Memorandum submitted by Mrs Diana Benn
Writing as a citizen of England, what do I see,
as a result of Devolution?
Firstly, members of Parliament, elected to represent
non-English constituencies taking part and voting on matters affecting
English constituencies. This is plainly illogical and undemocratic.
Secondly, ministers have been appointed to represent
eight regions of England. On the only occasion when the electorate
was invited to vote on the question of regional government, which
took place in the North-East in 2004, the vote was 78% against,
compared to 225 for. Nevertheless, ministers were appointed, committees
set up and funding made available. Again, this action could definitely
be described as undemocratic.
The only truly equitable solution to the present
situation is the establishment of an English Parliament, not eight
regional assemblies, or any so-called Grand Committee.
Finally, I see that the citizens of Berwick-upon-Tweed
wish once again to be re-united with Scotland in order to benefit
from the additional perks of free university education and care
for the elderly etc voted through the Scottish Parliament. This
demand will undoubtedly raise the "West Lothian Question"
yet again. However, Lord Barnett has long since disowned his formula
as being outdated as stated to the Commons Treasury Select Committee
in 2000.
February 2008
| 
