Market Failure?: Can the traditional market survive? - Communities and Local Government Committee Contents


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 160 - 163)

TUESDAY 24 MARCH 2009

MR TIM HIRST, MR MALCOLM VEIGAS AND MR NICK RHODES

  Q160  Chair: Just to make sure we have got it, you are not suggesting that the Government should say: "You must do this", but would just say: "When you are considering this space in the middle of the town, think it could be used for: ... " and then give them a long list, which would include a market? Is that it?

  Mr Veigas: Basically, yes. It would not just simply be a planning or a transport process that you are asking the local authority to do; it is something that adds, in overall terms, value because it can make that space do something else, as well as being a transport route in any one particular situation. It is like using a lamp-post: a lamp-post is a lamp-post until you put a banner on it or until you put a back-lit advert on it, and then it becomes an income stream. The principle is pretty much the same, is it not, and I think that is what I am trying to say.

  Q161  Anne Main: You gave a wonderful list of markets, and I would love to go and see all of them, but they were all abroad. Do you think—and you probably could just sell yourself as a tourism officer for those places—we promote our markets enough? Would there be people sitting over in Amsterdam saying: "Gosh, I really have to go to Leicester/Bradford/Bolton market", because there are all those wonderful things on offer that you have just described over there?

  Mr Veigas: Yes, there would be, and in 2004 and in 2006 that is exactly what Bradford did; they installed a mile of market stalls and we got European traders from 12 or 15 different countries to come and trade there for four days. I think you asked whether or not traders go abroad. There is an organisation called "Traders Abroad" who do exactly that. So whilst we have got cohorts coming over here, predominantly at Christmas and for continental markets, we have the archetypal Englishman abroad in terms of a list of products that sit within continental-style markets in Florence, as an example, or in Rome.

  Q162  Anne Main: I was not really thinking of the market traders swapping; I was thinking of people visiting us as destinations. Are you happy that the markets in the UK are promoted enough for people to want to go to see them?

  Mr Veigas: No, I think we could do better with promotions, generally. If we were to better use the food TV station, that would be really useful—if we had our own TV station that would be even more useful. We are looking at aggregating up advertising revenue, so in the North West, for example, Wigan, Warrington, Bolton and Bury are coming together and using local advertising in television to try and increase footfall. The other thing is attaching it to food festivals, and that is where the tourism operation really starts to bring big dividends.

  Mr Rhodes: I think there are certainly pockets of good promotions within the markets industry, locally, but I think it is fair to say that nationally the industry is not very well promoted, for all sorts of different reasons, mainly finance, but it could certainly raise the profile by organisations coming together and actually promoting the markets industry as a whole. It is something that is very sorely missed.

  Mr Hirst: If I could just add, it is not just about the market promoting itself, either; I think it is thinking about—going back to Malcolm's point about using city centre space as animated space—the wider visitor economy. Markets are not pushed well on a UK basis but they are not marketed well even on a regional basis. So, to go hand-in-hand more with, say, tourism and the visitor economy operations across regional and sub-regional areas, there is no reason why markets, as much as other attractions or major events, could not be much more entwined in the way they promote what they do. I think the wider visitor economy is something the markets could make an impact on.

  Q163  Chair: Thank you very much indeed. We are doing our best, as you have seen, to promote markets and, hopefully, our report when it comes out will be another peg on which publicity can be hung. So we would be more than happy for everybody in their different localities, when the report comes out, to make as much mileage as possible out of it. Thank you very much for your contributions.

  Mr Veigas: Thank you.

  Chair: Thank you very much to Leicester for organising the whole day.







 
previous page contents

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2009
Prepared 23 July 2009