Table of Contents for
Thursday 3 Mar 2016

Volume No. 769Part No. 119

Clicking on an entry will fetch the appropriate file and position it with the item at the top of the screen.

Following the Table of Contents is a more detailed list which gives subject headings, timelines and names of speakers


House of Lords

Student Loans: Muslim Students - Question

Water Billing - Question

Prisons: Violence - Question

Immigration: Harmondsworth - Question

Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders

Housing and Planning Bill - Committee (3rd Day)

Clause 2: What is a starter home?

Amendment 37B

Circular Economy - Question for Short Debate

Housing and Planning Bill - Committee (3rd Day) (Continued)

Amendment 38

Amendment 41

Amendment 42A

Amendments 44A and 44B

Amendments 45A and 45B

Clause 3: General duty to promote supply of starter homes

Clause 4: Planning permission: provision of starter homes

Amendment 50A

Amendment 50F

Clause 5: Monitoring

Clause 6: Compliance directions

Clause 7: Interpretation of this Chapter

Amendment 53E

Grand Committee

Armed Forces Bill - Committee (2nd day)

Amendment 10

Amendment 12

Amendment 13

Amendment 17

Amendment 18

Amendment 20A

Amendment 21

Amendment 22A

Clause 19: Commencement and transitional provision





This Table of Contents lists subject headings, timelines and
names of speakers in the Lords Hansard text for
Thursday 3 Mar 2016

Column: 933

House of Lords [3 Mar 2016]

11 am

Student Loans: Muslim Students - Question

11.05 am

Baroness Evans of Bowes Park (Con):

Lord Sharkey (LD):

Baroness Evans of Bowes Park:

Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town (Lab):

Baroness Evans of Bowes Park:

Column: 934

Lord Pearson of Rannoch (UKIP):

Baroness Evans of Bowes Park:

Lord Forsyth of Drumlean (Con):

Baroness Evans of Bowes Park:

Lord Elton (Con):

Baroness Evans of Bowes Park:

Lord Pearson of Rannoch:

Column: 935

Lord Newby (LD):

Lord Tebbit (Con):

The Lord Privy Seal (Baroness Stowell of Beeston) (Con):

Column: 936

Baroness Evans of Bowes Park:

Water Billing - Question

11.14 am

Lord Gardiner of Kimble (Con):

Lord Redesdale (LD):

Lord Gardiner of Kimble:

Column: 937

Lord Gardiner of Kimble:

Baroness McIntosh of Pickering (Con):

Lord Gardiner of Kimble:

Lord Rooker (Lab):

Lord Gardiner of Kimble:

Lord Whitty (Lab):

Lord Gardiner of Kimble:

Baroness Jones of Whitchurch (Lab):

Column: 938

Lord Gardiner of Kimble:

Lord Holmes of Richmond (Con):

Lord Gardiner of Kimble:

Prisons: Violence - Question

11.21 am

The Minister of State, Ministry of Justice (Lord Faulks) (Con):

Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD):

Lord Faulks:

Column: 939

Lord Cashman (Lab):

Lord Faulks:

The Lord Bishop of St Albans:

Lord Faulks:

Lord Hamilton of Epsom (Con):

Column: 940

Lord Faulks:

Baroness Corston (Lab):

Lord Faulks:

Lord Dholakia (LD):

Lord Faulks:

Column: 941

Immigration: Harmondsworth - Question

11.30 am

The Minister of State, Home Office (Lord Bates) (Con):

Lord Roberts of Llandudno (LD):

Lord Bates:

Lord Trimble (Con):

Lord Bates:

Lord Rosser (Lab):

Lord Bates:

Lord Lea of Crondall (Lab):

Lord Greaves (LD):

Lord Bates:

Lord Lea of Crondall

Lord Bates:

Lord Foulkes of Cumnock (Lab):

Lord Scriven (LD):

Column: 943

The Lord Privy Seal (Baroness Stowell of Beeston) (Con):

Lord Foulkes of Cumnock:

Lord Bates:

Business of the House - Motion on Standing Orders

11.36 am

Housing and Planning Bill - Committee (3rd Day)

11.36 am

Clause 2: What is a starter home?

Amendment 37B

Lord Shipley (LD):

Baroness Hollis of Heigham (Lab):

Lord Shipley:

Column: 944

Lord Kennedy of Southwark (Lab):

Column: 945

Lord Young of Cookham (Con):

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Lord Young of Cookham:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Lord Young of Cookham:

11.45 am

Lord Campbell-Savours (Lab):

Column: 946

Column: 947

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Column: 948

Column: 949

Noon

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Royall of Blaisdon (Lab):

Lord Beecham (Lab):

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Gardner of Parkes (Con):


Column: 951

Lord Greaves (LD):

Column: 952

12.15 pm

Column: 953

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Communities and Local Government (Baroness Williams of Trafford) (Con):

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 954

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 955

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Column: 956

12.30 pm

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:

Column: 957

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:


Column: 958

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Column: 959

Baroness Blackstone (Lab):

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

12.45 pm

Baroness Blackstone:

Column: 960

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:

Column: 961

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Column: 962

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Lord Beecham:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 963

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

1 pm

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Column: 964

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Column: 965

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Royall of Blaisdon:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Column: 966

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Young of Old Scone (Lab):

Baroness Williams of Trafford:


Column: 967

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Column: 968

Baroness Williams of Trafford:


Column: 969

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Blackstone:

Column: 970

Baroness Grender (LD):

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Column: 971

1.30 pm

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Grender:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 972

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Column: 973

Lord Skelmersdale (Con):

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Column: 974

Viscount Younger of Leckie (Con):

Lord Shipley:


Column: 975

Circular Economy - Question for Short Debate

1.46 pm

Baroness Jones of Whitchurch (Lab):

Column: 976


Column: 977

Column: 978

1.57 pm

Baroness Jenkin of Kennington (Con):


Column: 979

2.01 pm

Lord Whitty (Lab):


Column: 980

2.05 pm

Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer (LD):

2.08 pm

Baroness Young of Hornsey (CB):

Column: 981

Column: 982

2.12 pm

The Lord Bishop of St Albans:

2.15 pm

Lord Suri (Con):

Column: 983

2.18 pm

Lord Giddens (Lab):


Column: 984

2.21 pm

Lord Rees of Ludlow (CB):


Column: 985

2.25 pm

Lord Young of Norwood Green (Lab):


Column: 986

2.29 pm

Lord Teverson (LD):

Column: 987

2.32 pm

Lord Gardiner of Kimble (Con):


Column: 988


Column: 989


Column: 990

Housing and Planning Bill - Committee (3rd Day) (Continued)

2.47 pm

Amendment 38

Lord Beecham (Lab):

Column: 991

Lord Campbell-Savours (Lab):

Lord Beecham:


Column: 992

The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Baroness McIntosh of Hudnall) (Lab):

Lord Best (CB):

Column: 993

3 pm

Column: 994

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Lord Best:

Column: 996

Lord Kerslake (CB):


Column: 997

3.15 pm

Column: 998


Column: 999

Lord Young of Cookham (Con):

Baroness Hollis of Heigham (Lab):

Column: 1000

Lord Young of Cookham:

Baroness Bakewell of Hardington Mandeville (LD):


Column: 1001

3.30 pm

Lord Horam (Con):


Column: 1002

Lord Kerslake:

Lord Horam:


Column: 1003

Lord Shipley (LD):

Column: 1004

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Lord Shipley:

Lord Beecham:

Column: 1005

3.45 pm

Lord Shipley:

Lord Cameron of Dillington (CB):

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Communities and Local Government (Baroness Williams of Trafford):

Lord Cameron of Dillington:


Column: 1006

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Column: 1007

Lord Campbell-Savours:

The Earl of Lytton (CB):

Column: 1008

4 pm

Column: 1009


Column: 1010

Lord True (Con):

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Lord True:

Column: 1011

4.15 pm

Lord McKenzie of Luton (Lab):

Column: 1012


Baroness Gardner of Parkes (Con):

Lord McKenzie of Luton:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:


Column: 1013

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark (Lab):

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1014

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:


Column: 1015

Lord Best:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

4.30 pm

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1016

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Blackstone (Lab):


Column: 1017

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kerslake:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1018

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1019

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Shipley:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1020

4.45 pm

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Lord Beecham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1021

Lord Kerslake:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Beecham:


Column: 1022

Amendment 41

Column: 1023

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

5 pm

Baroness Doocey (LD):


Column: 1024

Column: 1025

Lord Kerslake:

Column: 1026

Lord True:

Lord Deben (Con):


Column: 1027

5.15 pm

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1028

Lord Kerslake:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Deben:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1029

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1030

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Amendment 42A

Amendments 44A and 44B

Amendments 45A and 45B

Column: 1031

Clause 3: General duty to promote supply of starter homes

Clause 4: Planning permission: provision of starter homes

Amendment 50A

Lord Cameron of Dillington:

5.30 pm

Column: 1032


Column: 1033

Lord Young of Cookham:

Column: 1034

Lord Deben:


Column: 1035

5.45 pm

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Column: 1036

Lord Deben:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Lord Stoneham of Droxford (LD):

The Duke of Somerset (CB):

Column: 1037

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

The Duke of Somerset:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

The Duke of Somerset:


Column: 1038

Lord Best:


Column: 1039

6 pm

Column: 1040

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:


Column: 1041

Lord Campbell-Savours:


Column: 1042

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1043

6.15 pm

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1044

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Column: 1045

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Campbell-Savours:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Cameron of Dillington:


Column: 1046

6.30 pm

Lord Best:

Lord Cameron of Dillington:

Column: 1047

Amendment 50F

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Hollis of Heigham:


Column: 1048

Baroness Grender:


Column: 1049

The Earl of Lytton:

Column: 1050

Lord Greaves:

6.45 pm

Column: 1051

Baroness Young of Old Scone (Lab):

Lord Deben:

Column: 1052

Baroness Williams of Trafford:


Column: 1053

Baroness Grender:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Column: 1054

Column: 1055

7 pm

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Greaves:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Clause 5: Monitoring

Clause 6: Compliance directions

Clause 7: Interpretation of this Chapter

Amendment 53E

Column: 1056

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Baroness Williams of Trafford:


Column: 1057

Column: 1058

Lord Kennedy of Southwark:

Column: GC147

Grand Committee [3 Mar 2016]

Armed Forces Bill - Committee (2nd day)

2 pm

The Deputy Chairman of Committees (Baroness Henig) (Lab):

Amendment 10

Lord Craig of Radley (CB):


Column: GC148

Lord Hope of Craighead (CB):

Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood (CB):


Column: GC149

Baroness Smith of Newnham (LD):

Earl Attlee (Con):

Column: GC150

2.15 pm

Lord Thomas of Gresford (LD):


Column: GC151

Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood:

Lord Thomas of Gresford:

The Minister of State, Ministry of Defence (Earl Howe) (Con):

Column: GC152

Lord Empey (UUP):

Column: GC153

Earl Howe:

Lord Tunnicliffe:

Earl Howe:

Lord Tunnicliffe:

Earl Howe:

Lord Craig of Radley:

Amendment 12

Column: GC154

Earl Attlee:

2.30 pm

Baroness Jolly (LD):


Column: GC155

Earl Attlee:

Lord West of Spithead (Lab):

Lord Touhig (Lab):

Column: GC156

Earl Howe:

Column: GC157

Earl Attlee:

Earl Howe:

Earl Attlee:

Amendment 13

Column: GC158

Lord Judd (Lab):


Column: GC159

2.45 pm

Column: GC160


Column: GC161

The Earl of Dundee (Con):

Lord Tunnicliffe:

Column: GC162

3 pm

Earl Howe:

Column: GC163


Column: GC164

Column: GC165

Lord Judd:

3.15 pm

Column: GC166

Amendment 17

Lord Thomas of Gresford:


Column: GC167

Earl Attlee:


Column: GC168


Column: GC169

3.30 pm

Column: GC170

Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood:


Column: GC171

Lord Hope of Craighead:


Column: GC172

Lord Thomas of Gresford:

Earl Attlee:

Lord West of Spithead:

Earl Attlee:

Column: GC173

3.45 pm

Lord West of Spithead:

Lord Thomas of Gresford:

Lord West of Spithead:

Viscount Slim (CB):

Column: GC174

Lord Touhig:


Column: GC175

Earl Howe:


Column: GC176

4 pm

Column: GC177

Amendment 18

Earl Attlee:

Column: GC178


Column: GC179

Lord Tunnicliffe:


Column: GC180

4.15 pm

Earl Howe:

Column: GC181


Column: GC182


Column: GC183

Earl Attlee:

Amendment 20A

Earl Attlee:

Column: GC184

Baroness Jolly:

Earl Attlee:

4.30 pm

Baroness Jolly:

Earl Attlee:

Column: GC185

Baroness Jolly:

Lord West of Spithead:

Lord Touhig:


Column: GC186

Earl Howe:


Column: GC187

Earl Attlee:

Column: GC188

Earl Howe:

Earl Attlee:

4.45 pm

Amendment 21

Lord West of Spithead:


Column: GC189

Earl Howe:

Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB):


Column: GC190

Column: GC191

Column: GC192

Lord Empey:


Column: GC193

5 pm

Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood:


Column: GC194

Baroness Jolly:

Lord Touhig:

Column: GC195

Earl Attlee:

Lord Alton of Liverpool:

Earl Howe:


Column: GC196

5.15 pm

Column: GC197

Lord Tunnicliffe:

Earl Howe:

Lord West of Spithead:

Amendment 22A

Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts (Con):


Column: GC199

Column: GC200


Column: GC201

5.30 pm

Baroness Smith of Newnham:

Column: GC202

Lord Thomas of Gresford:

Lord Touhig:


Column: GC203

Earl Howe:


Column: GC204

Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts:


Column: GC205

Column: GC206

Clause 19: Commencement and transitional provision