AI in the UK: ready, willing and able? Contents

Appendix 2: List of witnesses

Evidence is published online at http://www.parliament.uk/business/committees/committees-a-z/lords-select/ai-committee/ and available for inspection at the Parliamentary Archives (020 7219 3074).

Evidence received by the Committee is listed below in chronological order of oral evidence session and in alphabetical order. Those witnesses marked with ** gave both oral evidence and written evidence. Those marked with * gave oral evidence and did not submit any written evidence. All other witnesses submitted written evidence only.

Oral evidence in chronological order

*

Professor Nick Bostrom, Director, Future of Humanity Institute

QQ 1–8

*

Professor Dame Wendy Hall, Regius Professor of Computer Science, University of Southampton

**

Professor Michael Wooldridge, Head of Department and Professor of Computer Science, University of Oxford

*

Rory Cellan-Jones, Technology Correspondent, BBC News

QQ 9–17

*

Sarah O’Connor, Employment Correspondent, Financial Times

*

Andrew Orlowski, Executive Editor, The Register

*

Dr Ing. Konstantinos Karachalios, Managing Director, IEEE-Standards Association

QQ 18–28

*

Professor Alan Winfield, Professor of Robot Ethics, University of the West of England

*

Jeremy Barnett, Barrister, St Pauls Chambers, Leeds and Gough Square Chambers

QQ 29–37

**

Professor Chris Reed, Professor of Electronic Commerce Law, Queen Mary University of London

*

Professor Karen Yeung, Professor of Law and Director of the Centre for Technology, Ethics, Law and Society at Dickson Poon School of Law, King’s College London

*

Dr David Barber, Turing Fellow, The Alan Turing Institute, and Reader in Computational Statistics and Machine Learning, UCL

QQ 38–45

**

Dr Marko Balabanovic, Chief Technology Officer, Digital Catapult

**

Dr Timothy Lanfear, Director of EMEA Solution Architecture & Engineering Team, NVIDIA

*

Eileen Burbidge MBE, Partner, Passion Capital

QQ 46–54

*

David Kelnar, Investment Director and Head of Research, MMC Ventures

*

Libby Kinsey, Co-founder, Project Juno

**

Dr Mercedes Bunz, Senior Lecturer, Communications and Media Research Institute, University of Westminster

QQ 55–64

**

Elizabeth Denham, UK Information Commissioner, Information Commissioner’s Office

*

Dr Sandra Wachter, Postdoctoral Researcher in Data Ethics and Algorithms, Oxford Internet Institute

*

Olivier Thereaux, Head of Technology, The Open Data Institute

QQ 65–75

*

Javier Ruiz Diaz, Policy Director, The Open Rights Group

**

Frederike Kaltheuner, Policy Officer, Privacy International

**

Dr James Luke, Chief Technology Officer for the Public Sector, IBM

QQ 76–84

**

Kriti Sharma, Vice President of Artificial Intelligence and Bots, Sage

*

Andrew de Rozairo, Vice President, Customer Innovation and Enterprise Platform, SAP

*

Colin Griffiths, Policy Manager, Citizens Advice

QQ 85–94

**

Will Hayter, Project Director, Competition and Markets Authority

**

Olly Buston, CEO and Founder, Future Advocacy

QQ 95–104

*

Professor Dame Henrietta Moore, Director, Institute for Global Prosperity, UCL

**

Professor Richard Susskind OBE, IT Adviser to the Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales

*

Dr Mark Taylor, Global Strategy & Research Director, Dyson

QQ 105–115

**

Dr Joseph Reger, Chief Technology Officer EMEIA, Fujitsu

**

Paul Clarke, Chief Technology Officer, Ocado

*

Dr Julian Huppert, Chair, Independent Review Panel for DeepMind Health

QQ 116–127

**

Dr Sobia Raza, Head of Science, PHG Foundation

*

Nicola Perrin, Head, Understanding Patient Data, Wellcome Trust

**

Dr Hugh Harvey, Clinical Artificial Intelligence Researcher and Consultant Radiologist, Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust

QQ 128–142

*

Dame Fiona Caldicott, National Data Guardian for Health and Care, Office of the National Data Guardian

*

Professor Martin Severs, Medical Director, NHS Digital

**

Dr Mark Briers, Strategic Programme Director for Defence and Security, The Alan Turing Institute

QQ 143–152

*

Professor Chris Hankin, Co-Director, Institute for Security Science and Technology, Imperial College London

*

Major Kitty McKendrick, Visiting Fellow, Chatham House

QQ 153–162

**

Professor Noel Sharkey, Emeritus Professor of Artificial Intelligence and Robotics and Public Engagement, University of Sheffield

*

Mike Stone, Former Chief of Digital and Information Officer, Ministry of Defence

*

Dr Alvin Wilby, Vice President Research, Technical and Innovation, Thales Group

*

Professor Wolfgang Wahlster, CEO and Scientific Director, German Research Centre for Artificial Intelligence (DFKI)

QQ 163–171

**

Dr Alan Bernstein, President and CEO, Canadian Institute for Advanced Research (CIFAR)

QQ 172–180

**

Miles Berry, Principal Lecturer, School of Education, University of Roehampton

QQ 181–189

*

Graham Brown-Martin, Author and entrepreneur

**

Professor Rosemary Luckin, Professor of Learner Centred Design, UCL Institute of Education

**

The Rt Hon Matt Hancock MP, Minister of State for Digital, Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport

QQ 190–200

**

The Rt Hon the Lord Henley, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State at the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy

*

Dr Jérôme Pesenti, CEO, BenevolentTech at BenevolentAI

QQ 201–212

*

Professor David Edgerton, Hans Rausing Professor of the History of Science and Technology, and Professor of Modern British History, King’s College London

QQ 213–223

*

Professor Peter McOwan, Vice Principal, Public Engagement and Student Enterprise, Queen Mary University of London

*

Professor Sir David Spiegelhalter, President, Royal Statistical Society, Winton Professor of the Public Understanding of Risk, University of Cambridge and Chair, Winton Centre for Risk and Evidence Communication

Alphabetical list of all witnesses

10x Future Technology

AIC0024

The Academy of Medical Sciences

AIC0210

Accenture UK Limited

AIC0191

Advanced Marine Innovation Technology Subsea Ltd

AIC0038

Agents, Interaction and Complexity (AIC) Group, University of Southampton

AIC0115

AGISI.org

AIC0184

The Society for the Study of Artificial Intelligence and the Simulation of Behaviour (AISB)

AIC0086

The AI Initiative, The Future Society at Harvard Kennedy School

AIC0209

**

The Alan Turing Institute (QQ 143–152)

AIC0139

Mr Jaafar Almusaad

AIC0039

Amnesty International

AIC0180

Dr Sally Applin

AIC0172

Arm

AIC0083

Article 19

AIC0129

The Association of Medical Research Charities (AMRC)

AIC0202

Dr Shahar Avin

AIC0150

Baker McKenzie

AIC0111

Balderton Capital (UK) LLP

AIC0232

*

Dr David Barber, Turing Fellow, The Alan Turing Institute, and Reader in Computational Statistics and Machine Learning, UCL (QQ 38–45)

*

Jeremy Barnett (QQ 29–37)

Professor Andrew Basden

AIC0195

BBC

AIC0204

BCS, The Chartered Institute for IT

AIC0049

Dr Simon Beard

AIC0150

**

Miles Berry (QQ 181–189)

AIC0247

Big Brother Watch

AIC0154

Big Innovation Centre

AIC0119

Bikal

AIC0052

Dr Richard Billingsley

AIC0201

BioCentre

AIC0169

Bioss International Ltd

AIC0033

Dr Andrew Blick

AIC0064

Dr Paula Boddington

AIC0067

Michael Borgeaud

AIC0233

*

Professor Nick Bostrom (QQ 1–8)

Braintree

AIC0074

Mr Philip Bree

AIC0039

Bristows LLP

AIC0097

The British Academy

AIC0213

The British Institute of Facilities Management (BIFM)

AIC0205

British Standards Institution

AIC0165
AIC0231

*

Graham Brown-Martin (QQ 181–189)

BSA The Software Alliance

AIC0153

Dr Aysegul Bugra

AIC0051

Professor Alan Bundy

AIC0029

**

Dr Mercedes Bunz (QQ 55–64)

AIC0048

*

Eileen Burbidge MBE (QQ 46–54)

Eur. Ing. David Burden

AIC0061

Michael Butterworth

AIC0104

Cancer Research UK

AIC0219

Capco

AIC0071

CBI

AIC0114

*

Rory Cellan-Jones (QQ 9–17)

Center for Data Innovation

AIC0043

Centre for Health Economics University of York

AIC0242

Centre for Public Impact

AIC0173

Centre for the Study of Existential Risk

AIC0237
AIC0239

CENTURY Tech

AIC0084

Matthew Channon

AIC0051

Charities Aid Foundation

AIC0042

Mr Thomas Cheney

AIC0098

Dr Esyin Chew

AIC0166

Children’s Commissioner for England

AIC0123

**

CIFAR (QQ 172–180)

AIC0136

*

Citizens Advice (QQ 85–94)

Donald Clerk

AIC0022

CognitionX

AIC0170

Cognitive Finance Group

AIC0010

**

Competition and Markets Authority (QQ 85–94)

AIC0245

Contact Centre Systems Ltd.

AIC0032

Cooley (UK) LLP

AIC0217

Dr Steven Cranfield

AIC0104

Will Crosthwait

AIC0094

Darktrace

AIC0243

Data & Society Research Institute

AIC0221

Mr Graeme Davis

AIC0054

Deep Learning Partnership

AIC0027

Deep Science Ventures

AIC0167

DeepMind

AIC0234

Deloitte

AIC0075

Department of Computer Science, University of Bath

AIC0099

Department of Computer Science, University of Liverpool

AIC0192

**

Digital Catapult (QQ 38–45)

AIC0175

Doteveryone

AIC0148

Reverend Dr Lyndon Drake

AIC0108

*

Dyson (QQ 105–115)

Richard Ebley

AIC0026

The Economic Singularity Supper Club

AIC0058

*

Professor David Edgerton (QQ 213–223)

Professor Lilian Edwards

AIC0161

Electronic Frontier Foundation

AIC0199

Dr Julian Estevez

AIC0021

euRobotics Topics Group on ‘Ethical, Legal and
Socio-economic issues’

AIC0189

Faethm Pty Ltd

AIC0141

Family Law Partners

AIC0089

Dr Jerry Fishenden

AIC0028

Professor Robert Fisher

AIC0029

Dr Malcolm Fisk

AIC0012

Five AI Ltd

AIC0128

Foundation for Responsible Robotics

AIC0188

Professor John Fox

AIC0076

Laurence Freeman

AIC0147

**

Fujitsu (QQ 105–115)

AIC0120

**

Future Advocacy (QQ 95–104)

AIC0121

Future Intelligence

AIC0216

Future of Humanity Institute

AIC0103

Dr Samantha Gallivan

AIC0185

*

German Research Centre for Artificial Intelligence (DFKI) (QQ 163–171)

Joanna Goodman

AIC0104

Google

AIC0225

Government of Canada

AIC0222

Government of China

AIC0145

Government of Japan

AIC0224

Government of the Republic of Korea

AIC0228

Dr Paul Graham

AIC0088

Guide Dogs

AIC0040

Dr Ozlem Gurses

AIC0051

*

Professor Dame Wendy Hall (QQ 1–8)

*

Professor Chris Hankin (QQ 143–152)

Baroness Harding of Winscombe

AIC0072

*

Dr Hugh Harvey (QQ 128–142)

**

HM Government (QQ 190–200)

AIC0229

Fabia Howard-Smith

AIC0147

The Human Rights, Big Data and Technology Project

AIC0196

*

Dr Julian Huppert (QQ 116–127)

Dr Catrin Fflûr Huws

AIC0008

**

IBM (QQ 76–84)

AIC0160

IEEE European Public Policy Initiative Working Group on ICT

AIC0106

The IEEE Global Initiative for Ethical Considerations in Artificial Intelligence and Autonomous Systems

AIC0100

*

IEEE-Standards Association (QQ 18–28)

Imperial College London

AIC0214

**

Information Commissioner’s Office (QQ 55–64)

AIC0132

Information Systems Audit and Control Association (ISACA) London Chapter

AIC0193

Information Technology Industry Council (ITI)

AIC0176

Innovate UK

AIC0220

The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales

AIC0041

Institute of Mathematics and its Applications

AIC0107

International Associates

AIC0003

Dr Maria Ioannidou

AIC0082

Brian Joyce

AIC0179

Dr Paresh Kathrani

AIC0104

Kemp Little LLP

AIC0133

Professor Simon King

AIC0029

Dr Ben Kirman

AIC0127

The Knowledge, Skills and Experience Foundation

AIC0044

Dr Ansgar Koene

AIC0208

Dr Antonios Kouroutakis

AIC0051

KPMG LLP

AIC0211

Martina Kunz

AIC0150

Maciej Kuziemski

AIC0197

Professor Marta Kwiatkowska

AIC0190

Dale Lane

AIC0059

Law and Innovation Research Group and the Legal Teaching Research Group from The Fundação Getúlio Vargas School of Law, São Paulo, Brazil

AIC0177

Dr David Lawrence

AIC0036

The Law Society of England and Wales

AIC0152

James Lawson

AIC0073

Professor Shaun Lawson

AIC0127

Professor Mark Lee

AIC0093

Leverhulme Centre for the Future of Intelligence

AIC0182
AIC0236
AIC0237
AIC0238
AIC0239

LexisNexis UK

AIC0164

Liberty

AIC0181

Chrissie Lightfoot

AIC0104

Dr Conor Linehan

AIC0127

**

Professor Rosemary Luckin (QQ 181–189)

AIC0246

Dr Mike Lynch

AIC0005

AIC0230

Ms Nika Mahnič

AIC0200

The Market Research Society

AIC0130

Professor James Marshall

AIC0088

Dr Neil McBride

AIC0047

*

Major Kitty McKendrick (QQ 153–162)

Mr John McNamara

AIC0081

Sabine McNeill

AIC0009

*

Professor Peter McOwan (QQ 213–223)

Professor Andrew McStay

AIC0015

medConfidential

AIC0063
AIC0244

The Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA)

AIC0134

Microsoft

AIC0149

*

MMC Ventures (QQ 46–54)

*

Professor Dame Henrietta Moore (QQ 95–104)

Dr Zdenek Moravcik

AIC0019

Dr Ian Morgan

AIC0179

Dr Sarah Morley

AIC0036

**

National Data Guardian for Health and Care
(QQ 128–142)

AIC0143

Professor John Naughton

AIC0144

NCC Group plc

AIC0240

Dr Jean-Christophe Nebel

AIC0102

Hadley Newman

AIC0155
AIC0156

*

NHS Digital (QQ 128–142)

Nominet

AIC0131

Norton Rose Fulbright LLP

AIC0079

Professor Thomas Nowotny

AIC0088

**

NVIDIA (QQ 38–45)

AIC0212

**

Ocado Group plc (QQ 105–115)

AIC0050

Mr Jeremy O’Connor

AIC0034

*

Sarah O’Connor (QQ 9–17)

Dr Dan O’Hara

AIC0127

Dr Seán Ó hÉigeartaigh

AIC0150

Dr James O’Shea

AIC0226

Alex Olson

AIC0002

Onfido

AIC0163

Online Dating Association

AIC0110

*

Open Data Institute (QQ 65–75)

*

Open Rights Group (QQ 65–75)

ORBIT The Observatory for Responsible Research and Innovation in ICT

AIC0109

Ordnance Survey

AIC0090

*

Andrew Orlowski (QQ 9–17)

Marion Oswald

AIC0068

Professor Maja Pantic

AIC0215

Dr Andrew Pardoe

AIC0020

Joshua Parikh

AIC0031

Jonathan Penn

AIC0198

*

Dr Jèrôme Pesenti (QQ 201–212)

**

PHG Foundation (QQ 116–127)

AIC0092

Dr Andrew Philippides

AIC0088

Toby Phillips

AIC0197

Professor Barbara Pierscionek

AIC0046

Professor John Preston

AIC0014

PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (PwC)

AIC0162

**

Privacy International (QQ 65–75)

AIC0207

*

Project Juno (QQ 46–54)

Raymond Williams Foundation

AIC0122

**

Professor Chris Reed (QQ 29–37)

AIC0055

Research Councils UK

AIC0142

Research into Employment, Empowerment and Futures Centre (REEF), The Open University

AIC0124

Professor Kathleen Richardson

AIC0200

Professor David Robertson

AIC0029

Mrs Violet Rook

AIC0151

Dr Michael Rovatsos

AIC0029

Royal Academy of Engineering

AIC0140

The Royal College of Radiologists

AIC0146

The Royal Society

AIC0168

The Royal Statistical Society

AIC0218

The RSA

AIC0157

Dr John Rumbold

AIC0046

SafeToNet

AIC0087

**

Sage (QQ 76–84)

AIC0159

*

SAP (QQ 76–84)

Professor Maggi Savin-Baden

AIC0061

SCAMPI Research Consortium, City, University of London

AIC0060

Dr Valentina Rita Scotti

AIC0051

Dr Huma Shah

AIC0066

**

Professor Noel Sharkey (QQ 153–162)

AIC0248

Simul Systems Ltd

AIC0016

Jonathan Sinclair

AIC0023

AIC0035

SiteFocus Incorporated

AIC0187

Dr Will Slocombe

AIC0056

*

Professor Sir David Spiegelhalter (QQ 213–223)

Dr Chris Steed

AIC0017

*

Mike Stone (QQ 153–162)

**

Professor Richard Susskind OBE (QQ 95–104)

AIC0194

Professor Austin Tate

AIC0029

techUK

AIC0203

*

Thales Group (QQ 153–162)

Thames Valley Police

AIC0125

Thomson Reuters

AIC0223

Touch Surgery

AIC0070

Transport Systems Catapult

AIC0158

Richard Tromans

AIC0227

UCL Knowledge Lab

AIC0105

UK Computing Research Committee

AIC0030

The Association for UK Interactive Entertainment (Ukie)

AIC0116

*

Understanding Patient Data, Wellcome Trust
(QQ 116–127)

Dr Ozlem Ulgen

AIC0112

University College London (UCL)

AIC0135

Sheena Urwin

AIC0068

Michael Veale

AIC0065

Professor Chris Voss

AIC0118

*

Dr Sandra Wachter (QQ 55–64)

Dr Toby Walsh

AIC0078

Andrew Ware

AIC0150

Professor Kevin Warwick

AIC0066

Warwick Business School University of Warwick

AIC0117

Weightmans LLP

AIC0080

Wellcome Trust

AIC0202

Vishal Wilde

AIC0004

Professor Chris Williams

AIC0029

Professor Rebecca Williams

AIC0206

*

Professor Alan Winfield (QQ 18–28)

**

Professor Michael Wooldridge (QQ 1–8)

AIC0174

Workday Inc.

AIC0183

*

Professor Karen Yeung (QQ 29–37)

Young Enterprise

AIC0091

Dr Jianhan Zhu

AIC0045

Diego Zuluaga

AIC0235





© Parliamentary copyright 2018