Select Committee on Scottish Affairs First Report


4  Improving communication

24. The 2007 Pre-Budget Report said "The latest round of discussions on the North Sea fiscal regime with the oil and gas industry ended in September 2007. The Government is considering the conclusions from these discussions and will publish a consultation document examining the options for further action in due course".[78] Some commentators see the publication of the North Sea discussion paper as a positive step and view the formal consultation as building on a period of relatively informal consultation, where the policy areas and options that the Government would consider were not always clear.[79]

25. We are heartened by the positive moves by the Treasury to consult on the North Sea fiscal regime[80] and by the engagement of industry with that consultation. Both sides appear to see the ongoing process of consultation as constructive.[81] Previous discussions between the Treasury and the industry have identified a number of desirable features of any fiscal regime: simplicity, predictability, and recognition of the long-term nature of the industry and investment lead times.[82] We hope that these features will be taken into account as part of the ongoing consultation on the North Sea fiscal regime. However, in addition to these desirable features, other simple changes in approach could make a big difference. For example, the industry is keen to see a more joined-up approach from Government in the form of joint meetings with Energy ministers and Treasury ministers.[83] From an industry perspective it makes sense to join up policies across the whole industry, taking a holistic approach, and we do not see why Government should not approach it in the same way. We believe that the breadth of the current consultation is important as it cannot be sensible to look at only one or two elements; the whole fiscal regime needs to be examined and it is important to identify what the Treasury and the industry want from the fiscal regime. Only then can we start the tricky business of getting from here to there, while maximising recovery of the UK's natural resources.


78   H M Treasury, 2007 Pre-Budget Report and Comprehensive spend Review, paragraph 5.86 Back

79   http://www.ukbudget.co.uk/UKBudget2007/NorthSeaOilTax/budget07_oilandgasringfenceactivities.cfm Back

80   Ev 63 Back

81   Qq12 and 176 Back

82   H M Treasury, The North Sea Fiscal Regime: a discussion Paper, March 2007 Back

83   Q10 Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2007
Prepared 30 November 2007