Select Committee on Privileges Second Report


APPENDIX 5

List of authorities cited during the hearing


CASE-LAW
1.M'Kenzie v Stewart, 1 July 1752, Kames' Selections, p 12.
2.Marbury v Madison, (1803) 1 Cranch. 103.
3.Duke of Queensberry v Officers of State, 15 December 1807 FC, p51; Mor App, Pt 1, `Jurisdiction' p33.
4.Minister of Prestonkirk v Heritors of Prestonkirk, 3 February, 1808; reported in Connell on Tithes, Vol II, pp112-123 & Vol III, Appendix No CXVIII, p310; affirmed by the House of Lords, 20 May 1808, Connell, Vol II, pp122-123 (per Lord Justice-Clerk Hope at pp310, 319-320, & Lord President Blair at p376).
5.Donald v Magistrates of Anderson (1832) LS 119.
6.The Queen v Baines [1840] 12 Ad & E 210.
7.Earl of Kinnoull v Presbytery of Auchterarder (Whole Court); Robertson's Report of the Auchterarder Case, Vol II, per Lord Moncreiff at pp329-333.
8.Ex Parte Cannon Selwyn [1872] 36 JP 54.
9.Dean v Green (1882) 8 PD79.
10.Bradlaugh v Gossett (1884) 12 Q B D 271.
11.Orr Ewing's Trs V Orr Ewing (1885) 13 R (H L) 1.).
12.Sion College v London Corporation [1900] 2 QB 581.
13.Sion College v London Corporation [1901] 1 QB 617 (CA).
14.The Walker Trustees v Lord Advocate, 1910 SC 1037.
15.The Walker Trustees v Lord Advocate, 1912 SC (HL) 12.
16.Cape Brandy Syndicate v IRC [1921] 2 KB 403.
17.Laughland v Wansborough Paper Co Ltd, (1921) 1 SLT 341.
18.James v Commonwealth of Australia [1936] AC 578 (PC).
19.Ballantyne v Presbytery of Wigtown, 1936 SC 625.
20.Re the Regulation and Control of Aeronautics in Canada [1932] AC 54.
21.Liversidge v Anderson [1941] AC 206 (HL).
22.Inland Revenue v Glasgow Police Athletic Association, 1952 SC 102.
23.MacCormick v Lord Advocate 1953 SC 396.
24.Camille and Henry Dreyfus Foundation Inc v IRC [1954] Ch 672.
25.Bribery Commissioner v Ranasinghe [1965] AC 172 (HL).
26.The Petition of the Earl of Antrim and eleven other Irish Peers [1967] 1 AC 691.
27.Madzimbamuto v Lardner-Burke [1968] 1 AC 645 (PC).
28.Pickin v British Railways Board [1973] AC 765 (HL).
29.R v Chief Immigration Officer, Heathrow Airport, ex p Salamat Bibi (1976) 1 WLR 979 (per Lord Denning, MR at p985B).
30.Gibson v Lord Advocate, 1975 SC 136.
31.Kaur v Lord Advocate, 1980 SC 319.
32.Fothergill v Monarch Airlines Ltd [1981] AC 251.
33.Sillars v Smith 1982 SLT 539.
34.Report by the Committee for Privileges on Parliamentary Privilege and the Mental Health Legislation [1984].
35.R v Secretary of State for the Environment ex Parte Nottingham CC [1986] 1 AC 240 (HL).
36.Fraser v MacCorquodale, 1989 SLT 39.
37.R v Secretary of State for Transport ex parte Factortame Ltd. [1990] 2 AC 85 (HL).
38.R v Secretary of State for Transport ex parte Factortame Ltd [1991] 1AC 603 (ECJ & HL).
39.Steward v. Henry, 1988 SLT 34/39.
40.Pringle, Petitioner, 1991 SLT 330.
41.Murray v Rogers 1992 SLT 221.
42.Pepper v Hart [1993] AC 593 (HL).
43.New Zealand Maori Council v Attorney-General of New Zealand [1994] 1 AC 466 (PC).
44.Robbie the Pict v Hingston (No 2), 1998 SLT 1201.
45.R v Secretary of State for the Home Department ex Parte Salem [1999] 2 WLR 483 (HL).
 
ENCYCLOPEDIAS
46.Halsbury's Laws of England, vol 8(2), pp54-61 paras 51-56.
47.Halsbury's Laws of England vol 44(1) paragraph 1201 footnote.
48.The Laws of Scotland; the Stair Memorial Encyclopedia. Vol 5 pp137-167.
 
RECORDS OF PARLIAMENTARY PROCEEDINGS
49.Proceedings of the Commissioners appointed to treat for an union betwixt the Kingdoms of Scotland and England, APS XI 162 pp145-147, 174-181, 190-191.
50.Proceedings of the Parliament of Scotland, APS XI, 198-199.
51.Minutes of the Parliament of Scotland, 3 October, 1706 to 25 March 1707.
52.Defoe, History of the Union between England and Scotland (John Stockdale, 1786), pp284-527.
53.Cobbett Parliamentary History of England, Vol 6 (1702-1724), cols 533-606, 1046-1068, 1125-1130 & 1213-1222.
54.MacQueen, Report of the debates on the Life Peerage Question (1852), excerpts from between pp74-434.
55.Hansard 123 HL Deb col 777-781 (30 November 1852).
56.Hansard 129 HL Deb col 191, 200, 913 (28 June 1853).
57.Hansard 214 HL Deb col 1738-1739 (11 March 1873).
58.Report of the Joint Committee on House of Lords Reform [Session 1962-93], (Parliamentary Papers (House of Commons & Command) Session 30 October 1962-24 October 1963, Vol VI).
59.Hansard, 679 HC Debs, cols 1663-1664, 1707-1712 (27 June 1963).
60.Hansard HL Deb, cols 1515-1525 (11 July 1963).
61.Hansard 773 HC Debs, cols 1125-1126 & (19 November 1968).
62.Hansard, 297 HL Debs, cols 641-642 & 909-912 (19 & 20 November 1968).
63.Hansard, 777 HC Debs, cols 43-44; 83-84 & 129-134 (3 February 1969).
64.Hansard 778 HC Debs, cols 219-220, 637-638, 1351-1352, 1467-1482, 1491-1494, 1499-1514, 1519-1526, 1595-1598 & 1603-1608 (18, 20 & 25 February 1969).
65.Hansard, 301 HL Debs, cols 1271-1272, 1303-1306, 1331-1338 (8 May 1969).
66.Hansard HL Deb, Cols 1415 (27 July 1999).
 
STATUTORY MATERIALS
67.The Claim of Right APS IX, 38.
68.The Scottish Representative Peers Act 1707 (c 78).
69.The Toleration Act 1711 (c 7).
70.The Church Patronage Act 1711 (c 12).
71.The Heritable Jurisdictions (Scotland) Act 1746 (c 43).
72.The Act of Union (Ireland) Act 1800 (c 38).
73.The Union with Ireland Act 1800 (c 67).
74.The Representation of the People (Scotland) Act 1832 (c 65).
75.The Representative Peers (Scotland) Act 1847 (c 52).
76.The Representative Peers (Scotland) Act 1851 (c 87).
77.The Universities (Scotland) Act 1853 (c 89).
78.The Statute Law Revision Act 1867 (c 59).
79.The Representation of the People (Scotland) Act 1867 (c 48).
80.The Promissory Oaths Act 1868 (c 62).
81.The Irish Church Act 1869 (c 42).
82.The Promissory Oaths Act 1871 (c 48).
83.The Redistribution of Seats Act 1885 (c 23).
84.The Parliament Act 1911 (c 13).
85.The Representation of the People Act 1918 (c 64)
86.Church of Scotland Act 1921, 11 & 12 Geo 5, c 29.
87.The Irish Free State Constitution Act 1922 (c 1)
88.The Irish Free State (Agreement) Act 1922 (c 4).
89.The Universities (Scotland) Act 1932 (c 26).
90.Regency Act 1937, I Edw.8 & 1 Geo.6, c 16.
91.The House of Commons (Redistribution of Seats) Act 1944 (c 41) Third Schedule.
92.The Criminal Justice Act 1948 s.83(3) and Schedule 10 (c 58).
93.The Representation of the People Act 1948 (c 65)
94.The House of Commons (Redistribution of Seats) Act 1949 (c 66).
95.European Communities Act 1972 c 68.
96.The Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 s1(5) (c 65).
97.Canada Act 1982, c 11.
98.Parliamentary Constituencies Act 1986 (c 56).
99.Statute Law (Repeals) Act 1993 (c 50).
100.Human Rights Act 1998 (c 42).
101.The Scotland Act 1998 (c 46).
102.The Parliamentary Constituencies (Scotland) Order 1983 SI 1983/422.
103.The Parliamentary Constituencies (Scotland) Order 1995 SI 1995/1037 (s 90).
104.Excerpt from Scott, Andrew Fletcher & the Treaty of Union, pp 240-243, stating amendments to the Articles of Union carried in the Parliament of Scotland.
105.The Basic Law ("Grundgesetz") of the Federal Republic of Germany, Articles 20 & 79.
 
TEXT-BOOKS
106.Stair Institutions (1693) IV.1.61.
107.Bankton, Institute, IV,1,16-21., II 1,446-480.
108.Erskine, Institutes, L14; LI.19; L,2, 12 & L1,8.
109.Blackstone, Commentaries (1765), pp 96-98.
110.Erskine, Institutes, vol I (1871) pp 7-8, 21, 33, 57-62.
111.L.O. Pike, A Constitutional History of the House of Lords (1894) pp 358-363.
112.Maitland, The Constitutional History of England (1908) p 332.
113.Dicey, The Law of the Constitution (10th edtn), pp 1xiv-1xvii, & 64-67, 144-145.
114.Dicey & Rait, Thoughts on the Union (1920), pp 19-23, 182-185, 202-213, 242-244, 220-227 & 246-255.
115.Trevelyan, Ramillies and the Union with Scotland (1932) Chaps 13 & 14.
116.Fraser, An Outline of Constitutional Law (1948) pp 12-14.
117.Latham, Law & the Commonwealth (1949, pp 522-525.
118.Marshall, Parliamentary Sovereignty and the Commonwealth (1957) pp 47-55.
119.Smith, Scotland, The Development of its Laws and Constitution (1962) pp 49-61.
120.Heuston, Essays in Constitutional Law (1964), pp 1-11.
121.Mitchell, Constitutional Law (2nd edition, 1968), Chaps 4, 5.
122.Craies, Statute Law (7th edtn, 1971), pp 224-225 & 376-377.
123.Wade, Constitutional Fundamentals (1980) pp 30-50.
124.Ketcham, The Anti-Federalist Papers & the Constitutional Convention Debates (1986), pp 31-35, 92-93, 106-109 & 365-367.
125.Hood Phillips' Constitutional and Administrative Law, 7th edtn (1987) pp 47-49, 50-53, 62-66.
126.Fry, The Dundas Despotism pp 6-9, 28-29.
127.Barendt, An Introduction to Constitutional Law (1997) pp 52-59.
128.Bennion, Statutory Interpretation (3rd Edition, 1997) pp 541-543.
129.Erskine May, Treatise on the Law, Privileges, Proceedings & Usage of Parliament (22nd edtn, 1997), Chaps 5, 6, 11 & 25.
130.De Smith & Brazier, Constitutional & Administrative Law (8th edtn, 1998), pp 76-79.
131.Bradley & Ewing, Constitutional & Administrative Law (1998), pp 78-83.
132.Walker, Legal History of Scotland (1998) vol 5, Chapter 4.
133.O'Neill, Judicial Review in Scotland (1999, pp 116-117, para 4.05; & pp 133-152, paras, 4.56 to 4.116.
 
ARTICLES
134.Middleton, New Thoughts on the Union between England and Scotland [1954] 66JR37.
135.Smith, The Union of 1707 as Fundamental Law [1957] Public Law 99.
136.Dixon, The Common Law as an Ultimate Constitutional Foundation Australian Law Journal (1957) Vol 31 p 240.
137.Murray, The Anglo-Scottish Union, 1961 Scots Law Times (News) 161.
138.Williams, The Constitution of the United Kingdom (1972) 31CLJ266.
139.MacCormick, Does the United Kingdom have a Constitution ? [1978] Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly 1. 140. Upton, Marriage Vows of the Elephant: The Constitution of 1707 [1989] 105 LQR 79.
141.Munro, The Union of 1707 and the British Constitution Hume Papers on Public Policy Vol 2 No 2 (1994) 87.
 
PAMPHLET
142.Francis Grant, The Patriot Resolved (1707) [published anonymously].
 
MISCELLANEOUS/OTHER
143.Report of the Royal Commission on the Constitution (1969-73) (1973 Cmnd 5460) para 56.



 
previous page contents

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2000