Previous Section Index Home Page

16 Nov 2010 : Column 682W—continued


Mr Umunna: To ask the Attorney-General how many cases prosecuted by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) in each (a) magistrates and (b) Crown court in each local authority area were stopped or lost as a result of (i) discontinuance and (ii) attrition of CPS staff in each of the last three years. [24040]

The Solicitor-General: The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) collects data about the cases it prosecutes, but its data collection system is based on the number of defendants prosecuted rather than individual offences.

The CPS comprises 42 areas whose boundaries are largely based on those of the police forces of England and Wales. These boundaries are not co-terminate with either local authority boundaries or with those of individual magistrates courts or Crown courts.

The detailed data requested for individual magistrates courts and Crown courts can be obtained only at disproportionate cost. However there are data available which show: (i) the total of prosecutions discontinued by the CPS; (ii) the totals of other unsuccessful outcomes; (iii) the total of all unsuccessful outcomes; and, (iv) the totals of successful outcomes for each CPS area in the last three years for both magistrates court cases and Crown court cases. The data for prosecutions dropped by the CPS include cases that are discontinued, withdrawn or where no evidence is offered. Other unsuccessful outcomes will include all acquittals after trial. CPS data do not identify whether the reason for dropping a case was due to attrition of CPS staff. Tables containing these data have been deposited in the Library of the House.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 683W

Crown Prosecution Service: Closures

Mr Umunna: To ask the Attorney-General which Crown Prosecution Service offices have closed in the last 12 months. [24035]

The Attorney-General: Between 1 October 2009 and 30 October 2010 the following CPS offices closed.

Crown Prosecution Service: Personnel

Mr Umunna: To ask the Attorney-General how many Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) staff there were in each local authority area in each year since 2005; and how many cases were referred to the CPS in each local authority area in each such year. [24038]

The Solicitor-General: The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) is divided into 42 geographical areas across England and Wales. The number of staff in each area since 2005 is shown in table 1.

The CPS does not keep data on the basis of local authority boundaries, but on the basis of its area structure. Data are therefore only available for the 42 geographically based CPS areas.

The number of cases referred to the CPS includes all cases charged by the police which the CPS prosecutes, and the cases referred to the CPS by the police for a pre-charge decision. The breakdown between pre-charge decisions and cases charged by the police, in the last five years, are provided in tables 2 and 3 as follows.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 684W
Table 1-CPS staff

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010

ENGLAND and WALES

7148

7500

7820

7705

7700

7550

Avon and Somerset

173

191

198

183

188

177

Bedfordshire

63

68

63

71

74

76

Cambridgeshire

69

68

73

80

78

77

Cheshire

109

105

108

115

115

112

Cleveland

107

112

116

110

104

99

Cumbria

78

77

82

79

80

79

Derbyshire

104

111

115

122

123

119

Devon and Cornwall

121

136

134

125

122

121

Dorset

56

64

69

74

77

78

Durham

79

76

77

84

92

93

Dyfed-Powys

66

68

65

64

61

62

Essex

154

151

163

172

185

191

Gloucestershire

55

55

52

55

61

55

Greater Manchester

464

485

511

502

474

457

Gwent

83

81

85

97

86

84

Hampshire and I.O.W

223

226

246

248

243

239

Hertfordshire

97

116

128

114

120

120

Humberside

101

118

123

122

118

119

Kent

160

163

186

179

188

182

Lancashire

238

249

256

242

252

264

Leicestershire

117

130

130

128

119

120

Lincoln

64

79

78

82

79

70

London

1334

1336

1455

1394

1364

1319

Merseyside

295

319

303

276

259

247

Norfolk

93

100

100

99

95

90

North Wales

72

80

83

82

84

83

North Yorkshire

72

76

77

83

85

82

Northamptonshire

66

73

74

82

81

77

Northumbria

254

259

272

268

274

266

Nottinghamshire

165

163

172

157

182

184

South Wales

210

233

252

226

241

234

South Yorkshire

180

192

192

183

195

195

Staffordshire

138

139

149

156

152

144

Suffolk

74

76

76

75

70

70

Surrey

68

69

73

77

81

80

Sussex

131

152

157

162

165

167

Thames Valley

193

217

221

228

246

247

Warwickshire

38

39

43

43

42

40

West Mercia

110

140

144

149

147

148

West Midlands

515

530

531

530

515

501

West Yorkshire

309

322

330

322

317

324

Wiltshire

50

56

58

65

66

58



16 Nov 2010 : Column 685W
Table 2-Pre-charge decisions

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010( 1)

ENGLAND and WALES

577,286

564,200

538,055

485,409

402,193

Avon and Somerset

12,179

11,273

15,558

10,916

8,714

Bedfordshire

5,985

5,733

6,147

5,615

4,441

Cambridgeshire

7,446

6,194

6,563

5,746

5,652

Cheshire

9,573

10,147

9,473

8,527

6,658

Cleveland

6,392

6,498

6,927

6,045

5,085

Cumbria

6,642

5,950

5,528

5,319

3,425

Derbyshire

11,970

12,181

11,364

9,126

7,977

Devon and Cornwall

8,681

11,088

10,302

9,367

7,152

Dorset

7,825

6,137

5,981

4,631

3,935

Durham

7,144

7,776

7,409

6,927

4,957

Dyfed Powys

3,875

3,304

2,603

2,427

2,022

Essex

13,990

15,847

14,028

12,336

10,707

Gloucestershire

5,097

5,662

5,661

5,189

3,136

Greater Manchester

35,713

33,146

28,817

27,742

26,746

Gwent

6,480

6,531

5,921

5,609

4,675

Hampshire and I.O.W

15,734

19,015

19,281

17,242

13,725

Hertfordshire

8,061

8,053

6,098

5,460

5,291

Humberside

8,486

8,144

8,568

7,980

6,760

Kent

12,637

14,021

13,264

11,554

9,074

Lancashire

24,680

23,174

22,292

21,248

17,659

Leicestershire

10,061

9,992

8,118

8,047

6,152

Lincolnshire

5,597

3,974

4,266

3,703

2,861

London

84,990

83,786

86,406

72,262

64,208

Merseyside

20,374

19,616

18,405

15,014

12,171

Norfolk

7,729

7,383

7,381

7,305

5,876

Northamptonshire

5,713

5,627

5,167

5,323

4,198

Northumbria

20,158

18,490

15,797

12,891

9,860

North Wales

9,114

7,894

7,806

7,762

5,977

North Yorkshire

7,700

7,514

7,483

6,941

4,883

Nottinghamshire

12,811

13,316

10,275

11,792

9,744

South Wales

16,582

14,631

15,487

15,694

12,500

South Yorkshire

14,264

13,668

13,136

11,607

8,776

Staffordshire

13,382

11,340

10,383

9,020

6,266

Suffolk

8,356

7,187

6,531

5,381

4,800

Surrey

4,816

5,983

6,319

4,789

6,084

Sussex

15,655

15,303

15,327

14,021

12,309

Thames Valley

15,518

16,296

14,736

13,469

11,579

Warwickshire

4,101

3,695

2,968

2,375

1,908

West Mercia

12,078

12,256

10,758

9,057

6,918

West Midlands

41,633

41,242

33,581

31,315

23,858

West Yorkshire

23,933

20,839

21,454

23,675

20,433

Wiltshire

4,131

4,294

4,486

4,960

3,041

(1) January to October


16 Nov 2010 : Column 686W
Table 3-Police charged prosecutions

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010( 1)

ENGLAND and WALES

762,740

693,192

677,320

663,636

536,011

Avon and Somerset

20,909

20,328

17,257

16,433

14,183

Bedfordshire

7,723

6,607

6,185

5,944

4,375

Cambridgeshire

10,095

7,970

7,652

7,516

6,040

Cheshire

13,510

14,225

14,165

13,485

10,423

Cleveland

8,846

8,784

9,478

9,533

7,763

Cumbria

10,174

9,092

8,705

7,286

5,713

Derbyshire

10,401

9,962

8,512

7,425

5,846

Devon and Cornwall

18,753

16,544

16,274

15,599

12,629

Dorset

9,450

7,510

6,687

6,551

5,005

Durham

7,260

6,952

6,152

5,321

4,480

Dyfed Powys

8,829

7,808

7,922

7,661

6,193

Essex

18,339

17,508

18,126

18,863

14,832

Gloucestershire

5,604

4,842

5,083

4,747

3,334

Greater Manchester

51,020

42,073

42,195

36,121

28,471

Gwent

11,097

10,077

7,384

6,834

4,984

Hampshire and I.O.W

19,897

20,372

20,503

20,999

16,538

Hertfordshire

14,337

12,536

12,547

13,467

10,512

Humberside

10,527

10,838

11,089

10,791

8,885

Kent

19,965

18,887

17,191

16,639

13,019

Lancashire

25,445

23,470

22,111

23,397

17,292

Leicestershire

13,211

10,692

10,624

9,962

7,907

Lincolnshire

11,927

10,591

10,029

9,534

6,345

London

99,150

87,736

98,058

108,937

102,861

Merseyside

16,347

20,006

22,787

24,377

18,885

Norfolk

10,553

10,212

9,383

8,553

7,424

Northamptonshire

8,856

8,789

7,748

7,239

5,341

Northumbria

30,626

30,659

25,119

23,318

19,275

North Wales

11,537

9,519

8,918

9,206

7,817

North Yorkshire

8,517

7,734

8,200

7,203

5,389

Nottinghamshire

14,729

13,928

16,508

11,607

11,086

South Wales

24,172

19,153

18,894

18,844

14,096

South Yorkshire

18,695

17,724

17,991

16,880

13,819

Staffordshire

16,180

14,826

13,446

10,986

9,327

Suffolk

8,130

7,028

8,538

10,084

6,103

Surrey

7,039

8,208

8,002

7,848

5,850

Sussex

15,947

13,579

11,904

12,069

9,496

Thames Valley

31,998

26,577

22,119

22,527

17,166

Warwickshire

6,175

5,115

4,595

5,387

4,734

West Mercia

18,580

17,332

15,463

14,363

10,793

West Midlands

40,371

37,275

35,403

34,017

21,743

West Yorkshire

37,552

32,437

30,947

28,595

25,749

Wiltshire

10,267

7,687

7,426

7,488

4,288

(1) January to October

Departmental Contracts

Ian Austin: To ask the Attorney-General what the monetary value is of contracts the Law Officers' Departments have awarded to each (a) management consultancy and (b) IT company since 7 May 2010. [16193]

The Attorney-General: The information is as follows:

Monetary value of contracts awarded by TSOL to management consultancy companies from 7 May 2010 to 31 October 2010

TSOL has awarded no contracts to management consultancy companies since 7 May 2010.

Monetary value of contracts awarded by TSOL to IT companies from 7 May 2010 to 31 October 2010
Company Value of contract (£)

Specialist computer centres

10,800

Insight

5,306

Kelway UK Ltd

149,538

Total

165,644


Monetary value of contracts awarded by the SFO to management consultancy companies from 7 May 2010 to 31 October 2010
Company Value of contracts (£)

Corven Consulting Ltd

(1)173,792

PA Consulting

(2)851,044

Skills for Justice

6,483

Total

1,031,319

(1) Includes £96,680 accrued
(2) Includes £213,660 accrued

Monetary value of contracts awarded by the SFO to IT companies from 7 May 2010 to 31 October 2010
Company Value of contracts (£)

COA Solutions Ltd

1,345

2E2 UK Ltd

2,625

Sanderson Forensics Ltd

16,263

Specialist Computer Centres plc

58,925

Sungard Vivista

3,142,000

Total

3,221,158


Monetary value of contracts awarded by the NFA to management consultancy companies from 7 May 2010 to 31 October 2010
Company Value of contracts (£)

Magic Beans Consultancy Ltd

400


Monetary value of contracts awarded by the NFA to IT companies from 7 May 2010 to 31 October 2010
Company Value of contracts (£)

BrightWave Ltd

29,493


The CPS, AGO and HMCPSI have not awarded any contracts to management consultancy or IT companies since 7 May 2010.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 687W

Newspaper Press: Telephone Tapping

Mr Watson: To ask the Attorney-General whether the Director of Public Prosecutions was informed that the Metropolitan Police Service held transcribed voicemail messages as part of its telephone hacking and blagging investigation; and if he will make a statement. [23795]

The Attorney-General: In 2006 two people were prosecuted for offences of conspiracy to intercept communications and related offences. The DPP at the time, Sir Ken McDonald QC, now Lord MacDonald of River Glavern, and the reviewing lawyer are no longer in post, and no information is contained in the prosecution file on this specific issue. It is not therefore possible to ascertain whether the DPP was informed that the Metropolitan Police Service held transcribed voicemail messages as part of its investigation into telephone hacking.

Prosecutions: Convictions

Mr Umunna: To ask the Attorney-General what proportion of prosecutions in each local authority area in each of the last 12 months resulted in a conviction. [24170]

The Solicitor-General: The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) collects data on prosecutions conducted by them. Other Government Departments and local authorities also conduct prosecutions, which are not captured in the data retained by the CPS. CPS data relate to defendants and not to individual offences, and are recorded on the basis of the 42 geographically separate CPS areas, not local authority areas.

Tables showing the percentage of convictions for each CPS area for each of the last 12 months in the period 2009-10, together with the total successful and unsuccessful outcomes for each CPS area, for each month in that year, have been deposited in the Library of the House.

Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Animal Health and Veterinary Laboratories Agency

Miss McIntosh: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what timetable she has set for the merger of Animal Health and the Veterinary Laboratories Agency; and if she will make a statement. [23725]

Mr Paice: The Secretary of State announced on 29 June that Animal Health and the Veterinary Laboratories Agency were going to be merged. We are aiming to formally merge these bodies on 1 April 2011. The merger will bring together services, expertise and scientific capability on animal health. In resource constrained times it will improve our resilience in delivering important services, including our animal disease emergency response capability and science requirements for animal health.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 688W

Animal Products: EU Law

Caroline Nokes: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what assessment she has made of the potential market for a facility to store animal products that do not comply with EU import requirements. [23280]

Mr Paice: The UK has no approved stores or warehouses for the storage of animal products that do not meet the EU import conditions.

The importation into the EU of animal products could pose a risk to animal and public health unless it is properly controlled. Each consignment of animal products must be accompanied by appropriate documentation and must enter the EU through a Border Inspection Post (BIP), where checks are carried out to ensure that import conditions have been met.

While Council Directive 97/78 (the Veterinary Checks Directive), provides that non-conforming animal products may be stored within the EU in specially approved warehouses, subject to stringent controls, provided their ultimate destination is outside the EU, the Directive also provides that member states can refuse to allow storage of such goods in their territory on the grounds that they pose an animal or public health risk.

The UK therefore deems these products to be a risk. Regulation 47 of the Products of Animal Origin (Third Country Imports) (England) Regulations 2006 prohibits imports of non-conforming products into a warehouse in free zones, a free warehouse or a customs warehouse in England.

Beak Trimming

Mary Creagh: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what the membership of the Beak Trimming Action Group will be once it has been reconvened. [24528]

Mr Paice: The Beak Trimming Action Group will consist of poultry industry representatives, poultry breeders, welfare groups, representatives from scientific and veterinary professions, researchers and DEFRA officials.

Mary Creagh: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs pursuant to the written ministerial statement of 8 November 2010, Official Report, columns 2-4WS, on beak trimming (laying hens), who will be responsible for the cost of industry study tours to European countries where beak trimming is not carried out. [24525]

Mr Paice: In order to progress towards a ban on beak trimming, I have asked the industry to carry out its own study tours to European countries-for example Austria, where beak trimming is not carried out-and to consider experiences from their industry colleagues. Results of these tours will be fed back to the Beak Trimming Action Group to consider when formulating an action plan that will work toward a future ban on this procedure.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 689W

Circuses: Animal Welfare

Caroline Lucas: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs when she expects to make an announcement on the outcome of the consultation on the use of wild animals in travelling circuses. [23888]

Mr Paice: An announcement will be made early in the new year.

Common Land

Alan Keen: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how many recommendations she received for the registration of new town and village greens in each of the last 10 years; how many new town and village greens were registered in each such year; and what size the town and village greens were in each case. [24278]

Richard Benyon: Commons registration authorities (county councils in two-tier local authority areas) are responsible for processing and determining applications to register land as a town or village green under section 15(1) of the Commons Act 2006.

The figures in the following table are estimates derived from surveys of commons registration authorities in England, and scaled up accordingly. The data include registrations made under section 13(b) of the Commons Registration Act 1965 (the predecessor to section 15(1) of the 2006 Act), but do not include registrations made on a voluntary application by the owner under section 15(8) of the 2006 Act. There are no national data available for 2000-02.

Greens registered

Number

2009 (to end of September)

17

2008

26

2007

18

2006

8

2005

30

2004

9

2003

10


No data are collected centrally on the size of registered greens. However, a sample study of 25 greens registered between 2001 and 2009 found that the median size was 0.3 hectares.

Alan Keen: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what recent representations her Department has received on legislation relating to the registration of new town and village greens; whether she plans to review this legislation; and if she will make a statement. [24279]

Richard Benyon: A number of representations have been received recently from Members of Parliament, local authorities, and others about the registration of land as town or village greens.

The Government are considering whether change to the greens registration system is required as part of their commitment to create a new designation to protect green areas, and as a response to the Penfold Review,
16 Nov 2010 : Column 690W
which recommended making changes to the registration system to remove obstacles to development. I hope to make an announcement later this year.

Alan Keen: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how many applications for the registration of town and village greens were rejected by commons registration authorities in each of the last 10 years. [24280]

Richard Benyon: The figures in the following table are estimates derived from surveys of commons registration authorities in England, and scaled up accordingly. The data include applications rejected under both section 15(1) of the Commons Act 2006, and section 13(b) of the Commons Registration Act 1965. There are no national data available for 2000-02.

Number of applications rejected

2009(1)

79

2008

52

2007

35

2006

16

2005

22

2004

29

2003

30

(1) To end of September.

Dangerous Dogs

Jane Ellison: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what recent discussions she has had with the Secretary of State for the Home Department on her Department's consultation on dangerous dogs. [23004]

Mr Paice: Discussions between officials at DEFRA and the Home Office about the link between antisocial behaviour and dangerous dogs are ongoing. An announcement about the publication of the summary of responses to the consultation on dangerous dogs and a way forward will be made soon.

Departmental Information Officers

Miss McIntosh: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how many press officers are employed by (a) her Department, (b) the Environment Agency, (c) Natural England and (d) each other non-departmental public body sponsored by her Department; and if she will make a statement. [23727]

Richard Benyon: The information requested is set out as follows.

(a) DEFRA-20 press officers
Desk Number of press officers

Head of News

1

Food, Farming and Animal Health and Welfare

6

Natural Environment, Rural Affairs, Water and Waste

6

Climate, Flooding and Science

4.5

Strategic Media Planning

2.5


16 Nov 2010 : Column 691W

(b) The Environment Agency-26.5 press officers
Region Number of press officers

Anglian

2

Midlands

3

Wales

2.5

North East

2

North West

2

South West

1

Southern

3

Thames

4

Head office

8


(c) Natural England

Number of press officers

Natural England

5


(d) Other non-departmental public bodies sponsored by DEFRA

Number of press officers

Marine Management Organisation

1

CEFAS

(1)-

Forestry Commission

3

British Waterways

2

Gangmasters Licensing Authority

1

Rural Payments Agency

(1)-

Food and Environment Research Agency

1

(1) Equivalent of 0.5 people's jobs

Departmental Lobbying

Robert Halfon: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (1) how much her Department's agencies and non-departmental public bodies spent from the public purse on influencing public policy through (a) employing external (i) public affairs companies, (ii) strategic consultancies and (iii) corporate communications firms, (b) external marketing and (c) other activities in each of the last 10 years; [23755]

(2) which of her Department's non-departmental public bodies have undertaken activities to influence public policy for which they engaged (a) public affairs and (b) public relations consultants in each year since 1997; and at what monetary cost in each such year. [23792]

Richard Benyon: None of my Department's agencies or non-departmental public bodies have spent public money on these activities.

Environment Agency: Watercourses

Karl McCartney: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what steps she is taking to ensure that the Environment Agency has adequate resources to maintain all its watercourses. [24529]

Richard Benyon: The Environment Agency is responsible for maintenance of watercourses designated as "main rivers". Local authorities will continue to be funded by Formula Grant for their responsibilities for ordinary watercourses.

Environment Agency resources to carry out routine maintenance will be protected as far as possible. They will continue to be targeted, on a risk based approach, towards the parts of the country where the consequences of flooding would be highest.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 692W

Livestock: Overseas Trade

Neil Parish: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how many live (a) horses, (b) asses, (c) mules and (d) hinnies have been (i) exported from and (ii) imported into the UK from (A) EU member states and (B) third countries in each of the last two years; and for what purposes these animals were exported and imported in each case. [23318]

Mr Paice: Details of the total number of live horses, asses, mules and hinnies exported from Great Britain and imported into the UK from EU member states and third countries for 2008 and 2009 are provided in the tables, as recorded in the Trade Control and Expert System (TRACES) and the Certification of Exports, Notification of Trade and Assessment of Underlying Risk (CENTAUR) databases.

Registered horses need not be recorded in TRACES as they can move freely between EU member states accompanied by a health attestation document, which is valid for 10 days, and a valid horse passport.

It is not possible to split these figures into individual categories of horses, asses, mules and hinnies or to ascertain for what purposes these animals were exported and imported as these data are not recorded.

Total number of live horses, asses, mules and hinnies exported from Great Britain 2008-09

2008 2009

EU

6,914

6,965

Non-EU

3,233

2,673

Total

10,147

9,638

Source:
Certification of Exports, Notification of Trade and Assessment of Underlying Risk (CENTAUR) database

Total number of live horses, asses, mules and hinnies imported into the UK 2008-09

2008 2009

EU

3,858

3,147

Non-EU

1,529

1,341

Total

5,387

4,488

Source:
European Commission's Trade Control and Expert System (TRACES) database

Ofwat

Mr Sanders: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (1) what mechanism her Department has to assess the impartiality of Ofwat; and what the outcome was of the most recent assessment made by Ministers; [23360]

(2) if she will assess the merits of merging Ofwat with (a) Ofgem and (b) the Consumer Council for Water; [23361]

(3) what recent assessment she has made of the performance of Ofwat against its objectives. [23372]

Richard Benyon: On 26 August the Secretary of State announced the launch of a review of Ofwat, with an accompanying call for evidence that closed on 29 October.

The review aims to ensure Ofwat is fit for future challenges. It is examining how the regulator works, whether it offers good value for money and if it is
16 Nov 2010 : Column 693W
delivering what Government and customers expect. The review is also looking at the effectiveness of the Consumer Council for Water and its relationship with Ofwat and the water companies. The terms of reference for the Ofwat review can be found on DEFRA's website.

The review team is working closely, where appropriate, with the Department for Energy and Climate Change's review of Ofgem, which is also under way.

The Ofwat review is being run in parallel with the Water White Paper which is due for publication in June next year. The review will feed into the White Paper's development.

Redundancy

Mary Creagh: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs how many redundancies she expects there to be in each pay grade in her Department in each of the next five years; and what estimate she has made of the cost of such redundancies to her Department in each year. [24526]

Richard Benyon: DEFRA will make the reduction in headcount through natural wastage and voluntary departures wherever possible, with compulsory redundancies as a last resort. Until we know the numbers who take up voluntary departure, it will not be possible to estimate the number of compulsory redundancies. However, overall, we expect DEFRA and its arm's-length bodies to have between 5,000 and 8,000 fewer jobs by 2015.

Water Supply: Industry

Mr Sanders: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs if she will assess the merits of measures to encourage water-intensive industries to locate in areas less prone to water shortages. [23362]

Richard Benyon: Business decisions on the best place to locate will take into account many factors, including the availability of adequate water supplies.

A water-intensive business will usually want to obtain a licence to abstract water from the environment as this is cheaper than paying for water supplied by water companies. Business can make use of the published information on water availability via the Environment Agency's catchment abstraction management strategies. These identify the availability of water resources for new abstractions, and areas where water is unlikely to be available.

In addition, there are mechanisms in place to encourage efficient use of water by businesses, including water-intensive industries. The water technology list identifies products, across a range of technologies, that are at the leading edge of efficient water consumption. These technologies benefit from enhanced capital allowances. Investments in such products give long-term financial benefits by reducing the amount of water that needs to be abstracted from the environment or obtained from the public water supply.

The Water White Paper, which we intend to publish in June next year, will address the question of the management of water resources, both now and in the future.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 694W

Wild Horses

Pat Glass: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs if she will bring forward proposals to reduce the incidence of wild horses damaging private property. [22600]

Mr Paice: I do not intend to bring forward proposals to reduce the incidence of "wild horses" damaging private property. Depending upon the circumstances and nature of the damage caused, the owners of those free roaming horses that cause damage may be liable under the Animals Act 1971. If any horses causing damage are not owned, they may be controlled in a legal and humane manner.

Wildlife: Internet

Mr Sanders: To ask the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs what progress has been made on reducing the level of wildlife trade on the internet since the last meeting of the Conference of Parties to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species. [24066]

Richard Benyon: Further to the response I gave the hon. Member on 12 July 2010, Official Report, columns 457-58W, DEFRA is in the final stages of commissioning a project to establish a baseline of the scope and volume of wildlife trade via the internet. This project will also develop a search methodology to monitor illegal activity which will be shared with enforcement agencies worldwide. Following receipt of the results of that project, DEFRA will consider how best to tackle the use of the internet for illegal wildlife sales, including the possible issuance of a code of conduct for internet operators.

Women and Equalities

Commonwealth Women's Affairs Ministerial Conference

Priti Patel: To ask the Minister for Women and Equalities how much the Government Equalities Office spent on attendance at the Commonwealth Women's Affairs Ministerial conference in June 2010; and how many civil servants attended. [22060]

Lynne Featherstone: The UK sent one senior civil servant to this conference, the head of Gender Equality Policy, who is based in the Government Equalities Office.

The cost including travel and subsistence of attending the meeting was £3,195.

Departmental Travel

Priti Patel: To ask the Minister for Women and Equalities how much the Government Equalities Office spent on (a) foreign travel, (b) hotels, (c) taxi fares and (d) rail travel in each year since it was established. [22058]

Lynne Featherstone: The Government Equalities Office was established on 12 October 2007. The total expenditure on all travel and subsistence is detailed in the following table. A breakdown of the expenditure into the categories requested can be provided only at disproportionate cost.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 695W
Travel and subsistence Total expenditure (£)

2007-08(1)

18,880

2008-09

79,891

2009-10

129,542

2010-11(2)

43,874

(1) From 12 October 2010
(2) As at 31 October 2010

Equal Pay

Priti Patel: To ask the Minister for Women and Equalities what steps she is taking to reduce the gender pay gap. [24207]

Lynne Featherstone: The Government are committed to tackling the barriers that women face in the workplace and are taking a range of measures including making pay secrecy clauses unenforceable, extending the right to request flexible working to all employees, consulting on a new system of parental leave, and promoting gender equality on company boards including asking Lord Davies to fully investigate the issue.

Government Equalities Office: Finance

Priti Patel: To ask the Minister for Women and Equalities what the administrative budget for the Government Equalities Office will be in each of the next five years. [24203]

Lynne Featherstone: The recent spending review settlement, covering the next four years, allocated an administration budget to the Government Equalities Office as follows:

£ million

2011-12

45.9

2012-13

41.9

2013-14

34.1

2014-15

25.2


The budget for 2015-16 will be fixed by the next spending review.

The budget for the Government Equalities Office covers the costs of its non-departmental public body, the Equality and Human Rights Commission.

Transport

A69

John Stevenson: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will take steps to upgrade the remaining part of the A69 between Carlisle and Newcastle upon Tyne to a dual carriageway. [19629]

Mike Penning [holding answer 28 October 2010]: The Secretary of State for Transport announced on 26 October 2010, Official Report, columns 177-79W, the Department's plans for funding road improvement schemes for the spending review period, to the end of 2014-15.

The Department for Transport will also take forward work on a number of schemes already under consideration for the next spending review period. At present, the Department is not developing proposals for future schemes on this section of the A69.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 696W

Alloy Wheels

Mr Watson: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what data his Department collects on road accidents where defective alloy wheels were a contributing factor to the cause of that accident; and if he will make a statement. [23828]

Mike Penning: The Department for Transport does not collect any data on whether defective alloy wheels were a contributing factor to the cause of a road accident.

The Department holds several datasets on road accidents. In addition to the police road casualty data (STATS19) there are several in depth studies-the On the Spot study (OTS), the Co-operative Crash Injury Study (CCIS) and the Heavy Vehicle Crash Injury Study (HVCIS). None of these datasets holds any information on whether defective alloy wheels contributed to an accident.

Bus Services

Ben Gummer: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport if he will take steps to assist competing bus companies to reach co-operative agreements to provide regular services on (a) Wherstead road in Ipswich constituency and (b) other routes with an identified need. [24510]

Norman Baker: The regulatory framework for buses permits co-operative agreements between bus operators as long as certain conditions are met. We have seen good results in places where local authorities and operators work effectively in partnership to improve bus services-such as in Brighton, York and Cambridge.

While it is the role of Government to set this framework and encourage more of this type of activity for the benefit of bus passengers in Ipswich and elsewhere it is up to local authorities and communities to make it happen. This might be a local authority making a statutory quality bus partnership scheme, as in Nottingham, or instead endorsing a qualifying agreement between two operators, as in Oxford.

Ultimately, however, it is for commercial operators to decide whether to run services such as the route 66 bus in Ipswich, and at what frequency. If a service is not considered commercially viable, a local authority can decide it wishes to tender for and support a replacement service, or discuss with the local community alternative forms of transport provision.

Bus Services: Finance

Mr Betts: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what research his Department has (a) commissioned and (b) evaluated on the likely effects on (i) bus fares and (ii) service levels of the reduction in bus service operators grant proposed in the spending review. [22266]

Norman Baker: The Department for Transport has not commissioned or evaluated any specific research on the likely effects on bus fares and service levels of the reduction in bus service operators grant proposed in the spending review.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 697W

With regard to the potential impacts of a reduction in bus service operators grant on fares and bus services I refer the hon. Member to the answer of 15 November 2010, Official Report, column 570W.

Bus Services: Information Services

Mrs Moon: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport whether he plans to amend the Public Service Vehicle Accessibility Regulations 2000 to require on-board audio and visual passenger information systems on buses. [24156]

Norman Baker: Research has been commissioned to assess the costs and benefits of installing audio visual systems on buses. The research project has brought together a cross-section of stakeholders, including Guide Dogs, Royal National Institute of Blind People and Royal National Institute for Deaf People. We will take account of the results of this work in considering any changes to the Public Service Vehicle Accessibility Regulations 2000 (PSVAR). The project is due to report shortly.

Cycling

Ian Austin: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what assessment he has made of changes in the level of cycling in each cycling city and town in the latest period for which figures are available; and if he will make a statement. [23415]

Norman Baker: In 2005 the Department for Transport funded six cycling towns and in 2008 this funding was extended to include a further 11 cycling towns and one city until March 2011. Their remit was to increase significantly their cycling levels.

Preliminary evaluation of the first six cycling demonstration towns (CDTs) provided evidence of early changes in the levels of cycling and physical activity in CDTs across a range of indicators, including a 1 percentage point increase in the estimated proportion of people cycling for 30 minutes at least three times a week, and a 27% increase in levels of cycling as measured by automatic cycle counts. Taken together, these findings (published by Cycling England in 2009) strongly suggest that cycling levels were observably increasing in the CDTs three years after the initiative began, with some evidence indicating that similar increases were not occurring in comparable areas.

Monitoring of cycling levels in the CDTs is ongoing until at least 2011, in order to capture data on the longer-term trends in these towns.

Independent evaluation and monitoring of the 12 new CCTs (cycling city and towns) is scheduled to run until 2012, with final results (including the results of a large-scale pre-and post-intervention household survey) available in 2012-13. Analysis of the monitoring data will not be conducted until a suitable time series is available, to enable intervention effects to be distinguished from seasonal and other natural fluctuations in the data.

Dartford-Thurrock Crossing: Tolls

Jackie Doyle-Price: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport when he plans to bring forward proposals to increase charges at the Dartford-Thurrock crossing; and if he will make a statement. [22276]


16 Nov 2010 : Column 698W

Mike Penning: The Department for Transport intends to begin the necessary consultation on proposals for the new charging regime at the Dartford crossing around the end of 2010.

Increasing the charges as proposed allows future investment in improvements at the crossing, including the implementation of free-flow charging technology, and funding of proposals for a new, additional lower Thames crossing in the longer term.

Departmental Conditions of Employment

Jeremy Corbyn: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport how many civil servants in his Department have used the flexible benefits project to carry out cost comparison of products to date. [23878]

Norman Baker: The Department for Transport's "Your Reward" portal enables staff to view and purchase a range of products offered with retailer discounts. Since the scheme came into operation in November 2009, 88,151 viewings have been recorded to date. There is no information about whether the purpose was to carry out cost comparisons or to view and purchase products.

Departmental Pay

Priti Patel: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what allowances and payments in addition to salary were available to officials in his Department and its non-departmental public bodies in each year since 1997; and what the monetary value was of payments and allowances of each type in each such year. [18720]

Norman Baker: Within the Department for Transport, its seven executive agencies and its non-departmental public bodies there are a number of different allowances and payments available to employees who meet the relevant criteria.

However, I regret that a breakdown of these allowances and payments, or their monetary values, can be provided only at disproportionate cost.

Departmental Policy

Mr Watson: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what departmental policy reviews his Department has undertaken since 6 May 2010; on what date each such review (a) was announced and (b) is expected to publish its findings; what estimate he has made of the cost of each such review; who has been appointed to lead each such review; to what remuneration each review leader is entitled; how many (i) full-time equivalent civil servants and (ii) seconded staff are working on each such review; from which organisations such staff have been seconded; and how much on average such seconded staff will be paid for their work on the review. [21875]

Norman Baker: I refer the hon. Member to my answer of 6 July 2010, Official Report, column 140W.

Departmental Redundancy

Philip Davies: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport how many staff of (a) his Department and (b) its agencies have been offered enhanced early retirement packages in each of the last three years. [22030]


16 Nov 2010 : Column 699W

Norman Baker: The number of staff offered enhanced early retirement packages in (a) the Department for Transport and (b) its agencies in each of the last three years is set out in the following tables:

(a) Department for Transport

Number

2008

7

2009

1

2010

114


(b) Agencies

2008 2009 2010

Government Car and Despatch Agency

1

1

10

Driving Standards Agency

11

4

2

Driver Vehicle and Licensing Agency

33

49

0

Highways Agency

24

2

6

Maritime and Coastguard Agency

29

4

3

Vehicle Certification Agency

0

0

0

Vehicle and Operator Service Agency

7

99

0

Total for agencies

105

159

21


Departmental Work Experience

Luciana Berger: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport how many interns his Department has engaged in the last 12 months; and how many were (a) unpaid, (b) remunerated with expenses only and (c) paid a salary. [17210]

Norman Baker: In the last 12 months the Department for Transport has engaged 16 interns. They were all paid a salary above the minimum wage while on their internship.

Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee

Gavin Shuker: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what the cost to the public purse was of running the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee in each of the last three years. [24455]

Norman Baker: The total cost of the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee, including staff costs, research costs, members' remuneration and expenses was as follows:

£

2007-08

294,368

2008-09

375,119

2009-10

486,795


Gavin Shuker: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport what estimate he has made of the potential saving to the public purse as a result of the abolition of the Disabled Persons Transport Advisory Committee. [24458]


16 Nov 2010 : Column 700W

Norman Baker: I refer the hon. Member to my answer of 2 November 2010, Official Report, column 703W.

Institute for Fiscal Studies

Robert Halfon: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport how much his Department has spent on services provided by the Institute for Fiscal Studies in each year since its creation. [23400]

Norman Baker: The Department for Transport was formed in May 2002 and information is provided from that date or the date an agency was formed, if later.

The central Department has spent the following on services provided by the Institute for Fiscal Studies:

£

2003-04

1,275

2004-05

2,743

2006-07

200

2009-10

575


The central Department has no spend on services provided by the Institute for Fiscal Studies in financial years other than those listed above.

None of the seven executive agencies of the Department has any spend on services provided by the Institute for Fiscal Studies.

M18: Speed Limits

Mr Knight: To ask the Secretary of State for Transport for what reasons a 50 mph temporary speed limit was in force on the M18 motorway on 1 November 2010; what guidance he provides to the Highways Agency on the imposition of temporary speed limits when work is not being carried out; and if he will make a statement. [24199]

Mike Penning: Work to replace the central reserve safety barrier is taking place in stages on the M18 between junctions 2 and to the north of junction 4. This is the first in a series of four schemes being undertaken between September 2010 and the end of March 2011.

In order to undertake the work safely and with the minimum of disruption to the road user the hard shoulder is being used to maintain the full complement of running lanes throughout the day. In order to do this a temporary 50mph speed restriction is required. This restriction remains in place on each stage until all the work has been completed and the hard shoulder reinstated.

On 1 November works to replace the central reserve barrier had been completed. The hard shoulder, however, was coned off because works to reinstate the verge safety barriers and inspection chambers were taking place. Works were also being undertaken in the northbound verge to repair drains and install new gullies. Additionally, to the north of junction 3 works were taking place to install both a temporary closed circuit television system in the north and southbound verges as well as speed camera cabling in the southbound verge, for the next stage of barrier works.


16 Nov 2010 : Column 701W

On the evening of 1 November night time works to reinstate road markings, which involved a lane closure, were suspended to allow a wide load to pass safely through the works area.

National advice on setting temporary speed limits is given in Traffic Signs Manual Chapter 8 which is developed by the Highways Agency on behalf of Department for Transport. This identifies appropriate speed limits based on the relative risk to road users. This risk is normally the same whether road workers are present or not. The Highways Agency produced additional advice in July 2007 (Chief Highways Engineer Memo 203/07) on how to apply temporary speed limits at road works using the risk based approach in Chapter 8.


Next Section Index Home Page