Public Expenditure on Health and Personal Social Services 2009 - Health Committee Contents


2.  CAPITAL EXPENDITURE

2.1.7  Could the Department give for each PFI scheme which has reached financial close (a) the pre- and post-tax nominal and real Blended Equity Internal Rate of Return, (b) the pre- and post-tax nominal and real Project Internal Rate of Return, and (c) the financial gearing (ratio of debt to equity) in the financing structure? (Q12)

Answer

  1.  The information requested is given in tables 12a to 12c.

Table 12a

PRE AND POST TAX NOMINAL AND REAL BLENDED EQUITY INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN




Scheme
Pre tax
Post tax
  
Nominal
Real
Nominal
Real

Avon & Western Wiltshire MH NHS Trust
14.69
11.82
-
-
Barking, Havering & Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust
15.16
12.35
12.62
9.90
Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals NHS Trust
18.00
14.60
-
-
Barts & The London NHS Trust
17.00
14.10
-
-
Berkshire West PCT
-
-
-
-
Blackpool PCT
-
-
13.25
10.50
Brent Teaching PCT
14.89
12.02
-
-
Brighton & Sussex University NHS Trust
13.10
10.40
9.80
7.20
Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
  
  
  
Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS Trust—Stoke Mandeville
-
-
15.00
12.20
Cornwall Partnership NHS Trust
21.30
-
17.47
-
Dartford and Gravesham Hospital NHS Trust
13.98
11.27
-
-
Post refinancing in 2003 (1)
56.00
  
  
  
Derbyshire Mental Health Services NHS Trust
14.25
11.47
11.72
8.99
Devon PCT
14.14
11.40
-
-
East & North Hertfordshire PCT
15.83
13.15
11.92
9.34
East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust—Blackburn
13.60
10.83
10.04
7.35
East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust—Burnley
15.07
12.20
12.51
9.71
Hampshire PCT
14.73
12.00
-
-
Hereford Hospitals NHS Trust
18.10
15.30
-
-
Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust Maternity
13.00
10.20
-
-
Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust Oncology
15.00
12.19
-
-
Ipswich Hospital NHS Trust
14.50
11.74
-
-
Kingston Hospital NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
  
  
  
Kirklees PCT
-
-
13.95
11.20
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust—Wharfedale
13.07
10.31
-
-
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust
14.79
12.00
-
-
Lewisham Hospital NHS Trust
13.5
10.7
10.8
8.10
Lincolnshire Primary Care Trust
14.25
11.47
11.53
8.82
Maidstone & Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust
14.00
11.20
11.36
8.63
Mid Essex Hospital Services NHS Trust
12.65
9.82
9.44
6.70
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust
15.31
Commercial
in confidence
12.19
9.45
Newham University Hospital NHS Trust
14.97
12.01
-
-
North Cumbria Acute Hospitals NHS Trust
16.59
12.64
  
  
North Middlesex NHS Trust
14.75
11.95
-
-
North Staffordshire Combined Healthcare NHS Trust
-
-
-
15.00
North West London Hospitals NHS Trust
15.13
-
-
-
Northamptonshire Primary Care Trust
13.17
10.35
-
-
Northumberland, Tyne & Wear NHS Trust—Morpeth
14.79
11.99
-
-
Northumberland, Tyne & Wear NHS Trust—Neuro disability
16.93
13.79
-
-
Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust
-
-
12.63
9.86
Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust—Queens Medical Centre
14.79
12.14
-
-
Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre NHS Trust
13.42
10.65
-
-
Portsmouth NHS Trust
Commercial
in confidence
-
-
-
Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust Relocation
15.30
12.48
11.59
8.87
Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust Churchill
13.85
11.07
-
-
Redcar and Cleveland Community Hospital
13.65
10.94
-
-
Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust
10.66
8.10
  
  
Sandwell & West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust
13.96
11.09
13.58
10.65
South London Healthcare NHS Trust (Bromley)
23.30
20.30
-
-
Post refinancing in 2004 (1)
70.54
  
  
  
South London Healthcare NHS Trust (Queen Elizabeth)
20.30
16.50
-
-
South West Essex Teaching Primary Care Trust
Commercial in confidence
  
  
  
St George's Healthcare NHS Trust
12.40
9.66
-
-
St Helens & Knowsley NHS Trust
-
-
14.8
12.00
Surrey PCT
-
-
-
-
The Whittington Hospital NHS Trust
14.38
11.67
-
-
University Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
  
  
  
University Hospitals of North Staffordshire NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
  
  
  
Walsall Hospitals NHS Trust
15.00
12.20
-
-
Wandsworth PCT
13.27
10.51
-
-
West Middlesex University Hospital NHS Trust
15.30
12.27
-
-
Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust
15.99
-
13.61
-

Source:
Capital Investment, DH
  
Footnotes:
1.  "-" means the NHS body has reported to the Department that the information is not included in the full business case or financial model held by them. "Commercial in Confidence" means the NHS body, in consultation with their private sector partner, have taken the decision that the information cannot be released for this reason under the Freedom of Information Act.
2.  All the figures for both both blended equity and thus also project IRRs are the forecasts at the time of financial close on a scheme—they do not represent the current trading postions of the private sector consortium (ie reflecting losses or gains). The only instances where we have included amended figures is in the case of a refinancing.
3.  Information is not collected for PFI schemes at NHS foundation trusts.


Table 12b

PRE AND POST TAX NOMINAL AND REAL PROJECT INTERNAL RATE OF RETURN



Scheme
Pre tax
Post tax
  
Nominal
Real
Nominal
Real

Avon & Western Wiltshire MH NHS Trust
7.92
5.30
7.59
4.98
Barking, Havering & Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust
7.51
4.89
7.05
4.44
Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals NHS Trust
-
-
-
-
Barts & The London NHS Trust
6.90
4.30
6.70
4.10
Berkshire West PCT
6.56
3.98
-
-
Blackpool PCT
7.96
5.33
7.58
4.97
Brent Teaching PCT
7.63
4.71
-
-
Brighton & Sussex University NHS Trust
7.60
5.00
7.50
5.00
Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS Trust—Stoke Mandeville
8.26
5.64
7.98
5.37
Cornwall Partnership NHS Trust
-
-
-
-
Dartford and Gravesham Hospital NHS Trust
7.26
4.64
6.91
4.30
Derbyshire Mental Health Services NHS Trust
7.43
4.98
7.10
4.66
Devon PCT
8.25
5.51
-
-
East & North Hertfordshire PCT
8.94
6.43
8.23
5.73
East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust—Blackburn
7.64
5.02
7.41
4.79
East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust—Burnley
6.54
3.96
-
-
Hampshire PCT
8.00
5.38
7.64
5.03
Hereford Hospitals NHS Trust
9.98
7.20
9.38
6.72
Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust Maternity
9.10
6.40
8.60
5.90
Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust Oncology
6.50
3.90
6.00
3.50
Ipswich Hospital NHS Trust
7.71
5.07
7.23
4.01
Kingston Hospital NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Kirklees PCT
8.10
5.50
7.80
5.10
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust—Wharfedale
7.77
5.14
-
-
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust
8.10
5.46
7.69
5.06
Lewisham Hospital NHS Trust
7.60
5.00
7.40
4.70
Lincolnshire Primary Care Trust
7.50
5.01
7.15
4.68
Maidstone & Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust
5.72
3.14
4.09
1.55
Mid Essex Hospital Services NHS Trust
6.13
3.53
6.04
3.44
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust
6.31
3.34
3.72
0.82
Newham University Hospital NHS Trust
8.17
5.61
6.12
3.60
North Cumbria Acute Hospitals NHS Trust
10.55
6.81
8.01
4.36
North Middlesex NHS Trust
6.63
4.09
4.41
1.90
North Staffordshire Combined Healthcare NHS Trust
-
-
17.86
-
North West London Hospitals NHS Trust
-
-
7.79
-
Northamptonshire Primary Care Trust
8.06
5.42
7.93
5.29
Northumberland, Tyne & Wear NHS Trust—Morpeth
6.94
4.86
6.82
4.76
Northumberland, Tyne & Wear NHS Trust—Neuro disability
6.84
4.24
6.74
4.14
Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust
7.85
5.21
-
-
Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust—Queens Medical Centre
-
-
-
-
Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre NHS Trust
8.77
6.13
-
-
Portsmouth NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust Relocation
-
-
7.90
5.27
Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust Churchill
5.32
-
7.04
-
Redcar and Cleveland Community Hospital
7.26
4.86
7.09
4.52
Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust
8.23
5.61
-
-
Sandwell & West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust
7.43
4.82
7.23
4.63
South London Healthcare NHS Trust (Bromley)
-
-
-
-
South London Healthcare NHS Trust (Queen Elizabeth)
11.70
8.00
10.60
6.90
South West Essex Teaching Primary Care Trust
Commercial in confidence
St George's Healthcare NHS Trust
9.68
7.00
-
-
St Helens & Knowsley NHS Trust
5.50
2.90
5.40
2.80
Surrey PCT
-
-
-
-
The Whittington Hospital NHS Trust
7.73
5.09
7.46
4.82
University Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
University Hospitals of North Staffordshire NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Walsall Hospitals NHS Trust
6.70
4.10
-
-
Wandsworth PCT
7.18
4.57
-
-
West Middlesex University Hospital NHS Trust
8.95
6.08
8.07
5.23
Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust
-
-
7.92
-

Source:
Capital Investment, DH
  
Footnotes:
1.  "—" means the NHS body has reported to the Department that the information is not included in the full Business case or financial model held by them. "Commercial in Confidence" means the NHS body, in consultation with their private sector partner, have taken the decision that the information cannot be released for this reason under the Freedom of Information Act.


Table 12c

FINANCIAL GEARING (RATIO OF DEBT TO EQUITY) IN THE FINANCING STRUCTURE




  
  
Percentage
Scheme
Ratio
  
Debt
Equity

Avon & Western Wiltshire MH NHS Trust
91.49
8.51
Barking, Havering & Redbridge Hospitals NHS Trust
94.00
6.00
Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals NHS Trust
89.80
10.20
Barts & The London NHS Trust
92.12
7.88
Berkshire West PCT
79.00
21(charitable
contribution)
Blackpool PCT
92.30
7.70
Brent Teaching PCT
92.00
8.00
Brighton & Sussex University NHS Trust
89.00
11.00
Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS Trust—Stoke Mandeville
89.60
10.40
Cornwall Partnership NHS Trust
89.65
10.35
Dartford and Gravesham Hospital NHS Trust
89.60
10.40
Derbyshire Mental Health Services NHS Trust
90.00
10.00
Devon PCT
92.13
7.87
East & North Hertfordshire PCT
90.10
9.90
East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust—Blackburn
89.60
10.40
East Lancashire Hospitals NHS Trust—Burnley
94.43
5.57
Hampshire PCT
90.49
9.51
Hereford Hospitals NHS Trust
85.03
14.97
Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust Maternity
89.80
10.20
Hull and East Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust Oncology
91.20
8.80
Ipswich Hospital NHS Trust
91.19
8.81
Kingston Hospital NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Kirklees PCT
98.00
2.00
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust—Wharfedale
91.00
9.00
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust
91.13
8.87
Lewisham Hospital NHS Trust
89.80
10.20
Lincolnshire Primary Care Trust
90.56
9.44
Maidstone & Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust
92.55
7.45
Mid Essex Hospital Services NHS Trust
90.00
10.00
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust
91.00
9.00
Newham University Hospital NHS Trust
91.10
8.90
North Cumbria Acute Hospitals NHS Trust
90.50
9.50
North Middlesex Hospital NHS Trust
92.49
7.51
North Staffordshire Combined Healthcare NHS Trust
86.36
13.64
North West London Hospitals NHS Trust
92.00
8.00
Northamptonshire Primary Care Trust
90.96
9.04
Northumberland, Tyne & Wear NHS Trust—Morpeth
90.00
10.00
Northumberland, Tyne & Wear NHS Trust—Neuro disability
90.99
9.10
Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Trust
90.00
10.00
Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust—Queens Medical Centre
90.00
10.00
Nuffield Orthopaedic Centre NHS Trust
88.71
11.29
Portsmouth NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust Relocation
91.90
8.10
Oxford Radcliffe Hospitals NHS Trust Churchill
91.90
8.10
Redcar and Cleveland Community Hospital
92.43
7.57
Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust
86.00
14.00
Sandwell & West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust
91.70
8.30
South London Healthcare NHS Trust (Bromley)
88.50
11.50
South London Healthcare NHS Trust (Queen Elizabeth)
90.29
9.71
South West Essex Teaching Primary Care Trust
Commercial in confidence
St George's Healthcare NHS Trust
85.00
15.00
St Helens & Knowsley NHS Trust
91.70
8.30
Surrey PCT
85.28
14.72
The Whittington Hospital NHS Trust
90.25
9.75
University Hospitals Coventry & Warwickshire NHS Trust
91.50
8.50
University Hospitals of North Staffordshire NHS Trust
Commercial in confidence
Walsall Hospitals NHS Trust
92.80
7.20
Wandsworth PCT
90.48
9.52
West Middlesex University Hospital NHS Trust
91.00
9.00
Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust
87.00
13.00

Source:
Capital Investment, DH




 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2010
Prepared 20 January 2010