|Previous Section||Back to Table of Contents||Lords Hansard Home Page|
Lord Stoddart of Swindon: My Lords, since there are hundreds of deaths and injuries every year as a result of bull-bars and only 11 reported cases of CJD, will the Government now pursue a policy of non-cooperation with the European Union until it agrees to a measure which would save lives and injuries in this country?
The noble Viscount was sitting on the Bench when my noble friend Lord Barnett accused me and the noble Lord, Lord Tebbit, of xenophobia. Did he hear anything in my two very reasonable questions to suggest that I was xenophobic in any way?
I should have been disappointed had the noble Lord, Lord Stoddart of Swindon, not come up with a bovine reference of some kind. Research has been done into injuries which have resulted in fatalities through the use of bull-bars. Current research tends to indicate that the figure is rather lower than was originally supposed. It is not in the realm of hundreds but is a much smaller figure.
Lord Burnham: My Lords, will the Government not be too precipitate in action against bull-bars? Bull-bars have many useful purposes. There are many items that one can tie to them, including a balloon, if one so wishes, when there is no other way of raising it to the sky.
Lord Clinton-Davis: My Lords, does the Minister agree that we should move from bovine, marsupial and ballooning matters to the reality of the situation? As he indicated, we are encouraging further progress at Commission level. However, does he agree that the directive relates only to the construction of new vehicles? Vehicles currently fitted with bull-bars will not be affected. Does he further recognise that there are measures available in the United Kingdom to deal with the situation? Does he have any intention of taking action, particularly in the light of the inquiry that he caused to be made into the matter? Perhaps he would like to focus on that.
Viscount Goschen: My Lords, the thrust of our inquiry is towards addressing the problem of new vehicles being fitted with bull-bars. We have not ruled out retrospective action, but a number of significant difficulties are involved and we would have to consider carefully the appropriateness of such action.
The Earl of Courtown: My Lords, the great majority of schools in Scotland follow courses leading to qualifications offered by the Scottish Examination Board. There are no plans to alter the content of the Standard Grade History course in Scotland.
Lord Campbell of Croy: My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend for his reply which is welcome. However, if press reports are correct about the GCSE and the national curriculum--neither of which applies in Scotland--will a child have to be at school in Scotland to learn about the Battle of Hastings, kings and queens, Wellington and Nelson? That, of course, would be in addition to Bannockburn and Prestonpans.
The Earl of Courtown: My Lords, I am confident that the noble Lord will understand why I excuse myself from commenting on the veracity of press reports. However, I can confirm that within the Scottish curriculum as it stands at present, it is possible to study the Battle of Hastings. With the curriculum reforms which are proposed at present by the Government, the Battle of
Lord Beloff: My Lords, does the Minister agree that he is suggesting that Scottish children should be educated much better than English children? There is a move on the part of persons responsible for the national curriculum in history to minimise the teaching of proper political and institutional history in favour of vague nonsense.
The Earl of Courtown: My Lords, as I understand the situation in England and Wales, a mandatory list of events and peoples is not entirely necessary on its own. The teaching of mandatory subjects such as the French Revolution and the Napoleonic Wars will include such famous people as Nelson and Wellington. In addition, the subject of the Crown and Parliament in the 16th and 17th centuries will mention the Gunpowder Plot.
Lord Carmichael of Kelvingrove: My Lords, history is a subject on which everyone has his own opinion as to whether it is correct or incorrect. When I saw the Question, I did not know what the noble Lord, Lord Campbell, was seeking. I spoke to some people in Scotland who are involved with history and they were just as puzzled. However, it came to me that the thread between social and political Scottish and English history is very tangled in our country. Many Members here will remember with affection Lady Elliot of Harwood who encapsulated a great deal of history. She once told me how proud she was that her father had been carried on the shoulders of his father to the first Chartist demonstration in Britain held in Glasgow Green in 1832. That showed the generations, the movement of people and the public expression of a point of view by someone whom most people in the House will remember with great affection.
The Earl of Courtown: My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Carmichael, for giving me a history lesson. What he said was important: as well as learning about individuals and events of significance, it is also necessary for young people to be aware of important changes within society and consider them across a wide timescale.
Lord Wallace of Saltaire: My Lords, if we are to insist that children learn about battles, will the Minister ensure that Scottish and English children learn as much about the Battle of Stirling Bridge as Bannockburn, bearing in mind that William Wallace was an extremely good commander for the Scots? In teaching about the Battle of Waterloo, perhaps it could be pointed out that two-thirds of Wellington's army consisted of German and Dutch troops and only one-third of English, Scots and Irish.
Lord Monson: My Lords, since we are discussing the teaching of British history, does the noble Earl agree that this might be an opportune moment to congratulate the BBC on an excellent radio series which has just finished?
The Earl of Carlisle: My Lords, about a week ago a senior judge on the Bench asked me whether Estonia, the northern Baltic state where I live and work, is still governed from Moscow. I replied in the negative. Estonia is a free and independent state. Does the Minister agree that British history should be taught in schools in a European context rather than a narrow parochial one?
The Earl of Courtown: My Lords, my noble friend Lord Pearson always brings up interesting points in relation to Europe. Returning to the Question on the Order Paper, I confirm that in the Scottish syllabus, particularly relating to the Higher Grades, European history is an important part of the syllabus.
Moved, That Standing Order 38 (Arrangement of the Order Paper) be dispensed with on Friday next to enable the Motion standing in the name of the Earl Howe to be taken before the Motions standing in the names of the Viscount Goschen and the Baroness Miller of Hendon and on Monday 15th July next to enable the Motion standing in the name of the Lord Aldington to be taken before the Motion standing in the name of the Earl Ferrers and the Second Reading of the Social Security (Overpayments) Bill.--(Viscount Cranborne.)