Select Committee on Science and Technology Second Report


APPENDIX 4: TRENDS IN DELIVERED ENERGY CONSUMPTION AND ASSOCIATED LIFE CYCLE CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSIONS[116]


Introduction

Statistics for UK domestic energy consumption, broken down by end-use, are published annually by the DTI [1]. Figures for the period 1990-2002, in thousands of tonnes of oil equivalent (ktoe), are shown in Table 1. Corresponding figures in PJ (petajoules: 1 PJ = 1015 Joules) are shown in Table 2, based in the conversion 1 ktoe = 42.0 TJ (Terajoules; 1TJ = 1012 Joules) [2]. A graph of the Table 2 figures is shown in Annex 1, Graph A.

The DTI also supplies a breakdown of these figures by fuel: solid fuel, gas, electricity and oil (see Annex 2). This means that if life cycle carbon dioxide emission values can be obtained for the UK for these types of fuel, it will be possible to derive accurate life cycle carbon dioxide values corresponding to the DTI statistics of Tables 1 and 2. The carbon dioxide value for electricity will need to be based on the current UK energy generating mix, and the solid fuel, gas and fuel oil figures will need to be based on current patterns of extraction, refining and supply. This is the goal of the calculations outlined in this document.

Calculation of life cycle carbon dioxide values for each fuel

Life cycle primary energy equivalents and carbon dioxide emissions associated with delivered energy have recently been studied [3]. The data in that source were taken from a detailed study carried out at ETH (Zürich) on the life cycle inventories of European energy systems [4]. This study, which is very widely used, produced detailed life cycle inventories of energy systems supplying Switzerland and those European countries connected through the European electricity grid (UCPTE—although the UK is technically connected to the UCPTE through the DC link with France it does not play a part in its operation). Because the ETH study does not specifically examine UK energy systems, the results are not precisely representative of the UK. However some of the results in [3] can be applied to the UK: for example, energy derived from oil from the North Sea. Therefore this source has sometimes been used here for data on primary energy equivalences and carbon dioxide emissions associated with delivered energy. In other cases, where differences exist, these have been highlighted and the reason for the use of different figures has been explained.

Life cycle carbon dioxide emissions from heating oil and natural gas

The heating oil studied in [3] is a low sulphur fuel based on the European average extraction and supply system. The oil is supplied to domestic users to fuel a 100 kW boiler to provide 1GJ of heat. The supply value for CO2 emitted is 0.0135 g/MJ and the use value is 0.084 kg/MJ. In the UK in domestic homes, kerosene is generally used for heating. This has a lower carbon content of 0.24 kgCO2 per kWh or 0.0667 kgCO2 per MJ [5]. Further, in general in the UK the distances in distribution of heating oil from point of extraction to the refinery, and in distribution from the refinery to the consumer will be less than in the European data. However, the greenhouse gas emissions in this life cycle are mainly

Total UK domestic energy consumption by end use (DTI, 2004) (ktoe)
1990 1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating23563 27287
26515
27686
26089
24769
30063
26559
27966
27786
28423
29921
28884
Hot water10042 10185
10287
10562
10514
10540
10638
10762
10646
10727
10786
10906
11119
Lights & Appliances 54385610
5586
5653
5719
5776
5830
5891
5955
6016
6079
6136
6209
Cooking1507 1478
1435
1407
1384
1364
1350
1339
1328
1319
1310
1303
1296
Total40550 44559
43823
45308
43705
42449
47880
44551
45895
45847
46597
48265
47508

Total UK domestic energy consumption by end use (DTI, 2004) (PJ)
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
989.6
1146.1
1113.6
1162.8
1095.7
1040.3
1262.6
1115.5
1174.6
1167.0
1193.8
1256.7
1213.1
Hot water
421.8
427.8
432.1
443.6
441.6
442.7
446.8
452.0
447.1
450.5
453.0
458.0
467.0
Lights & Appliances
228.4
235.6
234.6
237.4
240.2
242.6
244.8
247.4
250.1
252.7
255.3
257.7
260.8
Cooking
63.3
62.1
60.3
59.1
58.1
57.3
56.7
56.2
55.8
55.4
55.0
54.7
54.4
Total
1703.1
1871.5
1840.6
1902.9
1835.6
1782.9
2011.0
1871.1
1927.6
1925.6
1957.1
2027.1
1995.3

concentrated in the conversion of the fuel into heat, so the effects of these differences are likely to be minor.

Higher CO2 emissions from heating oil arise principally from energy use in the refinery and also from gas flaring during extraction. Therefore, the use figure in this paper has been modestly adjusted downwards to 0.01 kgCO2/MJ, giving a figure for the total CO2 emissions of 0.077 kg/MJ delivered.

With respect to natural gas, figures have been used in this paper which are likely to be similar and representative of North Sea fuel. The enthalpy of burning methane to gaseous carbon dioxide and water vapour is 802.3 MJ/kmol; therefore the net calorific value is 802300/16 MJ/kg = 50.144 MJ/kg; similarly the gross calorific value is 55.644 MJ/kg (since the higher enthalpy value is 890.3 MJ/kmol). Hence per MJ of heat released, the kg of CO2 released are respectively for net, 0.054842 and gross, 0.049421. Compare this with another source with the values 0.05374 kgCO2/MJ for net and 0.05254 kgCO2/MJ for gross [6]. For gas, emissions from the supply chain are much smaller than for oil. Therefore a representative median figure has been taken of 0.053 kgCO2/MJ gross.

The supply used (i.e. total) CO2 emitted for heating oil is 0.077 kg/MJ [5]

The supply and use value for natural gas life cycle is 0.0530 kg/MJ [6]

Life cycle carbon dioxide impacts from solid fuel heating

The system for calculating life cycle coal emissions in [3] was derived from data on the French hard coal-fired electricity generation system, because of its similarity to the UK system, and then adjusting for the average prevailing total efficiency of European coal-fired electricity stations of 28.5 percent. The DTI provide a figure for the gross calorific value of house coal of 31.0 GJ/tonne [7], while kgCO2 emitted per tonne of coal burned is 2,419 [8]. Thus the use figure for domestic solid fuel heating is 0.078 kg/MJ. To this must be added a modest total of 0.01 kg/MJ emitted from production and supply, to yield total CO2 emitted, covering both supply and use of 0.088 kg/MJ [7,8]. When adjusted by the 28.5 percent European efficiency figure this yields a total figure for European electricity from coal of 0.309 kg/MJ, which checks with the figure in [3] of 0.315 kg/MJ.

Life cycle carbon dioxide impacts from electricity generation

General Methods of electricity provision are split into conventional thermal, hydroelectric, nuclear and other (including imports).

Conventional thermal: The conventional thermal figures are based on the emission figures already established, adjusted for the efficiencies assumed to be prevailing [9] (Table 3). CCGT plants in particular, and other natural gas plants to a lesser extent, are known to be increasing in efficiency. The transmission of electricity in all cases is taken to be distribution from the power station via the high voltage electricity grid to low voltage electricity for domestic use.

Other conventional sources: These contribute very little to overall emissions; their supply and use figures have been taken to be the average between CCGT and non-CCGT gas figures.

Hydroelectric power: Few figures are available. The most reliable come from Scandinavia where hydroelectric power takes up a very large proportion of electricity generated. Vattenfall, the largest Swedish hydroelectric utility, have performed a detailed life cycle assessment, suggesting 11g GWP-equivalents/kWh [10]. This equates to:

The supply and use for hydroelectric power is approximately 11g/3.6MW = 0.0031 kg/MJ [10]

TABLE 4

Assumed variations in average efficiencies of UK electricity generation plant (Year 2000 figures from [9])
1990 (est)
1995 (est)
2000
2003 (est)
Oil
0.25
0.25
0.25
0.25
Natural gas (CCGT)
0.4
0.43
0.46
0.49
Natural gas (non CCGT)
0.322
0.332
0.342
0.352
Coal for power stations
0.36
0.36
0.36
0.36

Nuclear energy: Two types of European nuclear reactor are common - the boiling water reactor (BWR) and the pressurised water reactor (PWR). Of these only the PWR is used in the UK (Sizewell B). The other types of reactor used in the UK are the advanced gas-cooled reactor (AGR) and Magnox power plants. These are peculiar to the UK and are not covered in [3]; therefore only electricity generation from the PWR is considered here. It is known that carbon dioxide emissions from nuclear power generation are very low; the figure is so low that variations in its value have no effect on the overall carbon dioxide intensity of the energy system, and we assume:

The supply and use value for nuclear energy is approximately 0.0031 kg/MJ.

Other non-conventional sources, and imports: These contribute very little to overall emissions; their supply and use figures have been taken to the average between the CCGT and non-CCGT gas figures.

Life cycle carbon dioxide emissions from UK electricity mix: These can now be calculated using the data and assumptions already made. In Table 4, the conversion efficiencies that have been assumed for thermal stations are shown in column A. Supply and use figures that have been assumed in this section are shown in column B.

The Digest of UK Energy Statistics gives data on the percentage of electricity supplied by the various generating sources [11]. These are shown in columns C0 for the baseline year 1990, and C1 and C2 for 1995 and 2003 respectively. For comparison, typical European values are shown in column D [4]. In columns E0, E1, and E2 are calculated the shares of carbon dioxide emissions from each of the generating sources on the left of the table, for the baseline year 1990, and for 1995 and 2003 respectively. These are summed to obtain carbon dioxide intensity values in kg/MJ for the whole generating mix.

The carbon intensity value for 1990 is presented as a range because the data in column C0 for that year was aggregated for the fuels coal, oil and non-CCGT gas. Even if the lowest value of this range were taken, there would still be a far sharper fall in CO2 intensity from 1990 to 1995 (0.191kg/MJ to 0.147 kg/MJ) than from 1995 to 2003 (0.147 kg/MJ to 0.134 kg/MJ). This suggests that the basis upon which the 1990 figures were collected may not be properly comparable with that used for figures after 1995.

Nevertheless, the most likely value in the range is indicated by assuming likely shares of 1990 UK supply. Here, taking 62 percent for coal, 15 percent for oil and 1 percent for gas, the figure of 0.199 kg/MJ has been calculated. This figure is assumed in the remainder of this document. Further, two "paths" of carbon intensity are postulated. Path 1 (Table 5.1 Annex1, Graph P) shows steady downward progress from the 1990 intensity figure to the 2003 intensity figure, and ignores the 1995 intensity figure of 0.147 kg/MJ. Path 2 (Table 5.2; Annex 1, Graph P) assumes steady (sharp) downward progress between the 1990 figure and the 1995 figure, and then much less severe downward progress towards the 2003 figure. The historic trends of CO2 emissions as implied by these paths, when matched against data from the Climate Change Inventory [12], are likely to yield useful information as to the historic and future course of CO2 emissions, and to any possible errors in emissions statistics.

Calculation of overall carbon dioxide emissions from UK delivered energy statistics and life cycle carbon dioxide values for each fuel

Overall carbon dioxide emissions corresponding to each end-use can now be calculated. The statistics for domestic energy consumption in Annex 2 are combined with the carbon dioxide values of the previous section. An example of the methodology will not be presented for the calculation of the 1990 space heating contribution to carbon dioxide emissions. The contribution itself comes from four sources:

Solid fuels: calculated from 1990 space heating solid fuel value (2,643 ktoe), converted to TJ by multiplying by 42.0 [2], then multiplied by CO2 for coal (0.088 kg/MJ), giving 9.77 Mt of carbon dioxide;

Gas: calculated from the 1990 space heating gas value (17,845 ktoe), converted to TJ by multiplying by 42.0 [2], then multiplied by CO2 for gas heating (0.0530 kg/MJ), giving 39.72 Mt of carbon dioxide.

Electricity: calculated from the 1990 space heating electricity value (1057 ktoe), converted to TJ by multiplying by 42.0 [2], then multiplied by CO2 for electricity for 1990 (0.199 kg/MJ, from Table 5.1 or 5.2 as appropriate to the path being calculated), giving 8.83 Mt of carbon dioxide for each path; and

Oil: calculated from 1990 space hating oil value (2,018 ktoe), converted to TJ by multiplying by 42.0 [2], then multiplied by CO2 for heating oil (0.077 kg/MJ), giving 6.53 Mt of carbon dioxide.

The four sources total 64.9 Mt of carbon dioxide, for both paths in Table 6.1 and Table 6.2. Contributions have been calculated likewise for each year, and for each path, between 1990 and 2002. The results are shown in Tables 6.1 and 6.2 and in Graphs B1 and B2 of Annex 1. For comparison, the figures for CO2 from the Review of the Climate Change Programme are also shown [12].

The results have also been converted to index values in Tables 7.1 and 7.2 and these are also shown in Graphs C1 and C2.

Table 4 Calculations of UK carbon dioxide intensity of electricity mix, for 1990, 1995 and 2003
A0
A1
A2
B0
B1
B2
C0
C1
C2
D
E0
E1
E2
Electricity source
Assumed conversion efficiencies for thermal stations, %
Supply and use carbon dioxide kg/MJ
% of UK supply
% of European supply

(for reference)
Shares supply and use kg/GJ
1990
1995
2003
1990
1995
2003
1990
1995
2003
1994
1990
1995
2003
Hard coal
36.0
36.0
36.0
0.244
0.244
0.244
78
42
35
17.5
19.032-24.024
10.27
8.46
Brown coal
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
n/a
0
0
10.5
0.00
0.00
Oil
25.0
25.0
25.0
0.308
0.308
0.308
4
1
9.7
1.23
0.37
Gas (non CCGT)
32.2
33.2
35.2
0.165
0.160
0.151
0.1
0
7.9
0.02
0.00
Gas (CCGT)
40.0
43.0
49.0
0.133
0.123
0.108
0.1
21
38
0
0.01
2.59
4.12
Other gases
36.1
38.1
42.1
0.149
0.141
0.129
0
0.9
0
1.9
0.00
0.13
0.12
Total conventional thermal
78.1
68
74
47.5
19.033-24.025
14.23
13.06
Hydro-power
0.0031
0.0031
0.0031
2.4
0.5
1
15.2
0.06
0.09
0.07
Nuclear
0.003
0.003
0.003
19.5
28.5
22
36.9
0.01
0.00
0.00
Other
0.149
0.141
0.129
0
1
2
0.4
0.00
0.14
0.22
Imports
0.149
0.141
0.129
0
2
1
0
0.00
0.28
0.06
100
100
100
100
19.103-24.032
14.74
13.42
Carbon dioxide intensity (kg/MJ)
0.191-0.240*
0.147
0.134

*MOST LIKELY VALUE 0.199, WITH SHARES OF UK SUPPLY COAL 62%, OIL 15% AND GAS 1%.

Table 5.1 Assumed path of UK electricity mix CO2 intensity (path 1: linear trend from 199kg/GJ in 1990 to 134 kg/GJ in 2003)
Assumed path of UK carbon dioxide intensity for electricity generation, kg/MJ
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001 20022003
0.199
0.194
0.189
0.184
0.179
0.174
0.169
0.164
0.159
0.154
0.149
0.144 0.1390.134

Table 5.2 Assumed path of UK electricity mix CO2intensity (path 2: linear trend from 199kg/GJ in 1990 to 147kg/GJ in 1995, followed by a separate linear trend from 147kg/GJ in 1995 to 134kg/GJ in 2003)
Assumed path of UK carbon dioxide intensity for electricity generation, kg/MJ
19901991 19921993 19941995 19961997 19981999 20002001 20022003
0.1990.189 0.1780.168 0.1570.147 0.1450.144 0.1420.141 0.1390. 137 0.1360.134

Table 6.1 Calculated CO2 values for UK end-use sectors in Megatonnes CO2, 1990-2002 (path 1). Figures shown in Graph B.1
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
64.9
75.6
73.1
75.5
71.2
67.2
81.5
71.4
75.7
74.5
75.3
79.5
76.1
Hot water
30.5
30.1
30.9
32.0
31.2
30.4
30.4
30.3
29.9
30.2
30.0
30.4
30.2
Lights & Appliances
45.5
45.7
44.4
43.7
43.0
42.2
41.4
40.6
39.8
38.9
38.0
37.1
36.3
Cooking
7.6
7.3
7.0
6.7
6.5
6.2
6.0
5.9
5.7
5.5
5.4
5.2
5.1
Total
148.4
158.8
155.3
158.0
151.9
146.1
159.3
148.2
151.1
149.1
148.7
152.2
147.6
Climate Change Inventory
152.9
150.5
148.1
145.6
143.2
140.8
141.6
142.4
143.2
144.0
144.8
145.6
146.4

Table 6.2 Calculated CO2 values for UK end-use sectors in Megatonnes CO2, 1990 - 2002 (path 2). Figures shown in Graph B.2
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
64.9
75.3
72.5
74.7
70.1
65.7
79.7
70.2
74.4
73.5
74.5
78.9
75.8
Hot water
30.5
29.9
30.4
31.2
30.2
29.2
29.4
29.4
29.2
29.6
29.5
30.0
30.0
Lights & Appliances
45.5
44.4
41.8
39.8
37.8
35.7
35.6
35.6
35.6
35.5
35.5
35.4
35.4
Cooking
7.6
7.2
6.7
6.3
5.9
5.5
5.4
5.3
5.3
5.2
5.1
5.0
5.0
Total
148.4
156.9
151.4
152.1
143.9
136.1
150.2
140.5
144.5
143.7
144.6
149.4
146.2
Climate Change Inventory
152.9
150.5
148.1
145.6
143.2
140.8
141.6
142.4
143.2
144.0
144.8
145.6
146.4

Table 7.1 Calculated CO2 values for UK end-use sectors (1990 = 100) (path 1). Figures shown in Graph C.1
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
100.0
116.6
112.6
116.4
109.7
103.7
125.6
110.1
116.7
114.8
116.1
122.6
117.3
Hot water
100.0
98.6
101.1
105.0
102.3
99.6
99.7
99.1
98.1
98.9
98.2
99.4
98.8
Lights & Appliances
100.0
100.6
97.6
96.1
94.6
92.9
91.0
89.3
87.5
85.6
83.7
81.6
79.7
Cooking
100.0
97.2
92.2
88.7
85.5
82.7
80.1
77.7
75.4
73.1
71.0
68.9
66.9
Total
100.0
107.0
104.6
106.4
102.3
98.4
107.4
99.8
101.8
100.5
100.2
102.5
99.4
Climate Change Inventory
100.0
98.4
96.8
95.3
93.7
92.1
92.6
93.1
93.7
94.2
94.7
95.3
95.8

Table 7.2 Calculated CO2 values for UK end-use sectors (1990 = 100) (path 2). Figures shown in Graph C.2
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
100.0
116.1
111.7
115.2
108.0
101.3
122.9
108.1
114.7
113.2
114.9
121.7
116.9
Hot water
100.0
97.9
99.6
102.4
98.9
95.6
96.4
96.4
95.6
96.8
96.6
98.3
98.3
Lights & Appliances
100.0
97.8
92.0
87.7
83.2
78.5
78.3
78.3
78.2
78.1
78.0
77.8
77.8
Cooking
100.0
95.1
88.2
82.9
77.9
73.3
71.9
70.8
69.6
68.6
67.6
66.6
65.8
Total
100.0
105.7
102.0
102.5
97.0
91.7
101.2
94.7
97.3
96.8
97.4
100.6
98.5
Climate Change Inventory
100.0
98.4
96.8
95.3
93.7
92.1
92.6
93.1
93.7
94.2
94.7
95.3
95.8

References:

[1] http://www.dti.gov.uk/energy/inform/energy_consumption/table/table3_7.xls July 2004.

[2] Conversion constant from http://www.eppo.go.th/ref/UNIT_OIL.html

[3] Michaelis, P, Life Cycle Assessment of Energy Systems, CES Working paper 05/00, Report to the UK Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution, 2000, ISSN 1464-8083

[4] Frischknecht, R, and Suter, P, Environmental Life Cycle Inventories of Energy Systems, ETH Zurich and Paul Scherrer Institute, Villigen 1996

[5] National Energy Foundation Website: http://www.natenergy.org.uk/oil-ch.htm

[6] From "The engineering toolbox" website; Fuel gases-Heating values for natural gas and corresponding conversion constants; http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/heating-values-fuel-gases-9_823.html

[7] DTI energy statistics-calorific values; http://dti.gov.uk/energy/inform/table_a1_a2.xls

[8] Defra, guidelines for company reporting on greenhouse gas emissions, Annex 1 -fuel conversion factors; http://www.defra.gov.uk/environment/envrp/gas/05.htm

[9] Digest of UK Energy Statistics (2004), Table 5.10, June 2005; http://dti.gov.uk/energy/inform/dukes/dukes2004/index.shtml

[10] http://www.vattenfall.com/files/responsibilities/lcaeng_03.pdf ; pp 6-7

[11] Digest of UK Energy Statistics (2004), Tables 5.1.1, 5.1.3, and 5.6. On the recommendation of Mike James of ONS, Table 5.6 has been used for the 2003 figures; May 2005. http://www.dti.gov.uk/energy/inform/dukes/dukes2004/index.shtml

[12] Review of the UK Climate Change Programme, Table 6 (Residential sector, expressed in MtC: convert to MtCO2 by multiplying by 44 and dividing by 12); http://www.defra.gov.uk/corporate/consult/ukccp-review/ccpreview-consult.pdf

Annex 1

Graph A




Graph P



Graph B.1



Graph B.2



Graph C.1


FIGURE 8C.2


Annex 2

UK Domestic energy consumption by end-use and fuel, 1990 to 2002 (ktoe) [1]
SOLID FUEL
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
2643
3296
3040
3494
2885
2063
2223
1899
1778
1859
1498
1716
1309
Hot water
1511
1268
939
891
730
553
570
564
559
547
431
475
496
Lights & Appliances
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cooking
14
13
12
11
10
9
8
7
7
6
6
5
5
Total
4169
4577
3990
4396
3625
2625
2801
2470
2343
2412
1935
2197
1810

GAS
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
17845
20381
19953
20728
19624
19088
23472
20696
21568
21793
22662
23514
23044
Hot water
7186
7563
7676
7780
7998
8225
8128
8302
8326
8292
8446
8415
8623
Lights & Appliances
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
Cooking
802
775
758
744
732
722
714
710
705
701
697
693
689
Total
25835
28721
28389
29254
28355
28037
32317
29710
30601
30788
31806
32625
32358


ELECTRICITY
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
1057
1299
1276
1164
1218
1327
1777
1508
1788
1757
1816
2000
2028
Hot water
893
850
1039
1180
1152
1062
1019
969
1056
1108
1121
1185
1017
Lights & Appliances
5436
5608
5584
5651
5717
5774
5827
5889
5953
6013
6076
6133
6206
Cooking
679
679
655
644
634
627
621
616
611
607
603
600
597
Total
8066
8436
8555
8639
8721
8790
9244
8982
9408
9485
9617
9917
9848


OIL
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
2018
2310
2247
2300
2362
2291
2592
2456
2832
2377
2447
2691
2504
Hot water
451
504
633
711
634
699
920
927
705
780
787
831
983
Lights & Appliances
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Cooking
11
10
9
9
8
7
7
6
5
5
5
5
5
Total
2480
2825
2889
3019
3004
2997
3518
3389
3543
3162
3239
3527
3491


Total UK domestic energy consumption by end-use and fuel (ktoe)
1990
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
Space heating
23563
27287
26515
27686
26089
24769
30063
26559
27966
27786
28423
29921
28884
Hot water
10042
10185
10287
10562
10514
10540
10638
10762
10646
10727
10786
10906
11119
Lights & Appliances
5438
5610
5586
5653
5719
5776
5830
5891
5955
6016
6079
6136
6209
Cooking
1507
1478
1435
1407
1384
1364
1350
1339
1328
1319
1310
1303
1296
Total
40550
44559
43823
45308
43705
42449
47880
44551
45895
45847
46597
48265
47508



116   Report commissioned by the Committee, and prepared by Dr Phil Sinclair MA CertEd MSc PhD, of the University of Surrey. Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2005