Technology Rules? The advent of new technologies in the justice system Contents

Appendix 2: List of witnesses

Evidence is published online at https://committees.parliament.uk/committee/519/justice-and-home-affairs-committee/publications/ and available for inspection at the Parliamentary Archives (020 7219 3074).

Evidence received by the Committee is listed below in chronological order of oral evidence session and in alphabetical order. Those witnesses marked ** gave both oral evidence and written evidence. Those marked with * gave oral evidence and did not submit any written evidence. All other witnesses submitted written evidence only.

Oral evidence in chronological order

*

Professor Sylvie Delacroix, Professor in Law and Ethics at University of Birmingham

QQ 1–24

*

Professor Carole McCartney, Professor of Law and Criminal Justice at Northumbria University

QQ 1–24

**

Professor Charles Raab, Professorial Fellow, Politics and International Relations, School of Social and Political Science at The University of Edinburgh)

QQ 1–24

*

Dr David Leslie, Ethics Theme Lead at Alan Turing Institute

QQ 25–38

*

Professor Michael Wooldridge, Head of Department of Computer Science, Professor of Computer Science at University of Oxford

QQ 25–38

**

Professor Colin Gavaghan, Director New Zealand Law Foundation Centre for Law and Policy in Emerging Technologies at University of Otago

QQ 39–51

*

Professor Elizabeth E Joh, Martin Luther King Jr. Professor of Law at University of California, Davis

QQ 39–51

*

Dr Rosamunde Elise van Brakel, Co-Director, Surveillance Studies Network, Associate Professor Tilburg University/Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB)

QQ 39–51

**

Silkie Carlo, Director, Big Brother Watch

QQ 52–67

**

Peter Dawson, Director, Prison Reform Trust

QQ 52–67

*

Professor Karen Yeung, Interdisciplinary Professorial Fellow in Law, Ethics and Informatics, Birmingham Law School at The University of Birmingham

QQ 52–67

*

David Lewis, Former Deputy Chief Constable and former ethics lead NPCC at Dorset Police

QQ 68–82

*

Dr Liam Owens, Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Semantics 21

QQ 68–82

**

Professor Sandra Wachter, Associate Professor and Senior Research Fellow at University of Oxford

QQ 68–82

**

Professor Paul Taylor, Chief Scientific Adviser, National Police Chiefs’ Council

QQ 83–98

**

Alun Michael, Police and Crime Commissioner for South Wales and Joint Lead for Data and Bioethics, Association of Police and Crime Commissioners

QQ 83–98

**

Darryl Preston, Police and Crime Commissioner for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and Joint Lead for Data and Bioethics, Association of Police and Crime Commissioners

QQ 83–98

*

David Tucker, Faculty Lead on Crime and Criminal Justice, College of Policing.

QQ 83–98

*

The Rt Hon Kit Malthouse MP, Minister of State for Crime and Policing at the Home Office and Ministry of Justice

QQ 99–111

*

Dr Christophe Prince, Director for Data and Identity, Home Office

QQ 99–111

Alphabetical list of all witnesses

Robin Allen QC, Barristers at A1 Law Consultancy/Cloisters Chambers

NTL0019

Dr Arianna Andreangeli, Senior Lecturer in Competition Law, Edinburgh Law School, University of Edinburgh

NTL0038

NTL0039

Dr Philip Avenell, Managing Director and Forensic Biologist at Forensic Access

NTL0024

Avon and Somerset Police

NTL0052

BAE Systems

NTL0056

Professor Melanie Bailey, Professor at University of Surrey

NTL0024

The Bar Council

NTL0048

Dr Marcin Betkier, Lecturer in Law at Victoria University of Wellington

NTL0021

Dr Stephen Bleay, Senior Lecturer in Forensic Science at London South Bank University

NTL0024

Katy Bourne OBE, Sussex Police and Crime Commissioner

NTL0045

Dr Rebecca Brown, Research Fellow at University of Oxford

NTL0030

Professor Dame Vicki Bruce DBE, Professor Emerita at Newcastle University

NTL0012

Professor A Mike Burton, Professor of Psychology at University of York

NTL0012

Professor Liz Campbell, Professor and Francine V McNiff Chair in Criminal Jurisprudence at Monash University

NTL0021

**

Silkie Carlo, Director, Big Brother Watch
(QQ 52–67)

NTL0037

Detective Sergeant Laurence Cartwright, Data Analytics lead at Sussex Police

NTL0040

Dr Jiahong Chen, Lecturer in Law at Sheffield Law School, University of Sheffield

NTL0035

The Crown Prosecution Service

NTL0018

Dr Benjamin Davies, Wellcome Trust Society & Ethics Research Fellow at University of Oxford

NTL0030

**

Peter Dawson, Director, The Prison Reform Trust (QQ 52–67)

NTL0004

defenddigitalme

NTL0044

Dr Delphine Defossez (Lecturer in Law), Northumbria University

NTL0022

*

Professor Sylvie Delacroix, Professor in Law and Ethics at University of Birmingham (QQ 1–24)

Professor Thomas Douglas, Professor of Applied Philosophy University of Oxford

NTL0013

NTL0030

Archie Drake, Research Associate at Kings College, London

NTL0011

Professor Gary Edmond, Professor of Law at UNSW Sydney

NTL0012

Professor Lilian Edwards, Professor of Law, Innovation and Society at Newcastle Law School, Newcastle University

NTL0035

Professor Seena Fazel, Professor of Forensic Psychiatry & Wellcome Trust Senior Research Fellow in Clinical Science at University of Oxford

NTL0030

Dr Lisa Forsberg, British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow at University of Oxford

NTL0013

NTL0030

Professor Simona Francese, Professor of Forensic and Bioanalytical Mass Spectrometry at Sheffield Hallam University

NTL0024

Professor Pete Fussey, Professor of Sociology, University of Essex

NTL0017

Professor Angela Gallop, Professor of Practice/Director of Forensic Science at University of Strathclyde/Forensic Access

NTL0024

**

Professor Colin Gavaghan, Director New Zealand Law Foundation Centre for Law and Policy in Emerging Technologies at University of Otago
(QQ 39–51)

NTL0047

Dr Jamie Grace, Senior Lecturer in Law at Sheffield Hallam University

NTL0001

Professor Nigel Harvey, Professor of Judgment and Decision Research at UCL London

NTL0025

Tobias Harvey, Student of Law at Kings College London

NTL0025

Dr Binesh Hass, Research Fellow at University of Oxford

NTL0030

The Home Office

NTL0055

Independent Office for Police Conduct

NTL0054

The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO)

NTL0016

Istanbul Bar Association

NTL0028

*

Professor Elizabeth E Joh, Martin Luther King Jr. Professor of Law at University of California, Davis (QQ 39–51)

Perry Keller, Reader in Media and Information Law, Director of Doctoral Studies at King’s College London

NTL0011

Professor Paul Kelly, Professor of Inorganic Chemistry at University of Loughborough

NTL0024

Professor Richard I.Kemp, Professor of Psychology at UNSW Sydney

NTL0012

Dr Kyriakos N Kotsoglou, Senior Lecturer in Law, Northumbria University/Research Fellow, University of Lausanne

NTL0006

NTL0007

The Law Society of England and Wales

NTL0023

Dr Christopher Lawless, Associate Professor at Durham University

NTL0029

*

Dr David Leslie, Ethics Theme Lead at Alan Turing Institute (QQ 25–38)

*

David Lewis, Former Deputy Chief Constable and former ethics lead NPCC at Dorset Police (QQ 68–82)

Liberty

NTL0020

Sjors Ligthart LLM PhD candidate at Tilburg University

NTL0013

Dr Nessa Lynch, Associate Professor of Law at Victoria University of Wellington

NTL0021

*

The Rt Hon Kit Malthouse MP, Minister of State for Crime and Policing at the Home Office and Ministry of Justice (QQ 99–111)

Stephen Mason, Associate Research Fellow, Institute of Advanced Legal Studies

NTL0002

Dee Masters, Barristers at A1 Law Consultancy/Cloisters Chambers

NTL0019

Professor Derek McAuley, Director of Horizon Digital Economy Research Institute at University of Nottingham

NTL0035

**

Professor Carole McCartney, Professor of Law and Criminal Justice at Northumbria University (QQ 1–24)

NTL0022

medConfidential

NTL0050

The Metropolitan Police Service

NTL0031

Professor Gerben Meynen, Professor of Forensic Psychiatry and Bioethics at Utrecht University and VU University Amsterdam

NTL0013

**

Alun Michael, Police and Crime Commissioner for South Wales and Joint Lead for Data and Bioethics, Association of Police and Crime Commissioners (QQ 83–98)

NTL0049

NTL0057

Migrants’ Rights Network

NTL0042

The Ministry of Justice

NTL0053

Abhishek Mishra, Doctoral Student at University of Oxford

NTL0030

Dr Brent Mittelstadt of the Oxford Internet Institute (OII)

NTL0058

Dr Reuben Moreton, Reli Ltd

NTL0026

Professor Ruth Morgan, Professor of Crime and Forensic Sciences at University College London

NTL0024

Dr Daragh Murray, Senior Lecturer in Human Rights at University of Essex

NTL0017

NCC Group

NTL0005

Dr Eilidh Noyes, University of Huddersfield

NTL0026

*

Dr Liam Owens, Founder and Chief Executive Officer, Semantics 21 (QQ 68–82)

Ms Angela Paul (PhD candidate in Law), Northumbria University

NTL0022

Police Scotland

NTL0043

Dr Susan Pope, DNA expert—chair of the Forensic Science Regulator DNA Specialist Group & is an assessor for the Netherlands Register of Court Experts at Principal Forensic Services

NTL0024

**

Darryl Preston, Police and Crime Commissioner for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough and Joint Lead for Data and Bioethics, Association of Police and Crime Commissioners (QQ 83–98)

NTL0049

NTL0057

Dr Christophe Prince, Director for Data and Identity, Home Office (QQ 99–111)

Privacy International

NTL0051

Public Law Project

NTL0046

NTL0059

Gary Pugh, Forensic Science Regulator

NTL0036

Dr Jonathan Pugh, Parfit Radcliffe Senior Research Fellow at University of Oxford

NTL0030

Dr Joe Purshouse, Senior Lecturer in Criminal Law and Justice at University of Sheffield

NTL0021

**

Professor Charles Raab, Professorial Fellow, School of Social and Political Science, University of Edinburgh Fellow, The Alan Turing Institute (QQ 1–24)

NTL0014

Dr Liam Ralph (Lecturer in Criminology and Policing) at the Centre for Crime and Policing & the Science and Justice Research, Northumbria University

NTL0022

Dr Kay L. Ritchie, Senior Lecturer in Cognitive Psychology at University of Lincoln

NTL0003

Royal Statistical Society

NTL0033

Associate Professor. Mehera San Roque, UNSW Sydney

NTL0012

SAS UK&I

NTL0041

Professor Julian Savulescu, Professor of Practical Ethics at University of Oxford

NTL0030

Serious Fraud Office

NTL0034

Professor Ilina Singh, Professor of Neuroscience and Society at University of Oxford

NTL0030

David Spreadborough, CFVA, Forensic Analyst at Amped Software

NTL0015

Dr Amy Stevens, Senior Research Officer, Human Rights, Big Data and Technology Project at University of Essex

NTL0017

Dr Clare Sutherland, Senior Lecturer at University of Aberdeen

NTL0012

**

Professor Paul Taylor, Chief Scientific Adviser, National Police Chiefs’ Council (QQ 83–98)

NTL0049

NTL0057

Dr Alice Towler, Research Fellow at UNSW Sydney

NTL0012

**

David Tucker, Faculty Lead on Crime and Criminal Justice, College of Policing (QQ 83–98)

NTL0057

Professor Gillian Tully, Professor of Practice for Forensic Science Policy and Regulation at King’s College London

NTL0024

UCL Centre for the Forensic Sciences

NTL0010

Dr Lachlan Urquhart, Lecturer in Technology Law, and Co-Investigator of the UKRI Trustworthy Autonomous Systems Node in Governance and Regulation at School of Law University of Edinburgh

NTL0035

*

Dr Rosamunde Elise van Brakel, Co-Director, Surveillance Studies Network, Associate Professor Tilburg University/Vrije Universiteit Brussel (VUB) (QQ 39–51)

**

Professor Sandra Wachter, Associate Professor and Senior Research Fellow at Oxford Internet Institute (OII), University of Oxford (QQ 68–82)

NTL0058

Dr Adrian Weller, Principal Research Fellow in Machine Learning at the University of Cambridge

NTL0040

Dr David White, Senior Lecturer at UNSW Sydney

NTL0012

Dr Matthias Wienroth (Vice-Chancellor’s Senior Fellow in Criminology/Sociology), Northumbria University

NTL0022

Professor Kim Wolff, Director King’s Forensics at King’s College London

NTL0024

*

Professor Michael Woodridge, Head of Department of Computer Science, Professor of Computer Science at University of Oxford (QQ 25–38)

*

Professor Karen Yeung, Interdisciplinary Professorial Fellow in Law, Ethics and Informatics, Birmingham Law School at The University of Birmingham (QQ 52–67)

Dr Miri Zilka, Research Associate in Machine Learning at the University of Cambridge

NTL0040





© Parliamentary copyright 2022