The following witnesses gave evidence. Those marked
* gave oral and written evidence and those marked ** only gave
oral evidence.
| Alliance Party of Northern Ireland
|
| Australian Commonwealth Grants Commission
|
** | Lord Barnett |
| Madoc Batcup |
** | Professor David BellUniversity of Stirling
|
* | Dr Gillian BristowCardiff School of City & Regional Planning
|
** | Mr Peter Bunting Irish Congress of Trade Unions, Northern Ireland
|
| cebr ltd |
* | Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy
|
| City of London |
** | Mr John CoreyNorthern Ireland Public Service Alliance
|
| COSLA |
| David Hume Institute |
* | Department of Finance and Personnel (Northern Ireland)
|
* | Department of Health |
| East England Development Agency
|
* | Economic Research Institute of Northern Ireland
|
| Federal Trust for Education and Research
|
* | Professor James Foreman-PeckCardiff Business School
|
* | Mr Jim GallagherMinistry of Justice
|
* | Mr Paul GriffithsConsultant to the Welsh Local Government Association
|
* | Dr Eurfyl ap GwilymPlaid Cymru
|
| Professor David HealdUniversity of Aberdeen Business School
|
* | Mr Victor HewittEconomic Research Institute of Northern Ireland
|
* | HM Treasury |
| The Independent Experts Group to the Commission on Scottish Devolution
|
* | Professor David KingUniversity of Stirling
|
| Local Government Association
|
| London Councils |
** | Lord MacGregor of Pulham Market
|
** | Mr Seamus McAleaveyNorthern Ireland Council for Voluntary Action
|
* | Mr Patrick McCartanNorthern Ireland Confederation of Health & Social Services
|
* | Professor Iain McLeanUniversity of Oxford and IPPR North
|
| Russell Mellet |
** | Mr David MoxhamScottish TUC
|
** | Rt. Hon Jim Murphy MPSecretary of State for Scotland
|
** | Rt. Hon Paul Murphy MPSecretary of State for Wales
|
* | National Health Service |
| Northern Ireland Civil Service
|
* | Northern Ireland Confederation for Health and Social Services
|
** | Mr John OsmondInstitute for Welsh Affairs
|
| Parliament for Wales Campaign
|
* | Plaid Cymru |
* | Mr Peter Price, Cymru YforyTomorrow's Wales
|
| Reform Scotland |
* | Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
|
* | The Scottish Government (NHS Scotland)
|
* | Mr Ruchir ShahScottish Council for Voluntary Organisations
|
* | Professor John SimpsonQueen's University, Belfast
|
** | Mr Michael SmythUniversity of Ulster
|
| Society of County Treasurers
|
| Sustrans Cymru |
** | Professor Kim SwalesUniversity of Strathclyde
|
* | Mr John Swinney MSPCabinet Secretary for Finance & Sustainable Growth, the Scottish Government
|
** | Mr Geraint Talfan-DaviesInstitute for Welsh Affairs
|
| TaxPayers Alliance |
* | Professor Colin ThainUniversity of Ulster
|
** | Sir Brian Unwin |
* | Wales Council for Voluntary Action
|
* | Welsh Local Government Association
|
** | Rt. Hon Shaun WoodwardSecretary of State for Northern Ireland
|