Submission from the Young Foundation (SC-36)
As the call for evidence from the Speaker's
Conference and terms of reference point out, there is a disparity
between the representation of women, ethnic minorities and disabled
people in the House of Commons, and their representation in the
UK population at large.
The situation in the House of Commons reflects
a wider problem in societythat significant groups are underrepresented
in positions of leadership and power in public bodies, business,
the voluntary sector and the media. It is important to look beyond
the House of Commons to address the problems of underrepresentation
within it. Civic engagement and public leadership at a local level
can be the first step on the journey to becoming a more prominent
leader. For most, and particularly for those from the underrepresented
groups, this progression requires encouragement and support.
The routes that once helped to find and nurture
leaders from marginalised communities in particularlike
the churches and trade unionsno longer do so to the same
extent. The main political parties have also shrunk. In the past,
these channels were vital to providing the networks and skills
that young people needed to reach positions of power, but they
have since diminished. For example, being selected by a political
party in a winnable seat generally requires candidates to both
have developed significant networks within their party, and possess
a range of skills, ranging from public speaking to leading a team
of supporters. These institutions also played a key role in spotting
talent, which could then develop through established and widely
understood channels.
As a result of these "channel blockages",
young people who are financially better off, or have access to
social networks, are advantaged in reaching positions of power.
On the whole, these young people are less likely to be from an
ethnic minority, be working class or have a disability. The Young
Foundation has identified a number of barriers to getting young
people from different communities engaged in civic leadership.
These consist of mutually reinforcing supply and demand factors
which are summarized in figure 1.
The Young Foundation will recommend that initiatives
which aim to readdress the imbalances in representation across
government, the public sector, business and the voluntary sector
need to combine addressing barriers to both the supply of new
leaders, and the demand for new leaders. Possible ways of doing
this include:
Match-making intermediaries
Connecting existing programmes to power
networksby creating new routes and making existing routes
more accessible
Focussing the motivation and passions
of young people: giving them opportunities to develop their ideas
into action
Raising aspirations (including through
local role models)
Mentoring and other individualised support
Including multiple methods on single
programmes, to provide a full range of opportunities to develop
and explore politics.
In particular, we would like to see more opportunities
focused on building the non-cognitive skills and networks that
young people need to be active in their communities, and take
up positions of power. These skills will also be increasingly
important to have in the workforce over the coming decades.
We should aim to create a pool of talented young
people with the potential to go on to become MPs, but also take
on other roles, whether in local government, other public bodies
(eg PCT boards), business or the voluntary sector. Broadening
the horizons and skills of young people is also more relevant
in a world where there is an increasing expectation that people
will change their career many times over the course of their lifetime.
The UpRising leadership programme, which has been set up by the
Young Foundation, is one possible model for this and is currently
being piloted in Barking and Dagenham, Newham and Tower Hamlets.
In every community, we would like to see a dedicated programme
focused on developing the skills and networks of young people
to be able to take up positions of power.
An approach that works across the board to create
routes for young people into positions of power (and to move from
one area or sector to another) is likely to be more effective
than one focused solely on a single institution. This is because
one of the keys to success is building the skills and networks
across the board that have both general application, and the potential
to lead to greater involvement in politics. Major institutions,
including Parliament, local authorities, quangos the BBC, the
Police, PCTs and Housing Associations amongst others therefore
need to reform to create better routes for the involvement and
development of young people.
To drive this systemic change, there is a need
to develop and spread best practice of unblocking routes to power
for young people. The government should help by encouraging institutions
to include this in their thinking, especially where new progammes
are being set up. For example, the proposed national internship
scheme should not only help young people get into employment,
but also spot and develop talented young people who can take up
positions of power in a variety of roles.
In summary, the disparity in representation
needs to be tackled by addressing both the supply and demand factors
that act as a barrier to young people influencing and taking up
power across the UK and in particular in Parliament.
|