First Report of Session 2013-14 - European Scrutiny Committee Contents



Annex: Questions posed in the Green Paper

General

  • Which lessons from the 2020 framework and present state of the EU energy system are most important when designing policies for 2030?

Targets

  • Which targets for 2030 would be most effective in driving the objectives of climate and energy policy? At what level should they apply (EU, Member State, or sectoral), and to what extent should they be legally binding?
  • Have there been any inconsistencies in the current 2020 targets and if so how can be coherence of potential 2030 targets be better ensured?
  • Are targets for sub-sectors such as transport, agriculture, industry appropriate, and, if so, which ones? For example, is a renewables target necessary for transport, given the targets for carbon dioxide reduction for passenger cars and light commercial vehicles?
  • How can targets better reflect the economic viability and the changing degree of maturity of technologies in the 2030 framework?
  • How should progress be assessed for other aspects of EU energy policy, such as security of supply, which may not be captured by the headline targets?

Instruments

  • Are changes necessary to other policy instruments and how they interact with one another, including between the EU and national levels?
  • How should specific measures at the EU and national level best be defined to optimise cost-efficiency of meeting climate and energy objectives?
  • How can fragmentation of the internal energy market best be avoided, particularly in relation to the need to encourage and mobilise investment?
  • Which measures could be envisaged to make further energy savings most cost-effectively?
  • How can EU research and innovation policies best support the achievement of the 2030 framework?

Competitiveness and security of supply

  • Which elements of the framework for climate and energy policies could be strengthened to better promote job creation, growth and competitiveness?
  • What evidence is there for carbon leakage under the current framework and can this be quantified? How could this problem be addressed in the 2030 framework?
  • What are the specific drivers in observed trends in energy costs and to what extent can the EU influence them?
  • How should uncertainty about efforts and the level of commitments that other developed countries and economically important developing nations will make in the on-going international negotiations to be taken into account?
  • How to increase regulatory certainty for business while building in flexibility to adapt to changing circumstances (for example, progress in international climate negotiations and changes in energy markets)?
  • How can the EU increase the innovation capacity of manufacturing industry? Is there a role for the revenues from the auctioning of allowances?
  • How can the EU best exploit the development of indigenous conventional and unconventional energy sources within the EU to contribute to reduced energy prices and import dependency?
  • How can the EU best improve security of energy supply internally by ensuring the full and effective functioning of the internal energy market (for example, through the development of necessary interconnections), and externally by diversifying energy supply routes?

Capacity and distributional aspects

  • How should the new framework ensure an equitable distribution of effort among Member States? What concrete steps can be taken to reflect their different abilities to implement climate and energy measures?
  • What mechanisms can be envisaged to promote cooperation and a fair effort sharing between Member States whilst seeking the most cost-effective delivery of new climate and energy objectives?
  • Are new financing instruments or arrangements required to support the new 2030 framework?






 
previous page contents next page


© Parliamentary copyright 2013
Prepared 17 May 2013