social studies/business/law 2,19724,087 26,2842,017 28,3018.4 91.6
X9—Others in Education 26285 31177 3888.4 91.6
C8—Psychology 5,92263,427 69,3494,153 73,5028.5 91.5
Q2—Comparative Literary studies 52550 60254 6568.6 91.4
K2—Building1,069 11,13712,206 1,36013,566 8.891.2
Q1—Linguistics 2332,407 2,640164 2,8048.8 91.2
CC—Combinations within Biological Sciences 2312,371 2,602133 2,7358.9 91.1
KK—Combinations within Architecture, Building and Planning 62633 69561 7568.9 91.1
DD—Combinations within Veterinary Science,Agricultural and related subjects 991 10012 1129.0 91.0
N5—Marketing 1,26112,707 13,9681,055 15,0239.0 91.0
F9—Others in Physical Sciences 2762,765 3,041223 3,2649.1 90.9
N1—Business studies 4,10640,697 44,8033,205 48,0089.2 90.8
Y—Combinations of physics/mathematical science with social studies/business/law 1,31212,927 14,239916 15,1559.2 90.8
Y—Combinations of physics/mathematical sciences 2622,572 2,834106 2,9409.2 90.8
P1—Information Services 34313 34729 3769.8 90.2
Y—Combinations of medical/biological/agricultural sciences 1,0759,844 10,919738 11,6579.8 90.2
D0—Veterinary Sciences, Agriculture and related: any area of study 19 10 1010.0 90.0
NN—Combinations within Business and Administrative Studies 3,08926,879 29,9682,338 32,30610.3 89.7
M1—Law by Area 7,24861,724 68,9724,286 73,25810.5 89.5
B1—Anatomy, Physiology and Pathology 2,84423,385 26,2292,764 28,99310.8 89.2
N3—Finance340 2,7953,135 3513,486 10.889.2
HH—Combinations within Engineering 2171,750 1,967149 2,11611.0 89.0
B2—Pharmacology, Toxicology and Pharmacy 2,109166,18 18,7272,113 20,84011.3 88.7
W3—Music2411 18,65421,065 1,85322,918 11.488.6
K3—Landscape Design 64495 55967 62611.4 88.6
F7—Ocean Sciences 83640 72353 77611.5 88.5
G1—Mathematics 3,06923,525 26,594868 27,46211.5 88.5
H4—Aerospace Engineering 8906,792 7,682671 8,35311.6 88.4
H9—Others in Engineering 215 173 2011.8 88.2
H0—Engineering: any area of study 25182 20739 24612.1 87.9
A9—Others in Medicine and Dentistry 429 335 3812.1 87.9
R6—Scandinavian studies 536 414 4512.2 87.8
D4—Agriculture 3992,849 3,248452 3,70012.3 87.7
G3—Statistics 56397 45336 48912.4 87.6
FF—Combinations within Physical Sciences 3062145 245195 254612.5 87.5
C4—Genetics243 1,6791,922 1132,035 12.687.4
V4—Archaeology 3392,306 2,645198 2,84312.8 87.2
Y—Combinations of languages with arts/humanities 4,72330,933 35,6562,138 37,79413.2 86.8
QQ—Combinations within Linguistics, Classics and related 3952,522 2,917169 3,08613.5 86.5
H2—Civil Engineering 1,79711,319 13,116886 14,00213.7 86.3
F3—Physics2,142 13,34515,487 38415,871 13.886.2
B5—Ophthalmics 6033,756 4,359384 4,74313.8 86.2
J7—Industrial Biotechnology 28170 19818 21614.1 85.9
C3—Zoology762 4,6035,365 2825,647 14.285.8
F1—Chemistry 2,52215,166 17,688531 18,21914.3 85.7
C1—Biology3,064 17,86620,930 94821,878 14.685.4
Y—Combinations of social studies/law with business 1,97711,524 13,501903 14,40414.6 85.4
T7—American studies 3902,254 2,644120 2,76414.7 85.3
Q3—English studies 7,46542,718 50,1832,517 52,70014.9 85.1
Y—Combinations of social studies/business/law with arts/humanities 5,41630,963 36,3792,624 39,00314.9 85.1
F6—Geology859 4,7835,642 2225,864 15.284.8
F2—Materials Science 211 131 1415.4 84.6
V9—Others in History and Philosophical studies 41224 26527 29215.5 84.5
C7—Molecular Biology, Biophysics and Biochemistry 15,388,148 9,686446 1013215.9 84.1
H3—Mechanical Engineering 2,79714,790 17,587982 18,56915.9 84.1
N2—Management studies 8,11142,806 50,9173,739 54,65615.9 84.1
F8—Physical and Terrestrial Geography, and Environmental Sciences 2,89915,001 17,900673 18,57316.2 83.8
H1—General Engineering 1,2926,623 7,915612 85,2716.3 83.7
K1—Architecture 2,90514,578 17,4831,166 18,64916.6 83.4
D2—Clinical Veterinary Medicine and Dentistry 735 426 4816.7 83.3
J0—Technologies: any area of study 15 6 616.7 83.3
Y—Combinations of engineering/technology 105524 62937 66616.7 83.3
D6—Food and Beverage studies 2171,078 1,295103 1,39816.8 83.2
J5—Materials Technology not otherwise specified 80397 47742 51916.8 83.2
T5—African studies 1678 9412 10617.0 83.0
R2—German studies 2171,027 1,24443 1,28717.4 82.6
H8—Chemical, Process and Energy Engineering 7533,526 4,279200 4,47917.6 82.4
J6—Maritime Technology 67311 37833 41117.7 82.3
V0—History & Philosophical studies: any area 92426 51840 55817.8 82.2
H7—Production and Manufacturing Engineering 6282,883 3,511160 3,67117.9 82.1
K4—Planning (Urban, Rural and Regional) 6152,809 3424242 3,66618.0 82.0
VV—Combinations within History and Philosophical studies 1,2595,535 6,794311 7,10518.5 81.5
Y—Combinations of engineering/technology/building studies 93405 49834 53218.7 81.3
Z—Combinations of 3 subjects, or other general courses 2,62311,298 13,9211,299 15,22018.8 81.2
R9—Others in European Languages, Literature and related 4641,983 2,447189 2,63619.0 81.0
R1—French studies 7403,063 3,803158 3,96119.5 80.5
D7—Agricultural Sciences 2498 1228 13019.7 80.3
H5—Naval Architecture 46184 23023 25320.0 80.0
Y Combinations of social studies/business/law with languages 2,3879,274 11,661768 12,42920.5 79.5
T2—Japanese studies 128490 61874 69220.7 79.3
V1—History by Period 8,80933,683 42,4921,657 44,14920.7 79.3
L2—Politics3,770 14,35818,128 1,27319,401 20.879.2
LL—Combinations within Social Studies 2,3768,927 11,303824 12,12721.0 79.0
J1—Minerals Technology 1452 661 6721.2 78.8
N0—Business and Administrative studies: any area 50183 23310 24321.5 78.5
T6—Modern Middle-Eastern studies 95346 441107 54821.5 78.5
D9—Others in Veterinary Science, Agriculture and related subjects 2587 1124 11622.3 77.7
D1—Pre-clinical Veterinary Medicine 8883,075 3,963477 4,44022.4 77.6
G0—Mathematical and Computer Science: any area 76253 3299 33823.1 76.9
TT—Combinations within non-European Languages and related 36119 15520 17523.2 76.8
A2—Pre-clinical Dentistry 1,8976,239 8,1361,072 9,20823.3 76.7
Y Combinations of languages 1,6755,487 7,162407 7,56923.4 76.6
Q9—Others in Linguistics, Classics and related 67205 27252 32424.6 75.4
V6—Theology and Religious studies 1,3213,993 5,314435 5,74924.9 75.1
A1—Pre-clinical Medicine 12,68036,510 49,19011,043 60,23325.8 74.2
L1—Economics 6,02717,044 23,0711,113 24,18426.1 73.9
V5—Philosophy 2,0745,844 7,918448 8,36626.2 73.8
L6—Anthropology 7952,206 3,001188 3,18926.5 73.5
RR—Combinations within European Languages, Literature and related 2,6497,155 9,804328 10,13227.0 73.0
L7—Human and Social Geography 3,90210,025 13,927336 14,26328.0 72.0
J2—Metallurgy 820 281 2928.6 71.4
L0—Social Studies: any area of study 6571,589 2,246116 2,36229.2 70.8
R3—Italian studies 85201 28622 30829.7 70.3
R4—Spanish studies 5591,230 1,78986 1,87531.2 68.8
R7—Russian and East European studies 78158 23658 29433.0 67.0
T9—Others in non-European Languages and related 1,0941,997 3,09171 3,16235.4 64.6
Q4—Ancient Language studies 1628 443 4736.4 63.6
T1—Chinese studies 267365 63255 68742.2 57.8
V3—History by Topic 2,1732,927 5,100304 5,40442.6 57.4
R0—European Languages, Literature and related: any area 713942 1,65542 169743.1 56.9
Q7—Classical Greek studies 22 40 450.0 50.0
Q8—Classical studies 2,8952,256 5,151163 5,31456.2 43.8
Q6—Latin studies 2518 431 4458.1 41.2
X2—Research and Study Skills in Education 00 04 40 0
GRAND TOTAL 195,1331,555,401 1,750,534150,291 1,900,82511.15 88.85

Each applicant can submit up to six applications to UCAS.

"Maintained schools" include comprehensive, grammar, sixth form centres, other maintained schools, sixth form colleges and FE/HE colleges.

Q163 (Chairman):   Problem for students with disabilities accessing the Disabled Students' Allowances (DSAs)

  The DSAs are widely publicised in all DIUS student finance literature (forms, guides and websites, etc) and disabled students are encouraged to apply. But DSAs are not quota based: they are awarded according to the student's individual needs for the particular course they are taking, following a specialist assessment. It would be unlikely that in individual higher education institutions there would be the same proportion of students receiving DSAs or that the proportion of full-time students receiving DSAs would be the same as the proportion of part-time students receiving them.

  Following the Review of Higher Education Student Finance Delivery in England (January 2006), Ministers to took the decision to centralise and transform the Student Finance Service, including the administration of DSAs. The new centralised service, which will be rolled out to new students entering higher education in the 2009-10 academic year, will include a dedicated team to support students applying for targeted support and will deliver an improved and consistent customer experience for all students. Local Authorities will continue to administer the service for returning students until 2011-12 when all students move to the new system.

  However, anything that can be done to ensure DSAs are taken up by all eligible students is to be welcomed. HEFCE has said it will commission research into how far the apparent differences between institutions in students' receipt of DSAs reflect eligible students missing out on their entitlement. DIUS will give careful consideration to any recommendations that the Funding Council makes as a result of this research.

Q163 (Chairman):   How the tuition fees are expected to affect retention

  There are no figures currently available for student retention in 2006-07, the first academic year in which the fees regime created under the Education Act 2004 applied to new full-time undergraduate students.

  The new system of variable fees is designed to ease financial pressures on full-time students by removing the requirement for up-front payment of fees, and replacing this by repayments of an interest-free fee loan from salary after graduation; introducing a means tested maintenance grant; and requiring institutions to provide bursaries for students if they propose to charge more than the basic fee. It is therefore possible that the impact of the new fees regime on retention rates will be positive, although DIUS would not expect to see strong effects because financial pressures are identified as only one of a range of the most commonly cited reasons for withdrawal.

  The published terms of reference for the independent Commission that will evaluate the impact of the first three years of the new fees regime include the consideration of their impact on retention rates.

Q165 (Chairman)— The reason for setting the target that 50% of 18 to 30 year olds should have participated in higher education

  The long-term aim that half of all young people should enter higher education was proposed in the Government's general election manifesto in 2001, and was enshrined in a Public Service Agreement (PSA) target from 2002. The adoption of such a rounded figure was indeed "aspirational", and also motivational. In saying that half of 18-30 year olds should enter higher education,[15] the Government has been seeking to send a clear signal to educators, employers, parents and young people themselves that higher education can no longer be the preserve of a relatively small minority of the population.

  A 50% participation rate is not notably high by international standards. International comparisons are complex because of different measurements used in different national systems. However, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) has presented comparisons based on their own measure of participation (sum of net entry rate for each year of age) showing data for 1998 and 2005.

  This OECD analysis breaks Higher education (HE) participation into two categories. It shows that the proportion of UK young people entering "academic" tertiary education is "mid-table" for full-length HE degree courses ("Type A" in the international classification). For "vocational" tertiary education ("Type B" in the international classification) the UK was in fifth place among the 17 countries in 2005. It is significant that a number of other OECD countries have grown HE participation over the period.

  In addition the 50% target supports the Leitch ambition that over 40% of the population aged 19 to state pension age should be qualified to Level 4 or above by 2020. The Leitch Report made a powerful case for the national need to raise the skill levels in our population. There are an increasing number of jobs and opportunities that need higher level skills: labour market projections suggest that 18 million jobs will become vacant between 2004 and 2020, and that half of them will be in the occupations most likely to employ graduates.

  At present only 30% are qualified to Level 4 or above. To reach the Leitch ambition requires an increase of over four million people with higher level qualifications between now and 2020. To achieve that growth we will have to increase participation in HE by those already in the workforce and that is why the 50% indicator sits alongside the new indicator under the Skills PSA that the proportion of working age adults qualified to level 4 and above should reach 34% by 2011 and 36% by 2014.



NOTE:  Because of the OECD's calculation method for these data, it is not appropriate to add the rates for type A and type B together to derive an overall estimate for tertiary education.

Ruth Thompson

Department for Innovation, Universities and Skills

November 2006







15   The Higher Education Initial Participation Rate (HEIPR) is the sum of the HE initiall participation rates for individual ages between 17 and 30 inclusive. It roughly equates to the probability that a 17 year old will participate in higher education by age 30 given the age specific participation rates. Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 19 February 2008