Legislative Scrutiny: Children, Schools and Families Bill; other Bills - Human Rights Joint Committee Contents


Memorandum submitted by Allan Jackson

  1)  Illegal File sharing, while I understand the concerns of the music industry we must not get to a point where Government determine who is/is not allowed access to the internet. It is very easy to access people's internet connection and pretends they are that person; therefore you could be punishing a completely innocent person.

2)  DNA and Fingerprints, these should only be retained where someone has committed a criminal offence; any one not charged should have these deleted as soon as the person is released.

  3)  Domestic Violence, if someone is guilty of domestic violence then arrest them, until then they are innocent, it is over the top to bar someone from their own property just based on allegations, the victim should of course be protected and there are many shelters that do this, if the abuser is then charged then the victim would be able to return to the property while that person is in prison. It should always be the case that the victim needs to prove the abuse.

  4)  Stop and Search, this is a huge misuse of police time, police should only be allowed to stop and search people if there is evidence that person has committed a crime, there should be no provision to make them ethnically balanced, it is a fact that while not all Muslims are terrorists currently all terrorists are Muslims, therefore at the moment I would expect more young Asian men being stopped.

  5)  Enforceable Entitlements for Parents and Pupils, what a load of codswallop, people do not need legal entitlements, who judges what the entitlement is and whether it has been met. Not necessary at all.

  6)  Mandatory Sex and Relationship lessons, while I understand the need for this, the parents should always be able to see the curriculum and withdraw their children if they feel it is appropriate, the state should never assume the role of a parent by deciding what is best for children, that is up to the parent.

  7)  Reporting of Family Court Proceedings, all court proceedings should be open and transparent, if there is a need for anonymity then pseudonyms can be used.

  8)  Entitlement to Personal Care at Home, I am not sure this is necessary or desirable, if people need help then surely that should be provided, if someone is treated negligently then there is already the opportunity for people to take action.

  9)  Asylum Support and Destitution, all applications for asylum should be made in the persons home country and they should have authorisation to travel if they arrive in the country without that authorisation then they should be put back on a plane and sent back to wherever that flight came from.

15 January 2010





 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2010
Prepared 19 February 2010