Select Committee on European Communities Fourteenth Report


APPENDIX 5 (continued)

Convention Drawn up on the Basis of Article K.3 of the Treaty on European Union, on Mutual Assistance and Co-operation between Customs Administrations

TITLE IV

SPECIAL FORMS OF CO-OPERATION

Article 19

PRINCIPLES

  1. Customs administrations shall engage in cross-border co-operation in accordance with this Title. They shall provide each other with the necessary assistance in terms of staff and organisational support. Requests for co-operation shall, as a rule, take the form of requests for assistance in accordance with Article 9. In specific cases referred to in this Title, officers of the applicant authority may engage in activities in the territory of the requested State, with the approval of the requested authority.

  Co-ordination and planning of cross-border operations shall be the responsibility of the central co-ordinating units in accordance with Article 5.

  2. Cross-border co-operation within the meaning of paragraph 1 shall be permitted for the prevention, investigation and prosecution of infringements in cases of:

    (a)   illicit traffic in drugs and psychotropic substances, weapons, munitions, explosive materials, cultural goods, dangerous and toxic waste, nuclear material or materials or equipment intended for the manufacture of atomic, biological and/or chemical weapons (prohibited goods);

    (b)   trade in substances listed in tables I and II of the United Nations Convention against illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances and intended for the illegal manufacture of drugs (precursor substances);

    (c)   illegal cross-border commercial trade in taxable goods to evade tax or to obtain unauthorised State payments in connection with the import or export of goods, where the extent of the trade and the related risk to taxes and subsidies is such that the potential financial cost to the budget of the European Communities or the Member States is considerable;

    (d)   any other trade in goods prohibited by Community or national customs rules.

  3. The requested authority shall not be obliged to engage in the specific forms of co-operation referred to in this Title if the type of investigation sought is not permitted or not provided for under the national law of the requested Member State. In this case, the applicant authority shall be entitled to refuse, for the same reason, the corresponding type of cross-border co-operation in the reverse case, where it is requested by an authority of the requested Member State.

  4. If necessary under the national law of the Member States, the participating authorities shall apply to their judicial authorities for approved of the planned investigations. Where the competent judicial authorities make their approval subject to certain conditions and requirements, the participating authorities shall ensure that those conditions and requirements are observed in the course of the investigations.

  5. Where officers of a Member State engage in activities in the territory of another Member State by virtue of this Title and cause damage by their activities, the Member State in whose territory the damage was caused shall make good the damage, in accordance with its national legislation in the same way as it would have done if the damage had been caused by its own officers. That Member State will be reimbursed in full by the Member State whose officers have caused the damage for the amounts it has paid to the victims or to other entitled persons or institutions.

  6. Without prejudice to the exercise of its rights vis-aÁ-vis third parties and notwithstanding the obligation to make good damages according to the second sentence of paragraph 5, each Member State shall refrain, in the case provided for in the first sentence of paragraph 5, from requesting reimbursement of the amount of damages it has sustained from another Member State.

  7. Information obtained by officers during cross-border co-operation provided for in Articles 20 to 24 may be used, in accordance with national law and subject to particular conditions laid down by the competent authorities of the State in which the information was obtained, as evidence by the competent bodies of the Member State receiving the information.

  8. In the course of the operations referred to in Articles 20 to 24, officers on mission in the territory of another Member State shall be treated in the same way as officers of that State as regards infringement committed against them or by them.

Article 20

HOT PURSUIT

  1. Officers of the customs administration of one of the Member States pursuing in their country, an individual observed in the act of committing one of the infringements referred to in Article 19(2) which could give rise to extradition, or participating in such an infringement, shall be authorised to continue pursuit in the territory of another Member State without prior authorisation where, given the particular urgency of the situation, it was not possible to notify the competent authorities of the other Member State prior to entry into that territory or where these authorities have been unable to reach the scene in time to take over the pursuit.

  The pursuing officers shall, not later than when they cross the border, contact the competent authorities of the Member State in whose territory the pursuit is to take place. The pursuit shall cease as soon as the Member State in whose territory the pursuit is taking place so requests. At the request of the pursuing officers, the competent authorities of the said Member State shall challenge the pursued person so as to establish his identity or to arrest him. Member States shall inform the depositary of the pursuing officers to whom this provision applies; the depositary shall inform the other Member States.

  2. The pursuit shall be carried out in accordance with the following procedures, defined by the declaration provided for in paragraph 6:

    (a)   the pursuing officers shall not have the right to apprehend;

    (b)   however, if no request to cease the pursuit is made and if the competent authorities of the Member State in whose territory the pursuit is taking place are unable to intervene quickly enough, the pursuing officers may apprehend the person pursued until the officers of the said Member State, who must be informed without delay, are able to establish his identity or arrest him.

  3. Pursuit shall be carried out in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 in one of the following ways as defined by the declaration provided for in paragraph 6:

    (a)   in an area or during a period, as from the crossing of the border, to be established in the declaration;

    (b)   without limit in space or time.

  4. Pursuit shall be subject to the following general conditions:

    (a)   the pursuing officers shall comply with the provisions of this Article and with the law of the Member States in whose territory they are operating; they shall obey the instructions of the competent authorities of the Member State;

    (b)   when the pursuit takes places on the sea, it shall, where it extends to the high sea or the exclusive economic zone, be carried out in conformity with the international law of the sea as reflected in the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, and, when it takes place in the territory of another Member State, it shall be carried out in accordance with the provisions of this Article;

    (c)   entry into private homes and places not accessible to the public shall be prohibited;

    (d)   the pursuing officers shall be easily identifiable, either by their uniform or an armband or by means of accessories fitted to their means of transport; the use of civilian clothes combined with the use of unmarked means of transport without the aforementioned identification is prohibited; the pursuing officers shall at all times be able to prove that they are acting in an official capacity;

    (e)   the pursuing officers may carry their service weapons, save (i) where the requested Member State has made a general declaration that weapons may never be carried into its territory or (ii) where specifically decided otherwise by the requested Member State. When officers of another Member State are permitted to carry their service weapons, their use shall be prohibited save in cases of legitimate self-defence;

    (f)   once the pursued person has been apprehended as provided for in paragraph 2(b), for the purpose of bringing him before the competent authorities of the Member State in whose territory the pursuit took place he may be subjected only to a security search; handcuffs may be used during his transfer; objects carried by the pursued person may be seized;

    (g)   after each operation mentioned in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3, the pursuing officers shall present themselves before the competent authorities of the Member State in whose territory they were operating and shall give an account of their mission; at the request of those authorities, they must remain at their disposal until the circumstances of their action have been adequately elucidated; this condition shall apply even where the pursuit has not resulted in the arrest of the pursued person;

    (h)   the authorities of the Member State from which the pursuing officers have come shall, when requested by the authorities of the Member State in whose territory the pursuit took place, assist the enquiry subsequent to the operation in which they took part, including legal proceedings.

  5. A person who, following the action provided for in paragraph 2, has been arrested by the competent authorities of the Member State in whose territory the pursuit took place may, whatever his nationality, be held for questioning. The relevant rules of national law shall apply mutatis mutandis.

  If the person is not a national of the Member State in whose territory he was arrested, he shall be released no later than six hours after his arrest, not including the hours between midnight and 09.00 hours, unless the competent authorities of the said Member State have previously received a request for his provisional arrest for the purposes of extradition in any form.

  6. On signing this Convention, each Member State shall make a declaration in which it shall define, on the basis of paragraphs 2, 3 and 4, the procedures for implementing pursuit in its territory.

  A Member State may at any time replace its declaration by another declaration, provided the latter does not restrict the scope of the former.

  Each declaration shall be made after consultations with each of the Member States concerned and with a view to obtaining equivalent arrangements in those States.

  7. Member States may, on a bilateral basis, extend the scope of paragraph 1 and adopt additional provisions in implementation of this Article.

  8. When depositing its instruments of adoption of this Convention, a Member State may declare that it is not bound by this Article or by part thereof. Such declaration may be withdrawn at any time.

Article 21

CROSS-BORDER SURVEILLANCE

  1. Officers of the customs administration of one of the Member States who are keeping under observation in their country persons in respect of whom there are serious grounds for believing that they are involved in one of the infringements referred to in Article 19(2) shall be authorised to continue their observation in the territory of another Member State where the latter has authorised cross-border observation in response to a request for assistance which has previously been submitted. Conditions may be attached to the authorisation.

  Member States shall inform the depositary of the officers to whom this provision applies; the depositary shall inform the other Member States.

  On request, the observation shall be entrusted to officers of the Member State in whose territory it is carried out.

  The request referred to in the first subparagraph shall be sent to an authority designated by each of the Member States empowered to grant the requested authorisation or pass on the request.

  Member States shall inform the depositary of the authority designated for this purpose; the depositary shall inform the other Member States.

  2. Where, for particularly urgent reasons, prior authorisation of the other Member State cannot be requested, the officers conducting the observation shall be authorised to continue beyond the border the observation of persons in respect of whom there are serious grounds for believing that they are involved in one of the infringements referred to in Article 19(2), provided that the following conditions are met:

    (a)   the competent authorities of the Member State in whose territory the observation is to be continued shall be notified immediately of the crossing of the border, during the observation;

    (b)   a request submitted in accordance with paragraph 1 and outlining the grounds for crossing the border without prior authorisation shall be submitted without delay.

  Observation shall cease as soon as the Member State in whose territory it is taking place so requests, following the notification referred to in (a) or the request referred to in (b), or where authorisation has not been obtained five hours after the border was crossed.

  3. The observation referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 shall be carried out only under the following general conditions:

    (a)   the officers conducting the observation shall comply with the provisions of this Article and with the law of the Member State in whose territory they are operating; they must obey the instructions of the competent authorities of the said Member State;

    (b)   except in the situations provided for in paragraph 2, the officers shall, during the observation, carry a document certifying that authorisation has been granted;

    (c)   the officers conducting the observation shall be able at all times to provide proof that they are acting in an official capacity;

    (d)   the officers conducting the observation may carry their service weapons during the observation save:

  (i)   where the requested Member State has made a general declaration that weapons may never be carried into its territory; or

  (ii)   where specifically decided otherwise by the requested Member State. When officers of another Member State are permitted to carry their service weapons, their use shall be prohibited save in cases of legitimate self-defence;

    (e)   entry into private homes and places not accessible to the public shall be prohibited;

    (f)   the officers conducting the observation may neither challenge nor arrest the person under observation;

    (g)   all operations shall be the subject of a report to the authorities of the Member State in whose territory they took place; the officers conducting the observation may be required to appear in person;

    (h)   the authorities of the Member State from which the observing officers have come shall, when requested by the authorities of the Member State in whose territory the observation took place, assist the enquiry subsequent to the operation in which they took part, including legal proceedings.

  4. The Member States may, at bilateral level, extend the scope of this Article and adopt additional measures in implementation thereof.

  5. When depositing its instruments of adoption of this Convention, a Member State may declare that it is not bound by this Article or by part thereof. Such declaration may be withdrawn at any time.

Article 22

CONTROLLED DELIVERY

  1. Each Member State shall undertake to ensure that, at the request of another Member State, controlled deliveries may be permitted on its territory in the framework of criminal investigations into extraditable offenses.

  2. The decision to carry out controlled deliveries shall be taken in each individual case by the competent authorities of the requested Member State, with due regard for the national law of that State.

  3. Controlled deliveries shall take place in accordance with the procedures of the requested Member State. Competence to act and to direct operations shall lie with the competent authorities of that Member State.

  The requested authority shall take over control of the delivery when the goods cross the border or at an agreed hand-over point in order to avoid any interruption of surveillance. During the rest of the journey it shall ensure that the goods are kept permanently under surveillance in such a way that at any time it has the possibility of arresting the perpetrators and seizing the goods.

  4. Consignments, the controlled delivery of which is agreed to may, with the consent of the Member States concerned, be intercepted and allowed to continue with the initial contents intact or removed or replaced in whole or in part.

Article 23

COVERT INVESTIGATIONS

  1. At the request of the applicant authority, the requested authority may authorise officers of the customs administration of the requesting Member State or officers acting on behalf of such administration operating under cover of a false identity (covert investigators) to operate on the territory of the requested Member State. The applicant authority shall make the request only where it would be extremely difficult to elucidate the facts without recourse to the proposed investigative measures. The officers in question shall be authorised in the course of their activities to collect information and make contact with suspects or other persons associated with them.

  2. Covert investigations in the requested Member State shall have a limited duration. The preparation and supervision of the investigations shall take place in close co-operation between the relevant authorities of the requested and applicant Member States.

  3. The conditions under which a covert investigation is allowed, as well as the conditions under which it is carried out, shall be determined by the requested authority in accordance with its national law. If, in the course of a covert investigation, information is acquired in relation to an infringement other than that covered by the original request, then the conditions concerning the use to which such information may be put shall also be determined by the requested authority in accordance with its national law.

  4. The requested authority shall provide the necessary manpower and technical support. It shall take measures to protect the officers referred to in paragraph 1, while they are active in the requested Member State.

  5. When depositing its instruments of adoption of this Convention, a Member State may declare that it is not bound by this Article or part thereof. Such declaration may be withdrawn at any time.

Article 24

JOINT SPECIAL INVESTIGATION TEAMS

  1. By mutual agreement, the authorities of several Member States may set up a joint special investigation team based in a Member State and comprising officers with the relevant specialisations.

  The joint special investigation team shall have the following tasks:

       -    implementation of difficult and demanding investigations of specific infringement, requiring simultaneous, co-ordinated action in the Member States concerned;

       -    co-ordinated of joint activities to prevent and detect particular types of infringement and obtain information on the persons involved, their associates and the methods used.

  2. Joint special investigation teams shall operate under the following general conditions:

    (a)   they shall be set only for a specific purpose and for a limited period;

    (b)   an officer from the Member State in which the team's activities take place shall head the team;

    (c)   the participating officers shall be bound by the law of the Member State in whose territory the team's activities take place;

    (d)   the Member State in which the team's activities take place shall make the necessary organisational arrangements for the team to operate.

  3. Membership of the team shall not bestow on officers any powers of intervention in the territory of another Member State.


 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 1998