Appointment of the Chief of the Defence Staff - Defence Committee Contents


Letter from Peter Luff MP, Minister for Defence Equipment, Support and Technology, Ministry of Defence, to the Chair

One of the conclusions of the Strategic Defence and Security Review which was announced in Parliament on 19 October was our decision not to bring into service the Nimrod MRA4 maritime patrol aircraft programme. Instead, we will continue to depend on other military assets to contribute to the tasks that were previously planned for the MRA4 aircraft. As I know that you have a strong interest in this project, I am writing to inform you of our intentions for taking its cancellation forward.

The decision not to bring the Nimrod MRA4 into service was difficult, owing to the nature of the military tasks to which it was designed to contribute, the amount of public money that had been spent on it, and the impact of the decision on the people who have dedicated their careers to delivering this capability, or who depend on it for their livelihoods. However, the severe financial pressures faced by the nation and the urgent need to bring the defence programme into balance meant that we could not retain all our existing programmes, and we had to prioritise those capabilities that we could continue to maintain. The MRA4 project has suffered from repeated delays and cost overruns. But it was the value for money decision when considering the aircraft's future support costs against the capability it was set to provide that contributed to the decision not to bring it into service, despite its advanced state. It would have cost significant amounts to operate and maintain the aircraft, and we estimate that around £2 billion will be saved over the next 10 years by not bringing the aircraft into service.

Since that difficult decision was taken, officials have been discussing with BAE Systems arrangements to terminate the contracts for production and support of the aircraft. I have considered a range of options for the disposal of the Nimrod MRA4 fleet and concluded that the most cost effective option is for the nine aircraft to be disposed of, following recovery of equipment and systems that can be used elsewhere. Discussions are continuing with BAE Systems on the detail of the disposal.

I am very conscious of the impact of this decision on those people who have been working on the project and those who were due to have operated and supported the aircraft, and their families. Both the Prime Minister and the Defence Secretary have said the Government will take into account the regional economic and social impacts of our decisions when they are made.

1 December 2010


 
previous page contents

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2011
Prepared 27 January 2011