The disclosure of climate data from the Climatic Research Unit at the University of East Anglia - Science and Technology Committee Contents

Memorandum submitted by John Wadsworth (CRU 08)

  I have spent the last 15 months or so researching AGW, the driver being the passing of the Climate Change Act 2008.

  I am not a climate scientist or hold any qualification or have any experience that relates to the field; however I am an engineer with the required understanding of the laws of physics.

  The research, mostly web based, has given me cause for concern with the arguments from both sides of the divide. I have also found that both sides can become very emotive and in some cases downright ignorant when their stance is challenged.

  I was therefore extremely pleased and grateful for your announcement to carry out a Select Committee investigation into the emails leaked from EAU—CRU. At last an independent inquiry into these deeply worrying issues.

  The morning following the announcement of the inquiry I read in the Daily

Telegraph: a statement attributed to you as the chair of the Commons science and technology committee:

  "There are a significant number of climate change deniers who are basically using the UEA emails to support the case this is poor science that has been changed or at worst manipulated. We do not believe this is healthy and therefore we want to call in the UEA so the public can see what they are saying"

  I would be grateful if you would please confirm that the statement attributed to you is correct?

You will, I have no doubt, understand my concerns when I was looking forward to finally getting an independent review of this matter.

  I have always considered it to be healthy for the chair of any committee to keep an open mind throughout the whole of the proceedings.

  Following the statement, you will not be surprised to find that the "deniers" (not a word I would have chosen) side of the divide have already written off the committees proceedings as a whitewash and I have a great deal of difficulty in countering their arguments.

January 2010

previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2010
Prepared 31 March 2010