Previous Section Back to Table of Contents Lords Hansard Home Page

EU: Justice and Home Affairs Council

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Constitutional Affairs (Baroness Ashton of Upholland): My honourable friend the

24 July 2006 : Column WS138

Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Nationality, Citizenship and Immigration (Joan Ryan) has made the following Written Ministerial Statement.

The Justice and Home Affairs Council will be held today, 24 July 2006, in Brussels. I am attending on behalf of the Home Office. I thought that it would be useful if I were to outline the main issues that I expect to be discussed.

The Council will take an initial presentation by the Commission on The Hague programme review. There will also be discussion of migration issues and, in the mixed committee format, the second generation Schengen information system. On the first of these, the Commission will present four communications: the future direction of The Hague programme, which includes a proposed use of Article 42 TEU (the passerelle clause); reviewing the implementation of The Hague programme to date (the scorecard); options for better evaluation of the impact of EU policies in the area of justice and home affairs (JHA); and a legislative proposal based on Article 67(2) TEC adapting the provisions of the European Court of Justice under Title IV (immigration, asylum and civil law matters). The presidency has indicated that it will focus on procedure and handling and is not looking for substantive discussion on these items at this Council. Detailed discussion, including in relation to the more controversial aspects, such as the possible use of Article 42 TEU (the passerelle clause) and Article 67(2) TEC (adapting the remit of the ECJ in Title IV) will take place later in the year, including at the September informal JHA Council in Finland. Those aspects aside, the Government’s initial view is to welcome the focus on implementation and more effective evaluation contained in the communications.

There will be information items on the EU preparations for the UN high-level dialogue on international migration and development and the report on the outcome of the Euro-African ministerial conference on migration and development held in Rabat on 10 and 11 July 2006. The Government welcome the adoption of the EU common position at the General Affairs and External Relations Council last week, on 13 July; we will continue to feed into preparations for the UN high-level dialogue on international migration and development, which takes place in September. There will also be a presentation by the Commission and Frontex (EU border agency) on the situation in the Mediterranean and Africa. We expect there to be a focus on the continuing influx of illegal immigrants to the Canaries and Malta. The UK strongly supports EU joint operational activity in the Mediterranean and has offered technical assistance to the Spanish and Maltese authorities.

There will be discussion on the management of migration flows, specifically on the two Commission communications on a policy plan for legal migration and a common policy on illegal immigration. The presidency will be seeking a first exchange of views on both items. The UK will be encouraging solutions of sharing best practice and establishing common principles, while advising against inflexible, detailed

24 July 2006 : Column WS139

prescription, especially in the form of legislative measures on labour access. The Government are fully committed to tackling the problem of illegal immigration of third-country nationals and notes with interest the Commission's communication; we will examine concrete proposals for measures when they are tabled in due course.

In the mixed committee format, the presidency will be hoping to agree a general approach on the key outstanding issues in the three legal instruments establishing SIS II—a regulation covering immigration aspects, a Council decision covering law enforcement aspects and a regulation covering access by vehicle registration authorities—with a view to reaching a First Reading deal with the European Parliament in September. This is the last opportunity to resolve the major outstanding issues within the Council before the expected EP vote in September. The UK will not participate in the regulation covering immigration but will participate in the other two legal instruments.

Two further presentations by the Commission are expected in the margins of the meeting. These are on (i) a proposal for a regulation setting up the powers and the financing of teams of national border control experts of member states (rapid border intervention teams) to provide joint EU technical and operational assistance at the external EU border, co-ordinated by Frontex; and (ii) a proposal for a Community code on visas—a Schengen measure in which the UK will not participate. Although the UK will not participate in the first proposal, we support the concept of nominated experts deployed at short notice to respond to emergencies to help to enhance the security of the EU external border, but will wish to look carefully at the detail.

Finally, there is likely to be a lunchtime presentation by Commissioner Franco Frattini on the issue of CIA rendition flights.

Fire Safety: Reduced Ignition Propensity Cigarettes

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Communities and Local Government (Baroness Andrews): My right honourable friend the Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State has made the following Written Ministerial Statement.

Careless handling of smokers' materials continues to be one of the major causes of UK accidental fire deaths in the home. Evidence has shown that reduced ignition propensity (RIP) cigarettes decrease the risk of inducing ignition or progressive smouldering in materials, therefore reducing the number of accidental fire deaths in the home.

RIP cigarettes have been legislated for in New York State, California, Vermont, Illinois, New Hampshire and Massachusetts and are all now in place, as well as in Canada. The legislation requires that all cigarettes conform to American Society for Testing and Materials Standards (ASTM International).

24 July 2006 : Column WS140

At the request of the UK, supported by Sweden, the European Commission undertook to look into the case for developing an appropriate technical standard for RIP cigarettes. The Department for Communities and Local Government will be working very closely with the Department of Health, which has led government work on tobacco regulation, and the Department of Trade and Industry, which leads on consumer product safety. It is expected that further discussion on the case for developing a European technical standard for RIP cigarettes will take place at the next general product committee meeting in Brussels this September.

Fraud Review

The Attorney-General (Lord Goldsmith): The final report of the fraud review is published today and I have placed copies in the Libraries of both Houses. The Government are issuing it for consultation and seek responses by 27 October 2006.

The report outlines current arrangements for dealing with fraud, identifies gaps and shortcomings in the system and makes recommendations for dealing with them. The recommendations are wide-ranging and are aimed at improving fraud deterrence, prevention, detection, investigation, prosecution and penalties. Benefits will include reduction of fraud losses to taxpayers, consumers and businesses, and a reduction in the harm that fraud causes to individuals and communities.

The Government accept the analysis of the report and are sympathetic to the broad conclusions and recommendations, but we believe that the report would benefit from a wider public consultation. Implementation of the recommendations will be considered in the light of consultation responses and after further evaluation of the funding and legislative implications.

Government Departments: Payment Performance

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Trade and Industry (Lord Sainsbury of Turville): My right honourable friend the Minister of State for Industry and the Regions (Margaret Hodge) has made the following Written Ministerial Statement.

The overall payment performance of Government is 96.87 per cent. Figures for the financial year 2005-06 show that there has been a slight fall compared to last year's figure of 97.09 per cent. Some 54 per cent of departments improved on their performance of last year.

Government departments and their agencies are required to monitor their payment performance and to publish the results in their departmental or annual reports. The table lists, by department, the proportion of bills paid within 30 days, or other agreed credit period, on receipt of a valid invoice.



24 July 2006 : Column WS141

The Government take this issue very seriously and are committed to improving the payment culture in the UK in order to create fair and stable business transactions. The Government's own payment performance is an important element in this policy.

Main Departments 2005-06Paid on Time

Defence Bills Agency (Ministry of Defence)

100

Office of Fair Trading

99.86

Intelligence Agencies (GCHQ)

99.80

Privy Council Office

99.71

Office for National Statistics

99.51

Office for Government Commerce

99.48

Office of Gas and Electricity Markets (Ofgem)

99.46

The National Archives (Public Records Office)

99.31

Health & Safety Executive

99.19

Scotland Office (Department for Constitutional Affairs)

99.11

Office of Water Services (Ofwat)

99.10

Postal Services Commission (PostCom)

98.97

Export Credit Guarantee Department

98.93

HM Revenue and Customs

98.80

Department for Transport

98.71

Charity Commission

98.24

Food Standards Agency

98.18

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister

98.09

Forestry Commission

97.98

Ordnance Survey

97.95

Department for Culture, Media and Sport

97.66

Office for Standards in Education (Ofsted)

97.66

Government Actuary's Department

97.54

Land Registry

97.38

Department for International Development

96.76

Department for Education and Skills

96.29

Department of Health

96.19

Treasury Solicitors Department

95.78

Department of Trade and Industry

95.67

UK Trade and Investment

95.35

Electoral Commission

94.91

Office of Rail Regulation

94.89

HM Treasury

94.70

Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra)

94.19

Cabinet Office (OPS)

94.06

Central Office of Information

93.17

Foreign and Commonwealth Office

92.96

Serious Fraud Office

91.46

Department of Work and Pensions

89.79

Crown Prosecution Service

88.96

Wales Office (Department for Constitutional Affairs)

88.64

Department for Constitutional Affairs (Lord Chancellor’s Department)

88.48

Northern Ireland Office

86.65

Home Office

86.24

National Savings and Investments

85.49

Royal Mint

84.98

Overall Total

96.87



24 July 2006 : Column WS142

Government Departments: Special Advisers

The Lord President of the Council (Baroness Amos): Listed below are the names of special advisers in post at 24 July 2006, the special advisers’ pay ranges for 2006-07, the number of special advisers in each pay band by department and the total pay bill of special advisers for 2005-06.

All special advisers are appointed under terms and conditions set out in the Model Contract for Special Advisers and Code of Conduct for Special Advisers, providing assistance on the full range of their appointing Minister's departmental responsibilities. Where a special adviser has a specific expertise or works mainly in a particular area of the department's work, this is indicated.



24 July 2006 : Column WS143



24 July 2006 : Column WS144

Appointing MinisterSpecial adviser in postExpertise

The Prime Minister

Jonathan Powell

Chief of Staff

Liz Lloyd

Deputy Chief of Staff

Ruth Turner

Director of Government Relations

Matthew Taylor

Chief Adviser on Strategy

Policy Directorate

David Bennett

Head of Policy Directorate

Conor Ryan

Paul Corrigan

Geoffrey Norris

Philip Collins

Justin Forsyth

Kieran Brett

Strategic Communications and Press

David Hill

Director of Communications

David Bradshaw

Hilary Coffman

Matthew Doyle

Chris McShane

Benjamin Wegg Prosser

Huw Evans

Events and Visits

Jo Gibbons

Director of Events, Visits and Scheduling

Katie Kay

Angela Goodchild (p/t)

John Watts

Victoria Gould

Research and Information Unit

Catherine Rimmer

Katie O'Donovan

Deputy Prime Minister and First Secretary of State

Joan Hammell

Chief of Staff

Mick Halloran

Minister for the Cabinet Office and for Social Exclusion (and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster)

Peter Kyle

Anna Turley

Secretary of State for Communities and Local Government

Julie Crowley

Media and communication

David Leam

Rachel O'Brien

Women and equality

Chief Whip (Commons)

Sue Jackson

Simon Benson

Chief Whip (Lords)

Margaret Ounsley

Secretary of State for Constitutional Affairs and Lord Chancellor

Garry Hart

Philip Bassett

Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport

Nick Bent

Secretary of State for Defence

Matt Cavanagh

Alaina Macdonald

Secretary of State for Education and Skills

Chris Norton

Mario Dunn

Clare Montagu

Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

Madlin Sadler

Tony Grayling

Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs

Sheila Watson

Ed Mitchell

Malcolm Chalmers

Foreign affairs

Minister for Europe

James Connal

Minister for Trade

Martin O'Donovan

Trade

Blair McDougall

Communications and human rights

Secretary of State for Health

Liz Kendall

Karen Livingston

Secretary of State for the Home Department

Steve Bates

Justin Russell

Anna MacMillan

Leader of the House of Commons and Lord Privy Seal

Mark Davies

Declan McHugh

Leader of the House of Lords and Lord President of the Council

Joe Dancey

Dorothea Hodge

Secretary of State for International Development

Beatrice Stern

Communications

Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and Secretary of State for Wales

Claire McCarthy

Northern Ireland issues

Philip Taylor

Northern Ireland issues

Andrew Bold

Wales issues

Matthew Burchell

Wales issues

Secretary of State for Scotland and Secretary of State for Transport

Paul Sinclair

Transport

Iain Gray

Scottish affairs

Secretary of State for Trade and Industry

Andrew Maugham

Sam White

Emily Thomas (unpaid)

Chancellor of the Exchequer 1, 2

Spencer Livermore

Damien McBride

Chief Secretary

Jonathan Ashworth

Jo Dipple

Secretary of State for Work and Pensions

John Williams

John Woodcock

Minister without Portfolio

Paul Richards

Andy Bagnall

1 In addition, the Chancellor of the Exchequer has appointed Dan Corry, Paul Gregg, Shriti Vadera, Michael Jacobs and Stewart Wood to the Council of Economic Advisers on special adviser terms.
2 Plus Sue Nye appointed as an unpaid adviser

Pay bands for 2006-07

The pay bands and pay ranges for special advisers for 2006-07 are as follows.

Scheme Ceiling

£136,500

Pay Band 4

£84,000 to £100,900

Pay Band 3 and Premium

£62,800 to £97,500

Pay Band 2

£49,300 to £65,400

Pay Band 1

£38,100 to £51,100

Pay Band 0

Up to £38,100

Advisers by Pay Band

At 24 July 2006, the number of special advisers in each pay band by department is as follows.



24 July 2006 : Column WS145

DepartmentPay Band
01234

No 101

-

62

2

132

12

Deputy Prime Minister’s Office

-

12

-

1

-

Cabinet Office

-

22

-

-

-

Communities and Local Government

-

12

22

-

-

Chief Whips Offices (Commons and Lords)

-

12

2

-

-

Constitutional Affairs

-

-

-

-

2

Culture, Media and Sport

-

-

1

-

-

Defence

-

12

12

-

-

Education and Skills

12

22

-

-

Environment, Food and Rural Affairs

-

-

12

12

-

Foreign and Commonwealth Office (includes Minister for Europe and Minister for Trade)

12

22

-

32

-

Health

-

11

12

-

-

Home Office

-

1

-

22

-

International Development

-

1

-

-

-

Leader of the House of Commons and Lord Privy Seal

-

12

1

-

-

Leader of the House of Lords and Lord President of the Council

-

22

-

-

-

Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and Wales

-

42

-

-

-

Secretary of State for Scotland and Transport

-

-

1

12

-

Trade and Industry 3

-

1

1

-

-

HM Treasury 3, 4

-

1

22

1

-

Work and Pensions

-

1

-

-

12

Minister without Portfolio

-

12

-

12

-

Total

1

29

17

23

4

Paybill costs: The cost of special advisers in 2005-2006 was £5.9 million 5.
1 Plus three special advisers who are paid beyond pay band 4 but within the scheme ceiling.
2 Includes provisional salaries yet to be agreed.
3 Plus one unpaid adviser.
4 Plus the five members of the Council of Economic Advisers who are employed on special adviser terms (one in band 4, three in band 3 and one in band 1). One of the members of the council works part time.
5 This figure includes salary, severance pay and estimate of pension costs.

Next Section Back to Table of Contents Lords Hansard Home Page