Market Failure?: Can the traditional market survive? - Communities and Local Government Committee Contents


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 232 - 239)

TUESDAY 31 MARCH 2009

MR STEPHEN DOUGLASS, MR CHRIS WROE AND MS TOT BRILL

  Q232  Chair: I understand we have got Mr Wroe for Westminster Council.

  Mr Wroe: Yes. Many apologies. I am a very last minute substitute for Councillor Astaire who is unfortunately out of his post at the moment.

  Q233  Chair: I am sorry to hear it. Send him our best wishes.

  Mr Wroe: Thank you.

  Q234  Chair: The same thing goes for you as for previous witnesses, do not feel obliged to "me too" if you agree with another witness. It is helpful if you elaborate. We have got your written submissions so you do not have to keep repeating your numbers and things that are in there. Obviously you are all three London markets. I think we have already appreciated from the witnesses we have had thus far that you are operating in a very different environment for all sorts of reasons from out-of-London markets. So you might want to concentrate on those aspects rather than where you are the same as the rest of the country. Are your markets thriving or declining? Is it some markets some way and some another? Could you tell us how many of the markets you run at a loss?

  Mr Douglass: I think, generally speaking, it is a mixed picture. I think what we have seen is a decline in traditional retail markets, but at the same time as that we have seen opportunities through specialist farmers' markets. We have also seen in recent years growth in private indoor markets. So I think what we have seen is the number of people who are market traders has remained stable. It is just that some of the on-street retail markets have undoubtedly been declining over a number of years. Looking at our statistics, that has slowed down recently, but certainly over the last 10 years or so there has been a dramatic fall in the numbers of people trading on traditional street markets.

  Q235  Sir Paul Beresford: Does that matter to Southwark?

  Mr Douglass: Yes, of course it matters. We think our street markets are very important to us in lots of ways, certainly in terms of vibrancy and public spaces.

  Q236  Sir Paul Beresford: So what are you doing about it?

  Mr Douglass: What we are doing about that is we are looking at seeking investment. I think there is an issue about reinvestment in those markets. That is not very easy to achieve in the current economic climate. We are looking at working with traders in terms of business development and business support. We are looking at improving the environment in street market areas and there are lots of actions we are taking. We have just done a fundamental review of the whole portfolio, working with the National Association of British Market Authorities, and that has set out some recommendations for the future that we are now looking at implementing. It is because of this decline that we have done this fundamental review.

  Ms Brill: I think the picture is the same as it is in Southwark, that it is patchy and it is variable. Markets have been changing over the years. The things that are sold have been changing. They are highly volatile. They react to changes in customers. So for us the fruit and vegetable traditional bits of the market have been in decline, but Golborne Road Market has recently become a success with the growth of a North African market there. We have recently set up one of London's few farmers' markets in the street and that is a reasonable success.

  Q237  Chair: Does that market happen once a week?

  Ms Brill: Yes.

  Q238  Chair: On a Saturday?

  Ms Brill: Yes.

  Q239  Sir Paul Beresford: Are markets important to Kensington and Chelsea?

  Ms Brill: Absolutely. First of all, because Portobello Market is an iconic market in London, so it is really very important to how we see ourselves, but they are important to the local communities. In North Kensington, which is a very deprived area, access to fresh fruit and food is really important. The farmers' market we have set up was set up specifically at the initiative of local ward members to regenerate an area that was kind of dead at the weekends.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2009
Prepared 23 July 2009