The attached document provides the information held
by HM Treasury on the PFI projects which were approved or conditionally
approved by the Project Review Group. These records cover the
period from January 2005 to March 2010. The Project Review Group
was a cross-departmental body, chaired by the Treasury, responsible
for approving PFI Credit funding provided by departments to local
authorities. The attached data is at the date of the Outline Business
Case for each project. No new centrally funded local authority
projects have been approved since March 2010. The funding arrangements
for local PFI projects were changed at last year's spending review
and the functions of the PRG since have been transferred into
the central Treasury approval process.
The information shows the percentage by which the
value for money of the privately financed option exceeded that
of the public sector comparator.
The data held for these projects is at the time of
the Outline Business Case. The final project documentation, including
information about tax expectations, is not held by Treasury and
therefore cannot be provided.
| Date of PRG Meeting
| Department | Local Authority
| Project | VfM of PFI vs. PSC
|
| 18-Mar-10 | Home Office
| WYPA | WYPA Operation and Training Accommodation Project
| 3.51% |
| 18-Mar-10 | Home Office
| Avon and Somerset Police Authority
| Avon & Somerset Police Accommodation Project
| 3.56% |
| 16-Mar-10 | CLG
| Staffordshire Fire and Rescue
| Staffordshire Fire and Rescue Service PFI 2
| 4.73% |
| 16-Mar-10 | DfT
| Birmingham City Council
| Birmingham Highways Management and Maintenance PFI Project (Additional Credits)
| 16.41% |
| 16-Mar-10 | DEFRA
| North London Waste Authority
| Residual Waste and Fuel Use Project
| Waste services, 7.2%, Fuel Use 5.8%
|
| 16-Feb-10 | CLG
| Stoke-on-Trent City Council
| Extra Care Housing PFI
| 4.14% |
| 16-Feb-10 | DfT
| Isle of Wight council |
Isle of Wight highways Maintainence
| 13.68% |
| 16-Feb-10 | DH
| Leeds City Council |
Holt Park Wellbeing Centre |
4.14% |
| 17-Nov-09 | DFT
| London Borough of Hounslow
| Hounslow Highways Maintainence
| 9.37% |
| 20-Oct-09 | DEFRA
| Essex County Council and Southend-on-Sea Borough Council
| Essex Waste Management Partnership PFI
| 7.50% |
| 21-Jul-09 | DfT
| Nottingham City Council
| Nottingham Express Transit (Phase 2)
| 10.40% |
| 21-Jul-09 | CLG
| Kent County Council |
Kent Excellent Homes for All
| 5.00% |
| 19-May-09 | DEFRA
| Solihull MBC, Coventry City Council and Warwickshire County Council
| Project Transform |
9.60% |
| 19-May-09 | CLG
| London Fire & Emergency Planning Authority
| London Fire Brigade Property PFI Project
| 6.00% |
| 31-Mar-09 | DfT
| Sheffield City Council
| Sheffield Highways Maintenance
| 12.40% |
| 17-Mar-09 | DEFRA
| Norfolk County Council
| Norfolk County Council Residual Waste Treatment Project (Contract B)
| 6.94% |
| 17-Mar-09 | DEFRA
| Hertfordshire County Council
| Hertfordshire Primary Waste Project (PWP)
| 14.70% |
| 17-Mar-09 | DEFRA
| London Boroughs of Croydon, Merton, Sutton and Royal Borough of Kingston
| South London Waste Partnership
| 14.39% |
| 17-Feb-09 | DEFRA
| Greater Manchester |
Greater Manchester Waste Disposal Authority
| 18.44% |
| 17-Feb-09 | DEFRA
| Kingston Upon Hull & East Riding of Yorkshire Councils
| Hull & East Riding of Yorkshire Waste PFI
| 14.20% |
| 18-Nov-08 | Home Office
| Gloucestershire Police Authority
| Gloucestershire Police Divisional Headquarters
| 3.25% |
| 18-Nov-08 | Defra
| Milton Keynes Council & Northamptonshire County Council
| Joint Residual Waste Management Project
| 14.80% |
| 21-Oct-08 | Defra
| Gloucestershire County Council
| Gloucestershire Waste Project
| 20.00% |
| 21-Oct-08 | CLG (Housing)
| London Borough of Brent
| Brent non-HRA Housing and Social Care PFI Project
| 2.60% |
| 21-Oct-08 | CLG (Housing)
| Salford City Council |
Pendleton HRA Housing PFI Scheme
| 9.43% |
| 30-Sep-08 | DfT
| Harrow Council | Harrow Street Lighting Project
| 16.80% |
| 16-Sep-08 | Defra
| Leicestershire County Council
| Leceistershire Waste |
11.45% |
| 16-Sep-08 | Defra
| Plymouth City Council, Torbay Council, Devon County Council
| South West Devon Waste Partnership
| 8.60% |
| 15-Jul-08 | DfT
| Cambridgeshire County Council (CCC) and Northamptonshire County Council (NCC)
| Cambridgeshire and Northamptonshire Street lighting PFI Project
| Capital Expenditure: Cambs: 8.25%, Northants 6.97%; Lifecycle: Cambs: 8.26% and Northants: 3.82%; Operating Costs: Cambs: 9.82% and Northants: 7.38%.
|
| 15-Jul-08 | DEFRA
| Staffordshire County Council (SCC)
| Staffs Waste (W2R) |
22.97% |
| 15-Jul-08 | DEFRA
| Collaboration between Gateshead Council, South Tyneside Council, Sunderland City Council
| South Tyne & Wear Waste PFI
| 25.11% |
| 17-Jun-08 | CLG
| Collaboration between Cumbria, Lancashire & Merseyside Fire & Rescue Authorities
| North West Fire & Rescue Services PFI Project
| 4.70% |
| 17-Jun-08 | CLG
| North Tyneside | Older People Homes for the Future (HRA)
| 7.34% |
| 20-May-08 | CLG
| Suffolk County Council
| Suffolk Fire and Rescue
| 8.18% |
| 25-Mar-08 | DEFRA
| Leeds | Waste
| 12.30% |
| 25-Mar-08 | DfT
| Knowsley | Street Lighting
| 5.47% |
| 25-Mar-08 | DEFRA
| Bradford | Waste
| 21.75% |
| 25-Mar-08 | DEFRA
| Suffolk County Council
| Waste | 7.95%
|
| 18-Mar-08 | CLG
| Woking | Housing
| 5.05% |
| 18-Mar-08 | CLG
| Leeds | Housing
| 12.00% |
| 18-Mar-08 | DEFRA
| Barnsley, Doncaster & Rotherham
| Waste | 19.93%
|
| 18-Mar-08 | CLG
| Gloucester | Fire
| 8.30% |
| 18-Dec-07 | DfT
| Coventry City Council |
Coventry Street Lighting |
9.37% |
| 18-Dec-07 | DfT
| Croydon and Lewisham |
Croydon and Lewisham Street Lighting
| 18.80% |
| 18-Dec-07 | CLG
| Manchester City Council
| Manchester Collyhurst HRA Housing
| 7.23% |
| 18-Dec-07 | DfT
| Hampshire County, Southampton City and West Sussex County Councils
| South Coast Street Lighting
| 14.20% |
| 18-Sep-07 | DfT
| Blackpool Council |
Blackpool Streetlighting |
10.50% |
| 18-Sep-07 | DfT
| Sheffield City Council
| Sheffield Streetlighting
| 10.10% |
| 18-Sep-07 | DfT
| Nottingham City Council
| Nottingham Streetlighting
| 15.90% |
| 18-Sep-07 | DfT
| Birmingham City Council
| Birmingham Highways Maintenance
| 16.41% |
| 18-Sep-07 | DfT
| Rochdale Metropolitan Borough Council and Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council
| Rochdale and Oldham Streetlighting
| 4.55% (Oldham) and 7.56% (Rochdale)
|
| 23-Jul-07 | DCSF
| Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council
| Sandwell Building Schools for the Future - Phase 1 (BSF Wave 3)
| 3.80% |
| 23-Jul-07 | DEFRA
| North Yorkshire County Council and City of York Council
| York and North Yorkshire Waste PFI
| 10.10% |
| 23-Jul-07 | DCSF
| Derbyshire County Council
| Derbyshire Building Schools for the Future (BSF Wave 3)
| 3.50% |
| 23-Jul-07 | CLG
| Nottingham City Council
| Bulwell Joint Service Centre
| 10.33% |
| 15-May-07 | CLG
| Manchester City Council
| Manchester Brunswick HRA Housing PFI
| 10.20% |
| 17-Apr-07 | DEFRA
| Merseyside Waste Disposal Authority
| Waste Management Project
| 13.10% |
| 17-Apr-07 | CLG
| Stoke on Trent & Staffordshire Fire Rescue Authority
| Community Fire Stations
| 10.43% |
| 17-Apr-07 | DfT
| Cumbria County Council
| Carlisle Northern Development Relief Route
| 8.50% |
| 20-Mar-07 | DH
| East Eussex | East Sussex Age Well Project
| 12.00% |
| 20-Mar-07 | CLG
| Oldham Metropolitan Borough Council
| Oldham Gateways HRA Housing Project
| 6.10% |
| 16-Jan-07 | DCLG
| Wigan Borough Council |
Wigan Joint Service Centre |
7.20% |
| 16-Jan-07 | DCSF
| Birmingham City Council
| BSF Wave 2 | 8.90%
|
| 21-Nov-06 | DfT
| TfL | Thames Gateway Bridge
| 7.00% |
| 21-Nov-06 | DCMS
| Bristol City Council |
Hengrove Park Leisure PFI |
20.00% |
| 21-Nov-06 | DCLG
| Leeds City Council |
Leeds Little London HRA Housing PFI
| 10.32% |
| 17-Oct-06 | DfES (now DCSF)
| City of Nottingham |
BSF. First Phase. | 3.60%
|
| 19-Sep-06 | DfES (now DCSF)
| Kent County Council |
BSF. First Phase. | 6.00%
|
| 19-Sep-06 | DCMS
| Liverpool City Council
| Liverpool Central Library and Archive
| 11.96% |
| 15-Aug-06 | DCLG
| London Borough of Newham
| Forest Gate HRA PFI project.
| 7.76% |
| 20-Jul-06 | DFES (Now DCSF)
| London Borough of Newham BSF
| Newham BSF | 5.00%
|
| 20-Jul-06 | DCLG
| North East Fire and Rescue Authority (NEFRA)
| Accommodation PFI project
| 6.40% |
| 20-Jul-06 | DEFRA
| Cornwall County Council
| Integrated waste management project.
| 7.43% |
| 16-May-06 | DfES (now DCSF)
| South Tyneside and Gateshead
| BSF. First phase of STaG project
| 4.17% |
| 16-May-06 | DEFRA
| Cheshire | Waste PFI
| 17.63% |
| 18-Apr-06 | DfES (now DCSF)
| Islington BC | BSF - Phase 1, Wave 2.
| 10.94% |
| 24-Mar-06 | ODPM
| Derby City Council |
Non HRA Housing PFI | 11.00%
|
| 20-Mar-06 | ODPM
| Lambeth Council | Myatts Field North HRA Housing PFI
| 9.36% |
| 20-Mar-06 | ODPM
| West Wiltshire District Council
| Non HRA Housing PFI |
14.30% |
| 21-Feb-06 | ODPM
| London Borough of Lewisham
| Lewisham HRA Brockley PFI Project
| 12.50% |
| 17-Jan-06 | ODPM
| Oldham Council | Sheltered Housing PFI Project
| 16.00% |
| 20-Dec-05 | DCMS
| Newcastle City Council
| Newcastle Libraries PFI
| 13.70% |
| 20-Dec-05 | ODPM
| Manchester City Council
| 2nd Round Housing (HRA) PFI Scheme - Miles Platting Neighbourhood
| 3.30% |
| 15-Nov-05 | ODPM / DoH
| Leeds City Council |
Independent Living Project |
8.50% |
| 16-Aug-05 | DFES
| Waltham Forest | BSF - Phase 1
| 8.40% |
| 16-Aug-05 | ODPM
| Kirklees Council | Housing PFI - Round 3
| 11.26% |
| 19-Jul-05 | DfT
| Norfolk County Council
| Street Lighting | 9.00%
|
| 19-Jul-05 | Home Office
| Norfolk Constabulary |
Three Counties Police Investigation Centre Project
| 7.30% |
| 06-May-05 | DFES
| Leicester Council |
BSF - Phase 1 | 10.00%
|
| 06-May-05 | DFES
| Leeds City Council |
BSF - Phase 1 | 5.88%
|
| 06-May-05 | DFES
| Newcastle Council |
BSF - Phase 1 | 8.10%
|
| 06-May-05 | ODPM
| Cheshire County Council
| Extra Care Housing PFI
| 14.00% |
| 06-May-05 | ODPM
| Kent County Council |
Non-HRA Housing PFI | 6.30%
|
| 15-Mar-05 | DFES
| Knowsley MBC | BSF Phase 1
| 4.74% |
| 15-Feb-05 | DFES
| London Borough of Lewisham
| BSF Phase 1 | 4.62%
|
| 15-Feb-05 | DFES
| Lancashire County Council
| BSF Phase 1 | 2.11%
|
| 18-Jan-05 | DFES
| London Borough of Greenwich
| BSF Phase 1 | 4.80%
|
| 18-Jan-05 | DEFRA
| Cambridgeshire County Council
| Waste PFI Project |
15.44% |
| 18-Jan-05 | DEFRA
| London Borough of Southwark
| Waste Management PFI |
21.07% |
| 18-Jan-05 | DEFRA
| Greater Manchester Waste Disposal Authority
| Post Collection Waste Services PFI
| 14.00% |
