The Defence contribution to UK national security and resilience - Defence Committee Contents


1  Security and resilience


Our inquiry

1.  We announced our intention to inquire into the Ministry of Defence's contribution to the United Kingdom's national security and resilience on 2 April 2008. We set out to examine "how the MoD and the Armed Forces interact with other departments and agencies to ensure the safety and security of the UK".[1] We invited written evidence on MoD and UK Armed Forces' contributions and capabilities, as well as its co-ordination and co-operation with other government departments (OGDs). We took oral evidence from industry on 17 June 2008, from the Ministry of Defence (MoD), Home Office and Cabinet Office on 21 October 2008, and finally from the Commander-in-Chief, HQ Land Forces, along with a panel of maritime security stakeholders, on 27 January 2009. Our inquiry was also informed by several classified briefings and papers from the MoD and Armed Forces, for which we are grateful.

2.  We visited the Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (DSTL) at Porton Down on 2 October 2008, where the work of the Counter-Terrorism Science and Technology Centre was explained to us. As part of our visit to HM Naval Base Clyde at Faslane in December 2008, the role played by the Fleet Protection Group Royal Marines in defending both the strategic nuclear deterrent and vessels in transit along the Clyde was demonstrated.

PUBLIC SERVICE AGREEMENTS

3.  In terms of Government performance and accountability, national security and resilience straddles several current public service agreements. Public Service Agreement 26 ("Reduce the risk to the UK and its interests overseas from international terrorism") is perhaps the most obvious. The scope of national security is reflected in two other PSAs: 3 ("Ensure controlled, fair migration that protects the public and contributes to economic growth"), and 27 ("Lead the global effort to avoid dangerous climate change").

BALANCED SCORECARD

4.  The Ministry of Defence's 'Balanced Scorecard' is the vehicle by which it assesses its own performance against its departmental objectives. The MoD's contribution to UK national security and resilience is particularly covered by the following objectives:

We address each of these issues below.

The National Security Strategy

5.  In March 2008, the Government published The National Security Strategy of the United Kingdom: Security in an interdependent world (NSS). Although the publication was co-ordinated by the Cabinet Office, the Strategy's stated aim was "to set out how we will address and manage this diverse though interconnected set of security challenges and underlying drivers".[3] Chapter 4 of the NSS deals in part with the contribution of the Armed Forces to the overarching security policy of the UK.

THREATS AND RESPONSES

6.  The NSS lays out the fundamental security architecture for its approach to threats to UK security and resilience, acknowledging that the traditional boundaries between Government departments, and between concepts of foreign and domestic policy, no longer apply. Equally, the concept of 'threat' has changed with the development of non-state actors such as international terrorist organisations.

"In the past, the state was the traditional focus of foreign, defence and security policies, and national security was understood as dealing with the protection of the state and its vital interests from attacks by other states. Over recent decades, our view of national security has broadened to include threats to individual citizens and to our way of life, as well as to the integrity and interests of the state."[4]

7.  The definition of national security and resilience now, therefore, encompasses a wide range of threats, from traditional state-on-state aggression through terrorist groups to civil emergencies such as flooding or pandemics. It also encompasses a spectrum of capabilities and responses—not merely preventing or dealing with attacks or natural disasters ('security'), but also ensuring that vital services are maintained and life can continue as close to normal as possible ('resilience').

8.  A central plank of the Government's approach to national security is its Counter-Terrorism Strategy (CONTEST), an updated version of which was published on 24 March 2009. It aims "to reduce the risk to the UK from international terrorism so that people can go about their business freely and with confidence".[5] The strategy is built around what are described as the 4 'P's, Prevent, Pursue, Protect and Prepare. The MoD notes that it "provide[s] a range of support in each of these areas to a greater or lesser extent".[6]

PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY OF NATIONAL SECURITY

9.  Several committees are active in the scrutiny of national security issues. Table 1: Scrutiny of national security issues
Committee Area of scrutiny
Defence Committee The Defence Committee scrutinises the expenditure, administration and policy of the Ministry of Defence and its associated public bodies.

The MoD's responsibilities in the field of national security are the subject of this report.

Home Affairs Committee The Home Affairs Committee scrutinises the expenditure, administration and policy of the Home Office and its associated public bodies.

In November 2008, the Home Affairs Committee appointed a Sub-Committee to inquire into the Government's counter-terrorist strategy, Project CONTEST. Formed of four members of the Home Affairs Committee, the Sub-Committee has taken oral evidence on three occasions, from a range of witnesses in the national security field.

Intelligence and Security Committee The Intelligence and Security Committee examines the policy, administration and expenditure of the Security Service (MI5), the Secret Intelligence Service (MI6), Government Communications Headquarters, as well as the Joint Intelligence Committee and the Intelligence and Security Secretariat.

The Intelligence and Security Committee is a statutory committee, established under the Intelligence Services Act 1994. Although formed of eight MPs and a Peer, it is not a Committee of the House, reporting as it does to the Prime Minister. It produces an annual report, as well as inquiring into particular subjects as they arise.

Joint Committee on the National Security Strategy In a written statement of 22 July 2008, the Prime Minister announced his intention to "consult the parliamentary authorities and the Opposition through the usual channels about the establishment and terms of reference of a Joint Committee on the national security strategy comprising the Chairs of the key departmental Select Committees with an interest in national security, and other Members of Parliament and Peers with particular interests or experience".[7]

The Committee is yet to be appointed.

10.  Parliamentary scrutiny of national security issues is a developing area. Once stabilised, it remains to be seen precisely how responsibilities will be divided. The Joint Committee will need to work out how its intended role in examining the overall strategy in its successive iterations will connect with scrutiny by existing committees. Whatever happens, we as the Defence Committee will retain an interest and therefore reserve the right to inquire into related issues as and when they arise. We are pleased that the membership of the Joint Committee is planned to include our Chairman, which will help co-ordinate our own work with that of the new body. We believe that different elements of national security are likely to be best examined in detail by the relevant departmental committees, with the Joint Committee bringing their views together in a critique of the strategy overall.

CO-ORDINATION OF NATIONAL SECURITY

11.  The Cabinet Office plays an important co-ordinating role for national security, through the Civil Contingencies Secretariat and the Joint Intelligence Committee, while the Foreign and Commonwealth Office, through the Foreign Secretary's oversight of the Secret Intelligence Service (SIS), is also intimately involved. The Home Office houses the Office for Security and Counter-Terrorism, which manages the Government's policy on counter-terrorism. The MoD is represented by the Defence Intelligence Staff (DIS) on the JIC and in the Joint Terrorism Analysis Centre. In times of crisis, meetings are convened in 'Cabinet Office Briefing Room A' (COBRA).

12.  Ministerial involvement in national security takes place in the Ministerial Committee on National Security, International Relations and Development, which is chaired by the Prime Minister—or, in his absence, either the Home or Foreign Secretaries—attended by around 15 members of the Cabinet, and supported by a Cabinet Office secretariat.[8] Lord West of Spithead is the Parliamentary Under-Secretary for Security and Counter-terrorism in the Home Office. However, none of these ministers, save the Prime Minister (at least notionally) is responsible for national security overall.[9] We expect the creation of a Joint Committee to improve Parliament's scrutiny of the NSS by bringing them together. However, the question of from which minister the new Joint Committee will take evidence is unclear, unless it is the Prime Minister, calls on whose time are many. We are concerned that this generates two problems: first, that co-ordination at the political level might not be as good as it could be, and secondly, that it only reaches the top of the in-tray in times of crisis. There are various views about the value of the appointment of a National Security Adviser reporting to the Cabinet. We request that the Government sets out its thinking on the matter in its response.


1   'Defence Committee inquiry into UK national security and resilience', Defence Committee Press Release, 2 April 2008 Back

2   Ministry of Defence, Annual Report and Accounts 2007-08, HC 850-II, Annex D, p 389 Back

3   Cabinet Office, The National Security Strategy of the United Kingdom: Security in an interdependent world, Cm 7291, March 2008, para 1.4 Back

4   Ibid., para 1.5 Back

5   Ev 67 Back

6   ibid.  Back

7   HC Deb, 22 July 2008, Col 111WS Back

8   http://www.cabinetoffice.gov.uk/secretariats/committees/nsid.aspx Back

9   Q 81; the Home Office leads on counter-terrorism aspects of national security, but this is but part of the wider national security picture. Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2009
Prepared 18 May 2009