|
| Title | Number
of
defeats
| Stage
name
| Subject
matter
| Voting
figures
| Reversed
by
HC
|
|
| Access to Justice
| 4
| Committee of the whole House
| Clause 31 stand part: Rights of audience: employed advocates
| C77 : NC88
| Yes |
| | Report
| Amdt 1, statement of principles underlying legal aid in England and Wales: including accessibility of legal services irrespective of means and/or disability
| C182 : NC111
| Yes |
| | Report
| Amdt 97, to prevent Criminal Defence Service itself providing advice and assistance (ie state defenders) (grouped with 98, 102 + 104)
| C189 : NC134
| Yes |
| | Consideration of Commons Amendments
| Commons Amdt 27; independence of legal representatives
| C141: NC85
| Yes |
| Disability Rights Commission
| 1
| Report |
Amdt 4; Commission to make proposals or give advice to any Govt agency as to practical application of any law
| C112: NC81
| Yes |
| Employment Relations
| 1
| Committee of the whole House
| Amdt 276; payment of higher wages not constitute a detriment to worker not receiving same wages
| C98: NC78
| No (Amt disagreed to by HC and then largely reinserted by HL and finally agreed to)
|
| European Parliamentary Elections
| 1
| Second Reading
| Reasoned amt against 2a
| C167: NC73
| N/A: Bill defeated and enacted under Parliament Acts
|
| Greater London Authority
| 1
| Report |
Amdt 5A; election for Mayor in event of no confidence by Assembly
| C213: NC117
| Yes |
| Health |
3
| Report |
Amdt 2; establishment of Primary Care Trusts - majority vote by members of primary care group needed
| C120: NC117
| Yes |
| | Report
| Amdt 47; Independent hospitals
| C161: NC113
| Yes |
| | Third Reading
| Amdt 7; (+ 8), patients to be referred out of area for specialist hospital treatment and aftercare
| C113: NC86
| Yes |
| House of Lords
| 4
| Second Reading
| Amt to motion for 2a
| C192: NC126
| N/A |
| | Committee of the whole House
| Motion to resume House
| C145: NC136
| N/A |
| | Report
| Amdt 25, Appointments Commission - Statutory body outside existing departments to advise Prime Minister on appointment of life peers
| C231: NC189
| Yes |
| | Report
| Amdt 46, in case of bill to extend life of parliament, no life peers created during that parliament may vote on bill
| C 283: NC177
| Yes |
| Immigration and Asylum Bill
| 1
| Report |
Amdt 118: voucher system to replace cash benefits to be delayed until improved administration of asylum claims takes effect
| C161: NC116
| Yes |
| Tax Credits
| 2
| Committee of the whole House
| Amdt 29, (+ 32); small employers to have the right to opt out of payment of the working families tax credit rather than automatic exemption
| C161: NC121
| Yes |
| | Committee of the whole House
| Amdt 31; single parents to have same choice as couples to receive payment of any tax credit direct from Board rather than from employer
| C150: NC103
| Yes |
| Welfare Reform and Pensions
| 10
| Report |
Amdt 7; stakeholder pension - no requirement to take annuity at specified date.
| C145: NC137
| Yes |
| | Report
| Amdt 96; extension of widow's benefit to two years
| C193: NC114
| Accepted in part through amts in lieu
|
| | Report
| Amdt. 96A; extension of widow's benefit to one year [NB voting figures amended as per c.439 Hansard 13/10/99]
| C163: NC184
| Yes |
| | Report
| Amdt 133; reverse proposed incapacity benefit restriction to recent contributors
| C251: NC95
| Accepted in part through amts in lieu
|
| | Report
| Amdt 136; reverse proposed incapacity benefit reduction for pension payments
| C198: NC90
| Accepted in part through amts in lieu
|
| | Report
| Amdt 144: reverse proposed withdrawal of severe disablement allowance
| C119: NC81
| Yes |
| | Report
| Amdt 184; earnings of workers supplied by service companies, etc.
| C84: NC66
| Yes |
| | Third Reading
| Amdt 1; war pensions for widows for life
| C166: NC107
| Yes |
| | Consideration of Commons Amendments
| Lords Amdt 20; war pensions for widows: entitlement
| C153: NC140
| Yes |
| | Consideration of Commons Amendments
| Lords Amdt 42; incapacity benefit: restriction to recent contributors
| C260: NC127
| Yes |
| Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence
| 1
| Third Reading
| Amdt 2; Youth offenders to be ordered to youth offender panels
| C149: NC144
| Yes |
|
| | | |
| |
| Total | 29
| | | |
|
|
