Judgments - Director of Public Prosecutions (Appellant) v. Collins (Respondent)

(back to preceding text)

27.  I confess that it did not at once strike me that such a telephone conversation would involve both participants in committing a criminal offence. I am finally persuaded, however, that section 127(1)(a) is indeed intended to protect the integrity of the public communication system: as Lord Bingham puts it at paragraph 7 of his speech, "to prohibit the use of a service provided and funded by the public for the benefit of the public for the transmission of communications which contravene the basic standards of our society". (Quite where that leaves telephone chat-lines, the very essence of which might be thought to involve the sending of indecent or obscene messages such as are also proscribed by section 127(1)(a) was not explored before your Lordships and can be left for another day.)


Lords  Parliament  Commons  Search  Contact Us  Index 

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Prepared 19 July 2006