Draft Civil Law Reform Bill: pre-legislative scrutiny - Justice Committee Contents


Provisions re Succession

  The conclusions detailed below relate to the proposals on succession only (a copy of the proposals are attached). The conclusions were reached following a telephone conference between:

Louise Sykes—Contentious Probate—Alison Matthews—Compliance

Adam Draper—Contentious Probate—Gillian Coverley—Trust & Probate

Chris Walton—Contentious Probate—Lisa Shenton—Wills

Forfeiture

  There is nothing in the proposal with which we disagree.

  The current position has the effect of penalising a child for the act of his/her parent. In our view, it is appropriate that the Law on Forfeiture should be amended to remove the impact on the innocent child by treating the forfeiting parent as having immediately predeceased the deceased.

  The only incidence we can foresee whereby the proposal may be subject to abuse/have a negative impact is in the incidence of a parent killing with a knowledge and/or intention that, although forfeiture would apply to them, their child would benefit. We do not expect that this situation would occur with any frequency.

Disclaimer

  We neither fundamentally agree nor disagree with the proposal because whilst the issue can be resolved by a change in the law, equally the issue can simply be resolved by way of a Deed of Variation/gift.

Death during minority, leaving children

  We agree with the proposal.

Impact assessment

  We agree with the impact assessment.

March 2010





 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2010
Prepared 31 March 2010