HOUSE
OF LORDS
|
SESSION 2005-06
[2005] UKHL 74
|
OPINIONS
OF
THE LORDS OF APPEAL
for
judgment IN THE CAUSE
|
Davidson (AP) (Appellant)
v.
Scottish Ministers (Respondents) (Scotland)
|
Appellate Committee
Lord Nicholls of
Birkenhead
Lord Hope of Craighead
Lord Rodger of Earlsferry
Lord Carswell
Lord Mance
|
Counsel
|
Appellants:
Aidan O'Neill QC
Simon Collins
Jason Coppel
(Instructed by
Balfour & Manson)
|
Respondents:
Neil Brailsford QC
Philip Sales
James Mure
(Instructed by Treasury
Solicitor)
|
Hearing
dates:
2 and 3 November 2005
|
on
Thursday
15 DECEMBER 2005
|
|
|
|