Select Committee on Public Administration Eleventh Report


APPENDIX: MATCHING PUBLIC SERVICE REQUIREMENTS WITH THIRD SECTOR ORGANISATIONS' STRENGTHS

Public service Requirement Third sector StrengthReason

The quality of service being provided is difficult to specify, measure and monitor User focusPrivate providers may have an incentive to reduce quality to increase profit. The third sector has no such incentive.

The demands of service users are high differentiated Flexibility, innovation and 'joining up' Public and private providers are geared to provide services for large numbers of people. The third sector has the flexibility to deal with individual needs.

When services have to be directed at localities or sections of the community that have been excluded from traditional service provision Knowledge, expertise and experienceThird sector organisations are often established by members of the excluded community in response to a perceived gap or inadequacy in service provision.

Labour-intensive services where the flexibility and commitment of volunteers can be an asset User focusVolunteers tend to spend more time providing a higher quality service, especially for disadvantaged people.

Services directed at users that do not trust businesses or the government Trust and accessibilityThird sector providers have no hidden agendas and higher credibility with disaffected users.

Service users are likely to require a co-ordinated portfolio of services Flexibility and 'joining up'Third sector providers spend more time on bringing services together for the user.

Users often have difficulty engaging with service providers (multiple disadvantages) Flexibility and 'joining up'Wider stakeholders allow the third sector to focus on overlapping disadvantage.

Source: HM Treasury, "Exploring the role of the third sector in public service delivery and reform", a discussion document accompanying the 2004 Spending Review.



 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008
Prepared 9 July 2008