Annual Report 2007-08 - Constitution Committee Contents


APPENDIX 1: PROGRESS OF SCRUTINY


Title
Bill Number
First discussed[27]
Comments
Action
Cleared
Queen's Speech
14/11/07
Local Transport Bill
HL 1, 15, 19
14/11/07
NFA
X
Dormant Bank and Building Society Accounts Bill
HL 2, 17, 26
28/11/07
NFA
X
House of Lords Bill
HL 3
N/A
Lord Steel PMB
Disabled Persons (Independent Living) Bill
HL 4
N/A
Lord Ashley PMB
Powers of Entry Etc. Bill
HL 5, 71
N/A
Lord Selsdon PMB
Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill
HL 6, 25
14/11/07
NFA
X
Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Bill
HL 7, 31, 46
28/11/07
Concern about the complex nature of the schemes proposed by the bill, which include powers for ministers by means of "directions" to suspend and revoke suspensions of regulators' powers to impose sanctions; the extent to which it is constitutionally appropriate for regulatory authorities to make determinations as to whether a person has committed a criminal offence and to impose unlimited financial penalties; and whether the procedural protections provided in the bill match up to the minimum standards of procedural fairness that a person accused of a criminal offence ought to have. Report published; agreed that Chairman would table amendments on behalf of the Committee; amendments tabled in Grand Committee; amendments tabled at Report; Government agreed to table their own amendments to reflect the Committee's recommendations; amendments agreed to.
X
Children and Young Persons Bill
HL 8, 20, 32, 42
28/11/07
NFA
X
Climate Change Bill
HL 9, 29, 44
28/11/07
NFA
X
Alcohol Labelling Bill
HL 10, 53, 64
N/A
Lord Mitchell PMB
Kidney Transplant Bill
HL 11
N/A
Baroness Finlay PMB
Child Maintenance and Other Payments Bill
HL 12, 35, 57
12/12/07
Concern that it is constitutionally inappropriate for a British citizen to be prevented from leaving the country by administrative action of the new Child Maintenance and Enforcement Commission (CMEC) rather than an order of the court, as the bill proposes. Report published; agreed that Chairman would table amendments on behalf of the Committee; amendments tabled in Grand Committee; amendments tabled for Report Stage but withdrawn after Government agreed to table their own amendments to reflect the Committee's recommendations; amendments agreed to.
X
Employment Bill
HL 13, 49, 60
16/1/08
NFA
X
Crossrail (Hybrid Bill) Bill
HL 14, 61, 70
N/A
Hybrid Bill
X
Criminal Justice and Immigration Bill
HL 16, 41, 51, 54
30/1/08
Concerns about the provisions changing the role of the Court of Appeal in appeals against convictions, and about the proposed Violent Offender Orders. Wrote to minister; Court of Appeal proposals dropped; Committee agreed to commission paper on civil preventative orders in general.
X
European Communities (Finance) Bill
HL 18
23/1/08
NFA
X
Channel Tunnel Rail Link (Supplementary Provisions) Bill
HL 21
6/2/08
NFA
X
House of Lords (Amendment) Bill
HL 22
N/A
Lord Avebury PMB
Retail Development Bill
HL 23
N/A
Lord Cotter PMB
Sale of Student Loans Bill
HL 24, 55, 63
6/2/08
NFA
X
Safety Deposit Current Accounts Bill
HL 27
N/A
Earl of Caithness PMB
National Insurance Contributions Bill
HL 28, 73, 78
20/2/08
NFA
X
Torture (Damages) Bill
HL 30
N/A
Lord Archer of Sandwell PMB
Health and Social Care Bill
HL 33, 62, 68
2/4/08
Concern that the enforcement powers to be given to the CQC are different from any of those powers contained in Part 3 of the Regulatory Enforcement and Sanctions Bill. Concluded that this bill's scheme should be added to the RES Bill. Wrote to minister; wrote to Pat McFadden MP to request that the scheme in this bill be added to the RES Bill.
X
Banking (Special Provisions) Bill
HL 34, 36
20/2/08
Concerns about lack of time for parliamentary scrutiny; use of negative rather than affirmative resolution procedure; scope of bill; use of public rather than hybrid bill; length of period before sunset clause takes effect; and Henry VIII clauses. Wrote to minister; Committee opted to address the issues of emergency legislation and hybridity at a future date, perhaps as part of a follow-up report to Parliament and the Legislative Process.
X
Statute Law (Repeals) Bill
HL 37
2/4/08
NFA
X
House of Lords (Members' Taxation Status) Bill
HL 38
N/A
Lord Oakeshott of Seagrove Bay PMB
Sunday Trading (Horticulture) Bill
HL 39
N/A
Earl of Courtown PMB
European Union (Amendment) Bill
HL 40
12/3/08
Evidence taken; report published; amendment tabled at Committee Stage; amendment rejected at Report Stage; Government compromise.
X
Immigration (Discharged Gurkhas) Bill
HL 43
N/A
Lord Lee of Trafford PMB
Iraq War Inquiry Bill
HL 45
N/A
Lord McNally PMB
Housing and Regeneration Bill
HL 47, 67, 77
7/5/08
NFA
X
Borough Freedom (No. 2) Bill
HL 48
N/A
Lord Graham PMB
Pensions Bill
HL 50
4/6/08
Concern about civil sanctioning powers. Wrote to minister; reply received; copies distributed.
X
Energy Bill
HL 52, 72
14/5/08
NFA
X
Planning and Energy Bill
HL 56, 75
N/A
Michael Fallon PMB
Education and Skills
HL 58, 80
Concern about civil sanctioning powers. Wrote to minister; reply received; copies distributed.
X
Special Educational Needs (Information) Bill
HL 59
N/A
Baroness Pitkeathley PMB
Counter-Terrorism Bill
HL 65
11/6/08
Wrote to minister; reply received; copies distributed; Report published.
Health and Safety (Offences) Bill
HL 66
N/A
Keith Hill PMB
Planning Bill
HL 69
8/10/08
NFA
X
Finance Bill
HL 74
N/A
No scrutiny.
X
Criminal Evidence (Witness Anonymity) Bill
HL 76
9/07/08
Set out constitutional context of the emergency legislation. Report published.
X



27   Date of discussion in Committee Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2009