Environment Audit CommitteeWritten evidence submitted by Simon Trevan, support worker, Plymouth City Council
Background
Part of my role and the role of St George Community Resource Centre, within Plymouth City Council is to support adults with learning disabilities to access community based facilities, usually facilities such as sports centres, shops and voluntary work places.
Where possible we enable people to access public transport services, mainly buses.
The people that we support, in the St George CRC, require support to access these services. There are a few people attending St George who can access transport (buses and taxis) independently.
There are many people in Plymouth, with Learning Disabilities, who live more independently (living on their own or in supported living situations) than attendees at St George (mainly living in their family homes).
To support this group of people a Consultation Event relating to transport and associated issues was launched to help enable access to public transport and thus services that people need within their communities.
Consultation Event
Slides from the Transport Consultation Event held in Plymouth have not been reproduced here.
Part of the event was to gather feedback from people who attended to inform the council and other service delivery.
Below is the feedback as recorded.
TRANSPORT EVENT CONSULTATION FEEDBACK
What’s good about travelling on buses and taxis?
Buses |
Taxis |
||
— |
Get on with the drivers (polite) |
— |
Availability—particularly taxis |
— |
Can get any bus, on a good bus route |
— |
You get to your destination quicker when in a taxi |
— |
It’s free x 2 |
— |
Taxi better—wait out in the cold bus stop |
— |
Drivers telling people that are drunk to get off the bus |
— |
Taxis—are quicker- not waiting for a bus |
— |
Some people enjoy travelling on buses |
— |
Lots of taxis, more than buses |
— |
Nice people on the bus |
— |
Taxis come to your door |
— |
Nice bus drivers |
— |
I like to travel on taxis then buses—too many people on buses |
— |
To help to travel around |
||
— |
Safe on the bus |
||
— |
Gets you to A-B |
||
— |
Lots of buses on different routes, most areas covered |
||
— |
Nice scenery |
||
— |
Drivers are very helpful x 2 |
||
— |
Buses have cameras to help protect the passengers |
||
— |
I got no problems with buses |
||
— |
I can use my bus pass x 3 |
||
— |
Independence |
||
— |
Warm and clean |
||
— |
Ok when they are on time |
||
— |
Great as I have a bus pass x 2 |
||
— |
Being able to get out and about x 2 |
||
— |
Key card good for travelling |
||
— |
Frequency of First—Park and Ride Milehouse Service |
||
— |
Get’s you to your destination |
||
— |
I can travel independently |
||
— |
Park and ride a lot cheaper |
TRANSPORT EVENT CONSULTATION FEEDBACK
What’s bad about travelling on buses and taxis?
Buses |
Taxis |
||
— |
Journeys take too long |
— |
Taxis are very expensive x 9 |
— |
Move off before you sat down x 2 |
— |
I don’t trust taxi drivers |
— |
Not enough time to set off |
— |
Taxi fare starts off before it sets off |
— |
Paying for support staff |
— |
You can not eat food in Taxis |
— |
They don’t run on time and are always late x 4 |
— |
Taxis are not safe |
— |
The teenagers swear a lot on the bus |
— |
Some taxi drivers, pedestrians make me feel nervous |
— |
Rude and unhelpful drivers x 5 |
— |
Bad time keeping for buses and taxis |
— |
The bus service stops too early on a Sunday x 2 |
— |
Taxis don’t always park on the right side of the road and I don’t feel safe crossing on my own. |
— |
Prices on the bus |
— |
Relying on staff to book my taxis, I would rather do it myself |
— |
Need to put more buses |
||
— |
Not letting blind people sit down before setting off |
||
— |
Need more room for prams and wheelchairs |
||
— |
Cost (concessions) before 9:30 am |
||
— |
Dodgy readers |
||
— |
Support worker (named—not named) |
||
— |
Multi-trip—(£1.50 per journey)—share? Just Plymouth? |
||
— |
Not park and ride |
||
— |
Don’t turn up on time or don’t turn up at all x 5 |
||
— |
Buses break down often, people left standing outside in the cold x 3 |
||
— |
When buses are running late they will drive through on amber light or they don’t stop at the bus stop at all |
||
— |
Too expensive |
||
— |
Too many lights |
||
— |
People at the back of the driver |
||
— |
Bad time keeping for buses and taxis |
||
— |
Prices of bus fares went up just before Christmas, no explanation why prices went up just a notice on a board. But some people with learning disabilities did not understand or could not read it. |
||
— |
School kids do not give up their seats for the needy |
||
— |
Lots of drunken people on buses x 2 |
||
— |
Drivers not happy |
||
— |
School kids vandalise the seats and play around on the buses |
||
— |
Not enough time to get up off the seat |
||
— |
Not many buses on Sundays when most people need to travel |
||
— |
Some buses are overcrowded |
||
— |
Not enough buses on certain days (weekends, holidays) |
||
— |
Drivers don’t wait if they see you rushing for the bus |
||
— |
Confusing timetable to figure out (holidays etc) |
||
— |
Not happy because we cannot use bus passes before 9:30 |
||
— |
Sometimes people are bullied on the bus and the driver may not have noticed |
||
— |
Some buses have litter on the floor |
||
— |
Where to catch the bus |
||
— |
Waiting outside in the cold bus stop |
||
— |
Me and my mum don’t like the bus being late |
||
— |
Sometimes have to walk too far |
||
— |
More money |
||
TRANSPORT EVENT CONSULTATION FEEDBACK
What would make travelling on buses and taxis better?
Buses |
Taxis |
||
— |
Making the timetables easier to understand, explaining things better |
— |
Taxis should be cheaper—stick to a firm you trust |
— |
Making the timetable more realistic—length of time it takes a bus to travel from one place to another |
— |
Taxis drivers should treat people better |
— |
More buses on the road |
— |
Taxis are expensive, they should be cheaper to use x 2 |
— |
Would like to use travel pass before 9:30 x 7 |
— |
Have taxis drivers CRB checked |
— |
More security cameras on board |
— |
Provide a taxi service that is suited to transport vulnerable adults |
— |
Cheaper tickets x 2 |
— |
Proper monitoring of cars and drivers |
— |
To lower floor more to make it easier to get on |
— |
All women taxi service |
— |
More room for prams and wheelchairs x 2 |
— |
More CCTV in taxis and buses |
— |
Make buses that don’t break down |
||
— |
The bus arriving on time and being more reliable x 4 |
||
— |
More “electronic table” information at bus stops |
||
— |
Patience and understanding of my disability |
||
— |
I want to be able to use my free bus pass x 2 |
||
— |
Sunday times more frequent |
||
— |
More buses at peak times |
||
— |
Better communication |
||
— |
Rural buses stop early in the evening prepare to have later buses |
||
— |
More drivers and more buses/route |
TRANSPORT EVENT CONSULTATION FEEDBACK
What would make travelling on buses and taxis better?
Buses |
Taxis |
||
— |
Timetables easier to read, digital screens are easier |
||
— |
More CCTV in taxis and buses |
||
— |
Having good looking bus drivers, not having bad tempered ones |
||
— |
Letting people get on with a £5 note and refusing them and telling them to get change from the shop and missing the bus |
||
— |
More considerate staff |
||
— |
Drivers could be more polite and friendlier and more patient x 2 |
||
— |
The drivers being more helpful x 3 |
5 September 2012