Select Committee on Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Minutes of Evidence


Memorandum submitted by the Former Independent Scientific Group on Cattle TB

  I am pleased to let your Committee have our considered scientific response to Sir David King's report, in which he advocates culling badgers as a method of controlling cattle TB nationally. In our response we summarise some of the counter-arguments developed in detail in ISG scientific publications. Sir David has underestimated the powerful arguments showing substantial negative effects on TB incidence in cattle involved in such culling, as well as the formidable logistical difficulties which make such detrimental effects a more likely outcome than the intended benefits.

  We believe the report's authors misunderstand a number of scientific issues and, equally seriously, fail to take into account the full range of data on which the ISG conclusions and recommendations to Ministers were based.

  An immediate objective of a cattle TB control policy must be to reduce the national disease incidence. We note that Sir David has not commented on the various constructive suggestions made in the ISG report—particularly those relating to cattle-based controls—that we believe would address this objective. The misunderstanding of our mathematical modelling work is particularly unfortunate, and likely to have led him to underestimate the likely benefits of improved cattle based control measures.

  Furthermore, to have any positive impact on this control policy objective, badger culling would need to cover much of southwest of Britain and would have to be conducted in a systematic, coordinated way, and sustained for many years. Geographically restricted culling, even over a number of selected areas of a hundred square kilometres or more, could be expected to have, at best, only minimal impact nationally, and would be likely to make matters worse if its implementation were uncoordinated, unsustained or patchy.

Professor John Bourne CBE

November 2007



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 27 February 2008