Previous Section Index Home Page

25 Mar 2010 : Column 554W—continued

Local Government: Devon and Norfolk

Justine Greening: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government what his plans are for the implementation of (a) the draft Exeter and Devon (Structural Changes) Order 2010 and (b) the draft Norwich and Norfolk (Structural Changes) Order 2010. [323092]

Ms Rosie Winterton: Following the approval by this House and the other place of the draft orders implementing unitary councils for Exeter and Norwich, I informed the House yesterday, Official Report, columns 38-41WS, that the Government had concluded it was right to proceed in making those orders, and that we intended to do so as soon as practicable. The orders were subsequently made yesterday and have come into force today.

Local Government: Translation Services

Mr. Evans: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government how much was spent on translation services by local authorities in (a) Ribble Valley, (b) Lancashire and (c) England in each of the last five years. [324420]

Barbara Follett: The information is not collected centrally.

Non-Domestic Rates

Robert Neill: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government with reference to his Department's publication of February 2010, Number of hereditaments benefiting from Small Business Rate Relief and the number of empty hereditaments, what his latest estimate is of the number and proportion of eligible small firms who do not claim small business rate relief. [323186]

Barbara Follett: Local authorities estimated that 462,000 hereditaments were benefiting from Small Business Rate Relief (SBRR) on December 2008. By applying that figure to the eligibility estimates made for the 2005 rating list it is estimated that around 80 per cent. of
25 Mar 2010 : Column 555W
eligible hereditaments were claiming SBRR in 2008-09 - see table 1. This estimate suggests that around 20 per cent. or 113,000 of eligible hereditaments are not claiming SBRR. However, relief granted to small businesses has been increasing since SBRR was introduced-from £202 million in 2005-06 to £298 million in 2008-09. This represents a real terms increase of 34 per cent. Furthermore in 2008-09, 92 per cent. of the total relief that would be paid if all those estimated to be eligible were to claim, was actually being paid - see table 2.

Table 1: Take-up of SBRR - numbers claiming

2006-07 2007-08 2008-09

Number of hereditaments actually claiming SBRR (thousand)

396

433

462

Number of hereditaments estimated to be occupied by eligible small businesses (thousand)

575

575

575

Percentage of estimated eligible actually claiming:

69

75

80


Table 2: Take-up of SBRR 2005-06 to 2008-09 - relief

2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09

Total relief that would be paid out if all properties estimated to be occupied by eligible small businesses were to claim(1) (£ million)

295

300

315

325

Relief actually claimed: (£ million)

202

237

259

£98

Percentage take-up(2) (%)

69

78

83

92

(1) For details of how this estimate was made please see the paper "Small business rate relief-improving evidence on eligibility and take-up: Methodology"
(2) Percentage of total relief, which would be paid if all eligible small businesses claimed it, that was actually paid

Justine Greening: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government how many hereditaments are (a) above the rateable value threshold for small business rate relief, (b) below the rateable value for small business rate relief but not occupied by eligible small businesses, (c) below the rateable value threshold for small business rate relief and occupied by an eligible small business claiming the relief and (d) below the rateable value threshold for small business rate relief and occupied by a eligible small business not claiming relief in each region; what estimate he has made of the monetary value of small business rate relief available to each eligible firm claiming the relief in each region; and how much has been claimed in small business rate relief by businesses in each region in 2009-10 to date. [323817]

Barbara Follett: The information is as follows:

(a) The number of hereditaments above the rateable value threshold for Small Business Rate Relief by region on the 2005 Rating List are shown in the following table. These numbers are consistent with the statistical release titled "Non-domestic rateable values: 2010 Local Ratings Lists-England and Wales" published on 18 December 2009.


25 Mar 2010 : Column 556W
Government office region Number of hereditaments above the rateable value threshold( 1) for SBRR on 2005 Rating List

North East

18,000

North West

59,000

Yorkshire and the Humber

41,000

East Midlands

35,000

West Midlands

47,000

East of England

51,000

London

81,000

South East

79,000

South West

42,000

Total

453,000

(1) Hereditaments with a rateable value over £15,000 or £21,500 in London

(b), (c) and (d) The report "Small Business Rate Relief-improving evidence on eligibility and take-up was published on 9 December 2009 and it estimates that of the approximately 1.2 million non-domestic properties in England which fall below the current rateable value (RV) thresholds for SBRR, around 575,000 are occupied by eligible small businesses. This report has been validated by an independent peer review and is available at

This methodology can only be applied nationally for England as a whole. Therefore it is not possible to calculate an estimate of eligibility of small business rate relief by region.

No estimate has been made of the monetary value of small business rate relief in each eligible firm in each region claiming the relief.

The amount of small business rate relief is collected from local authorities on a financial year basis. Therefore it is not possible to provide figures on how much small business rate relief has been claimed in 2009-10 to date. The amount of small business rate relief claimed by businesses in each region in 2009-10 will be available following the publication of the Statistical Release on "National non-domestic rates collected by local authorities in England 2009-10" later this year.

Non-Domestic Rates: Empty Property

Justine Greening: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government what estimate has been made of the number of properties on which empty property business rate relief was claimed in each region in 2009. [323821]

Barbara Follett: Details of the number of properties on which empty property business rate relief was claimed in each region in England as at 31 December 2008, the latest date for which data are available, are given in the following table:


25 Mar 2010 : Column 557W

Number of properties claiming empty property relief as at 31 December 2008 (Thousand)

North East

7.6

North West

27.6

Yorkshire and the Humber

17.1

East Midlands

12.2

West Midlands

18.2

East of England

15.0

London

20.8

South East

15.8

South West

13.6

Total England

147.9


Data as at 31 December 2009 will be available later in 2010.

Planning Permission

Mrs. Spelman: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government if he will end the requirements made by the density targets in Planning Policy Statement 3. [324002]

Mr. Ian Austin: The density target in Planning Policy Statement 3 is an indicative target rather than a prescriptive one and it allows for flexibility where needed. PPS3 states that local planning authorities may wish to set out a range of densities across the plan area rather than one broad density range although 30 dwellings per hectare net should be used as a national indicative minimum to guide policy development and decision-making, until local density policies are in place. PPS3 goes on to say that where local authorities wish to plan for, or agree to, densities below this minimum, this will need to be justified.

Recycling: Conferences

Mrs. Spelman: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government if he will place in the Library a copy of the speaking notes and accompanying materials used by the Audit Commission speaker at the Local Authority Recycling Advisory Committee Conference in 2008. [323986]

Ms Rosie Winterton: This is an operational matter for the Audit Commission and I have asked the chief executive of the Audit Commission to write to the hon. Member direct.

Letter from Steve Bundred, dated 25 March 2010:

Right to Buy Scheme

Mr. Stewart Jackson: To ask the Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government what the average right to buy discount was (a) in cash terms, (b) in real terms in 2010 prices and (c) as a proportion of the market value of the property in (i) England and (ii) each Government Office Region in England in each year since 1996-97. [319311]

Mr. Ian Austin: The average right to buy discount in cash terms and real term and as a proportion of the
25 Mar 2010 : Column 558W
market value of the property in England and its regions are shown in the table. Figures are not available prior to 1998-09 and the discounts in real terms are presented in 2008-09 prices in line with the latest GDP deflator series.


25 Mar 2010 : Column 559W

25 Mar 2010 : Column 560W

Average RTB discount per dwelling (cash terms) Average RTB discount per dwelling (in real terms) Average RTB discount as a percentage of market value

North East

1998-99

14,490

18,469

48

1999-2000

10,670

13,337

47

2000-01

12,590

15,533

47

2001-02

11,680

14,096

46

2002-03

13,240

15,479

45

2003-04

14,850

16,885

42

2004-05

18,800

20,798

34

2005-06

21,140

22,959

34

2006-07

21,010

22,162

31

2007-08

21,460

22,001

28

2008-09

21,650

21,650

29

North West

1998-99

16,510

21,043

48

1999-2000

16,670

20,837

48

2000-01

16,700

20,604

47

2001-02

17,230

20,793

46

2002-03

18,200

21,278

45

2003-04

19,460

22,127

43

2004-05

21,370

23,641

41

2005-06

23,590

25,619

37

2006-07

24,580

25,927

34

2007-08

25,210

25,846

32

2008-09

25,370

25,370

32

Yorkshire and the Humber

1998-99

15,650

19,947

47

1999-2000

15,650

19,562

47

2000-01

15,630

19,284

46

2001-02

16,260

19,623

46

2002-03

16,270

19,021

44

2003-04

18,110

20,592

43

2004-05

20,250

22,402

40

2005-06

22,550

24,490

35

2006-07

23,030

24,292

31

2007-08

23,740

24,339

28

2008-09

23,050

23,050

29

East Midlands

1998-99

18,260

23,274

50

1999-2000

16,740

20,924

46

2000-01

17,100

21,097

45

2001-02

17,830

21,517

43

2002-03

21,390

25,007

41

2003-04

21,820

24,810

wok

2004-05

22,420

24,803

35

2005-06

22,770

24,729

31

2006-07

23,600

24,894

28

2007-08

23,850

24,452

27

2008-09

23,860

23,860

29

West Midlands

1998-99

18,230

23,236

49

1999-2000

18,470

23,087

48

2000-01

19,960

24,626

49

2001-02

19,840

23,943

47

2002-03

20,330

23,768

44

2003-04

22,580

25,675

40

2004-05

23,930

26,474

34

2005-06

25,060

27,216

33

2006-07

25,050

26,423

30

2007-08

25,620

26,266

30

2008-09

25,820

25,820

30

East

1998-99

25,020

31,890

49

1999-2000

27,350

34,187

47

2000-01

27,300

33,682

45

2001-02

27,830

33,586

43

2002-03

30,360

35,494

39

2003-04

31,360

35,658

35

2004-05

32,580

36,043

33

2005-06

33,250

36,110

30

2006-07

33,020

34,830

27

2007-08

33,790

34,643

25

2008-09

33,960

33,960

25

London

1998-99

34,070

43,425

53

1999-2000

36,150

45,186

51

2000-01

37,140

45,822

48

2001-02

36,990

44,640

42

2002-03

35,960

42,041

37

2003-04

37,190

42,287

32

2004-05

35,490

39,262

28

2005-06

30,280

32,885

22

2006-07

21,150

22,309

14

2007-08

20,710

21,233

13

2008-09

20,990

20,990

10

South East

1998-99

29,780

37,957

50

1999-2000

30,760

38,449

47

2000-01

31,060

38,321

44

2001-02

32,640

39,390

42

2002-03

34,510

40,346

39

2003-04

36,200

41,161

35

2004-05

36,640

40,535

32

2005-06

36,850

40,020

30

2006-07

36,500

38,501

28

2007-08

36,880

37,811

26

2008-09

36,690

36,690

26

South West

1998-99

21,230

27,059

50

1999-2000

21,670

27,087

48

2000-01

23,090

28,488

46

2001-02

24,880

30,025

44

2002-03

26,460

30,934

40

2003-04

28,430

32,326

36

2004-05

28,870

31,939

34

2005-06

29,150

31,658

31

2006-07

29,310

30,917

28

2007-08

29,660

30,408

27

2008-09

29,320

29,320

24

England

1998-99

22,880

29,162

50

1999-2000

23,630

29,537

48

2000-01

23,880

29,462

47

2001-02

23,380

28,215

44

2002-03

23,790

27,813

41

2003-04

24,640

28,017

37

2004-05

25,650

28,376

33

2005-06

25,530

27,726

31

2006-07

24,970

26,339

27

2007-08

25,340

25,979

24

2008-09

25,410

25,410

24

Source:
Local authority returns to CLG on P1B

Next Section Index Home Page