DR 348: Letter to the Chairman of the Committee from Sir Peter Ricketts KCMG, Permanent Under Secretary of State, Foreign and Commonwealth Office

 

 

I am writing to update you on the latest FCO management issues. This letter covers the period April to June 2009.

 

passport operations

 

As part of a project to reduce the running costs of our overseas passport operation, the FCO has streamlined its passport services in Australasia, North America, Western Europe and Northern Europe.  Regional passport production centres (PPCs) have been established in Washington, Paris, Madrid, Dusseldorf and Wellington.  Future plans in this financial year include expanding the North America centre and establishing PPCs in Southern and Eastern Africa, South East Asia and the Middle East and Gulf regions.  The FCO anticipates substantial long term savings as a result of rationalisation, as well as improved customer service and greater consistency across the network.

 

2008-09 resource accounts and departmental report

 

On 30 June, the Resource Accounts and Departmental Report were laid before Parliament. The FCO was the first main Whitehall department to lay its accounts, for the second year running, and the first to lay a combined Departmental Report and set of accounts. In terms of the main administration and programme budget, the real achievement was a £2.4m underspend (0.14%), which is significantly below the 1% target set by the Board at the start of the financial year. This is concrete evidence that the Five Star Finance programme is delivering sustained improvement throughout the year in our financial management.

 

national audit office (nao) report on financial management in the fco

 

This report was published in June. The press release stated: 'The Foreign and Commonwealth Office has made good progress in its financial management, aiming to establish itself as one of the best Departments in Whitehall in this respect.' The report concluded that we have shown strong leadership in raising the profile of good financial management and that we have improved the accuracy, reliability and timeliness of internal and external financial information. In relation to the Five Star Finance programme, the NAO endorsed our assessment of three and a half stars, recognising that we face unique financial challenges because of our global operations, especially in relation to the measures we have taken to manage currency exposure, following the withdrawal of Treasury protection from exchange rate fluctuations. The report also noted a number of areas-greater professionalisation, underspend, strengthening the link between business planning and resource allocation-where we either have taken, or are taking, action.

Top Risks Register  

 

When updated in July, the Top Risks Register included five operational risks (physical security, resources, internal financial controls, IT systems, UKBA) and ten strategic risks (terrorist attack, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Middle East, global economic crisis, Horn of Africa, Overseas Territories, nuclear proliferation and Sudan). The Board also discussed individual risks in depth at its monthly meetings, most recently the global economic crisis (May) and Overseas Territories (June).

 

Business Planning/Departmental Strategic Objectives (DSO) and Public Service Agreement (PSA) Monitoring

 

Final assessments of progress in 2008-09 against our DSOs and the PSA on which the FCO leads (Conflict Reduction) were published in our 2009 Departmental Report.  The Board also held its internal end-year reviews of DSO, Geographic and, for the first time, Corporate Business Plans during June.  We feel this process is improving each time we do it.  We agreed to keep the same format for future reviews but to look at ways to make the questions more challenging and even more focussed on metrics.         

 

A NAO report on PSA30 data systems was published on 10 June.  The report stated that the FCO had made good progress in identifying robust systems for these indicators and that these afforded a reasonable view of performance against this PSA. 

 

Cost recovery

 

We have been working to improve the arrangements for charging full economic costs to other Government Departments, all have now signed up to the new Service Level Agreement which governs the terms under which we provide support and services to them and their staff based in FCO posts.  Negotiations with the Metropolitan Police and some others to secure agreement are continuing.

 

Activity Recording

 

100% of the fourth quarter's activity recording data was successfully collected to meet the deadlines set for the costing data and for producing the FCO Accounts for 2008/09. The accuracy of the data has improved, with fewer inconsistencies, but the system for collection on Excel spreadsheets is labour-intensive and we are looking at ways to simplify the process as much as possible. 

 

Corporate Services

 

The Corporate Services Programme (launched in December 2008) aims to simplify, standardise and streamline our corporate policies, processes and tools. The Programme will deliver over three years in five areas: localising more of our currently UK-based management officer jobs overseas; further outsourcing of facilities management (since December, 14 overseas posts in Europe have switched over to a new facilities management contract for the UK and NW Europe); consolidating more of our corporate services functions in country and regional networks (as we have begun in the United States) ; and consolidating some of our corporate services in the UK at a Corporate Services Centre in central Milton Keynes to drive efficiency and better service through better technology and greater self-service for staff.

 

Estates

 

On 1 June we created one unified team under the direction of a new Director of Estates, Security and Facilities Management, Alan Croney. Alan comes with many years of experience in estate management, most recently as Director of Property Services for the Metropolitan Police. His appointment, which followed an external recruitment competition, will allow us to improve the existing links between our estates, security and facilities management functions. I have asked him to take a critical look at the FCO's management of our estate and supporting functions and report back to the FCO Board in the autumn. I will keep the Committee informed.

 

As part of our investment in the UK estate, we have completed a reorganisation and refurbishment of the rooms occupied by the FCO Press Office, including a new room for press conferences, media briefings and similar events in the FCO Main Building. The new facility will allow us to better cater to a range of media events and meetings, both for the FCO and No.10, allowing us to carry out our communications function in a more modern and effective way. We have also opened a new communications centre (COMCEN) for processing high classification communications with our network of Posts. The new centre replaces a much larger 1970s centre which contained a lot of redundant technology.

 

New offices for the Embassy in Algiers were opened on 15 June. The new Embassy is designed to meet our security standards. Sustainability was also fundamental to the design: part of the building has a green roof; and solar heating panels on the roof provide hot water. The building was designed by London-based architects John McAslan and Partners, and project managed and constructed by the FCO's Strategic Building Partner, Mace International. It sits alongside the British Ambassador's Residence.

 

Following the sale of part of the British Embassy compound in Bangkok in 2006 for £49.5m, it was necessary to provide some staff housing and amenities by redeveloping part of the remaining site. A housing complex comprising 18 flats and 6 houses together with new amenity facilities has recently been completed.

 

As the Committee may recall from their visits to Moscow in 2004 and 2007, we have been undertaking an extensive refurbishment of the Ambassador's Residence following the move of the Embassy to its new site.  In 2006 we began the extensive refurbishment of the main Residence.  While we expected this to be completed at the end of December 2007 at a cost of £10.6m, problems with our main contractor and the planning authorities changing requirements on this listed and historic building have led to a substantial delay and cost overrun.  We are taking commercial steps against the main contractor, who completed their revised scope of works in July, and expect to complete the remaining works in late 2009 at a total project cost of just under £14m.

 

We continue to look for efficiencies and savings in our management of the overseas estate. I attach at Annex A our quarterly report for properties sold and purchased for the fourth quarter of the 2008-2009 financial year. None of the properties sold were the Residence of a Head of Mission. In Abidjan we successfully sold our old Embassy offices which were not fit for purpose and had been on the market for some time due to the security situation. In light of the continuing uncertainty over the future political situation in Cote d'Ivoire, we retain a Political Officer who works from the Residence. In Antalya we have purchased a new office following a request from the new owner of our current leased offices for vacant possession.

 

As in previous years at this time, I also attach at Annex B a full list of properties sold and purchased for financial year 2008-09.

 

Greening the FCO

 

The Sustainable Development in Government (SDiG 2008) assessment gave the FCO an improved star rating against sustainable operations on the Government Estate targets (which apply only in the UK). Our far-reaching project to create an effective and energy-efficient global IT platform continues to cause an increase in our carbon emissions in the UK, despite action to mitigate some of these. We believe that these IT related issues will peak in 2010 and then decline.

 

The Foreign Secretary's Green Awards earlier this year recognised the innovative work being carried out by the teams across the network to reduce our carbon footprint. Sustainable measures include creating a green roof in Zagreb and connecting the Ambassador's Residence in Stockholm to ground source heating. Our new embassies in Manila and Algiers have been awarded excellent and very good ratings respectively for their sustainable design under a bespoke Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method (BREEAM), and Berlin has recently received the first BREEAM in Use award for an existing building overseas. The launch of an online tool on World Environment Day will enable us to calculate our global carbon foot print for the first time later this year.

 

FCO Services

 

FCO Services has now laid before Parliament its Annual Report and Accounts for 2008/09 and I understand that you and your fellow Committee members have received copies.

 

In its first year of operations as a Trading Fund and in a difficult economic climate, FCO Services has produced an encouragingly strong performance. The organisation has achieved all its formal financial Ministerial KPI targets. Your Committee has previously commented on the likelihood of FCO Services' expansion into wider markets in this current climate, but I can confirm that their 2008/09 results show a 15.3% growth in wider market revenue. This is ahead of plan, exceeds their 2008/09 target of 10% and indicates that their business strategy is having a positive impact.

 

FCO Services has increased the efficiency of its operations over 2008/09 and this, together with its strong business performance, has enabled it to play an important role in enabling us to meet our overall efficiency saving obligations under the CSR. We are firmly focused on delivering the best possible value for the public purse and FCO Services will continue to play a key role in helping us achieve this.

 

In addition to its continuing attention to delivering efficiencies, FCO Services will work to embed the changes it has made over the course of the last year and build further the skills and capabilities of its workforce in order to enhance the service it delivers to customers. This is a key focus for FCO Services' business strategy for 2009/10.

 

Third Generation Firecrest (F3G)

 

In the UK we have made significant progress in deploying our new IT system, F3G, with the transfer of our data to new servers in June.  From July to January 2010, we will be separating our 'Confidential' data into a new security tier, which is isolated from the internet in accordance with Cabinet Office guidelines. We will also be introducing F3G laptops classified up to 'Restricted'.  Overseas, we have deployed F3G to 33 Posts (as at 30 June).  Staff are already seeing benefits, including the ability to work at home and on the move with the F3G laptop.  We expect to increase our rate of deployment to at least four Posts a week from August, and our target is to complete the global rollout between March and May 2010.

 

uk border agency (UKBA)

 

As part of the UKBA's International Group (formerly UKVisas) wider integration in the newly established Executive Agency of the Home Office, staff currently based in the FCO's King Charles Street Office will be moving to 2 Marsham Street.  The move of approximately 256 staff should be complete by the end of July.  The FCO and UKBA continue to work closely to deliver an effective immigration policy for the UK

 

review of allowances

 

I have commissioned an internal review of all of the allowances we pay to staff serving overseas to ensure that they provide value for money to the Department and the taxpayer, support our business needs, fit the family circumstances of FCO staff in the 21st Century, provide the right incentives to staff to serve in the places where we need them most and offer a fair and flexible package to enable staff and families to maintain a UK-level of quality of life (or compensation for it) wherever they serve. The aim is to ensure that everything we do is fully justified, including on value for money grounds.

 

We are consulting DfID (who are conducting a similar review), MOD and other Departments with staff serving overseas. We are keen to incorporate any lessons we can learn from their experience and share our own findings with them. The FCO Board will consider recommendations from the review in the autumn.

 

expenses

 

In common with other Whitehall Departments, we are publishing details of the business expenses (travel, transport, meals and accommodation when travelling and official entertainment) of senior FCO officials (at Director-General level and above) in the UK and overseas. The first return covering expenses for these staff during the Quarter April to June 2009 will be published on our public website by the end of July. 

 

Stakeholder Survey

 

The FCO commissioned an independent research agency (IPSOS MORI) to question a representative sample of the UK public on their perceptions of the FCO. Its purpose was to inform our communications and engagement activity in the UK.

 

The enclosed presentation (Annex C) gives you an overview of the results. IPSOS MORI found that there is a relatively low level of familiarity with the FCO.

 

Among those that were aware of the FCO, they were more favourable than unfavourable towards us. Respondents cited the FCO's work on 'helping Brits abroad' as one of our key attributes while appearing to 'let in too many foreigners' was seen as a driver for negative sentiment.

 

The results were used to help identify issues we needed to address in our community outreach programme during Leadership Week earlier this year. They have also been used to inform our ongoing website upgrades.

 

survey of whitehall partners

 

In June we received the results of our latest survey of Whitehall Partners. This was the biggest and most accurate survey we've done to date. A copy is enclosed (Annex D).

 

Most Government Departments think the FCO is a good organisation: delivering well and getting better. The FCO reputation, knowledge, professionalism and the quality of our staff is valued, and 95% of Departments regard the relationship as critical or important for themselves.

 

The survey also highlights areas we need to improve: including consistency of service across the world to all WPs, and ensuring that we embrace their agendas and treat them as genuine partners.

 

The results of the survey will be made available to all staff, and we have asked our Directors and Heads of Mission to ensure that they do work closely with all Governments Departments. We have also established dedicated account managers for our major partners. We will repeat the survey in a year or so to track improvements.

 

30 November 2009

 


Annex A

 

fco property sales for the period 1 january to 31 march 2009

 

date

post

type of property

exchange rate pound to sterling

gross sales receipt

transation currency

sterling

15- Jan- 09

Buenos Aires

Residential

0.6873797086

USD 362,000

248,831

28- Jan - 09

Ottawa

Residential

0.5879931793

CAD 500,000

293,997

17- Feb- 09

Abidjan

Office

0.0014088436

CFA 150,000,000

211,327

31-Mar-09

Montserrat

Residential

0.6976419701

USD 145,160

101,270

 

 

 

gross sales proceeds

£855,425

 

 

fco property purchases for the period 1 january to 31 march 2009

 

date

post

type of property

exchange rate pound to sterling

gross sales receipt

transation currency

sterling

28-Jan-09

Montserrat

Residential

0.6873797086

USD 725,000

498,350

11-Mar-09

Washington

Residential

0.7023951675

USD 578,000

405,984

13-Mar-09

Washington

Residential

0.7023951675

USD 682,000

479,034

18-Mar-09

Montserrat

Residential

0.7023951675

USD 412,500

289,738

26-Mar-09

Antalya

Office

0.9267840593

EURO 420,000

389,249

27-Mar-09

Panama

Residence

0.7023951675

USD 2,850,000

2,001,826

 

 

 

total purchases

4,064,181

 

 

 

 

annex b

 

fco property sales for the period 1 april 2008 to 31 march 2009

 

date

post

type of property

exchange rate to pound sterling

gross sales receipt

transaction currency

sterling

16-May-08

Dublin

Residence

0.7841292245

EUR 8,250,000

6,469,066

05-Jun-08

Tallinn

Land

0.0501162697

EEK 12,100,020

606,408

02-Jun-08

Amsterdam

Residence

0.7889546351

EUR 4,050,000

3,195,266

17-Jun-08

Madrid*

Office

0.7889546351

EUR 50,500,000

39,842,209

25-Jun-08

Wellington

Residential

0.3957574798

NZD 840,000

332,436

02-Jul-08

Cape Town

Residence

0.0640053252

ZAR 9,000,000

576,048

08-Jul-08

Wellington

Residential

0.3809378690

NZD 621,000

236,562

01-Aug-08

Stockholm

Residential

0.0830509601

SEK 7,642,459

634,714

08-Aug-08

Durban

Residence

0.0671415815

ZAR 2,600,000

174,568

22-Aug-08

Buenos Aires

Residential

0.5259835893

USD 275,000

144,645

25-Aug-08

Ottawa

Residential

0.5206977350

CAD 295,000

153,606

02-Sep-08

Manila

Office

0.0118243842

PHP125,241,840

1,480,908

30-Sep-08

Wellington

Residential

0.3783006734

NZD 645,000

244,004

17-Oct-08

Ottawa

Residential

0.4997251512

CAD 705,000

352,306

17-Oct-08

Wellington

Residential

0.3718578016

NZD 555,000

206,381

07-Nov-08

Wellington

Residential

0.3588988982

NZD 340,000

122,026

17-Nov-08

Ottawa

Residential

0.5403652869

CAD 752,000

406,355

31-Dec-08

Lilongwe

Residential

0.0044379946

MWK 42,000,000

186,396

15-Jan- 09

Buenos Aires

Residential

0.6873797086

USD 362,000

248,831

28-Jan-09

Ottawa

Residential

0.5879931793

CAD 500,000

293,997

17- Feb- 09

Abidjan

Office

0.0014088436

CFA 150,000,000

211,327

31-Mar-09

Montserrat

Residential

0.6976419701

USD 145,160

101,270

 

 

 

gross sales proceeds

56,219,329

 

* Note: This is a forward sale with vacation delayed until early autumn 2009

 


 

fco property purchases for the period 1 april 2008 to 31 march 2009

 

date

post

type of property

exchange rate to pound sterling

gross purchase expenditure

transaction currency

sterling

26-Jun-08

Dushanbe

Land

0.5048465267

USD 91,350

46,118

28-Jan-09

Montserrat

Residential

0.6873797086

USD 725,000

498,350

11-Mar-09

Washington

Residential

0.7023951675

USD 578,000

405,984

13-Mar-09

Washington

Residential

0.7023951675

USD 682,000

479,034

18-Mar-09

Montserrat

Residential

0.7023951675

USD 412,500

289,738

26-Mar-09

Antalya

Office

0.9267840593

EURO 420,000

389,249

27-Mar-09

Panama

Residence

0.7023951675

USD 2,850,000

2,001,826

 

 

 

total gross purchase

4,110,299