Select Committee on the Crossrail Bill Minutes of Evidence


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 11860 - 11879)

  11860. MS KHELA: It is in these documents.

  11861. MR ELVIN: Can you tell me where please? (After a short pause)

  11862. CHAIRMAN: You want all these undertakings to be recommended to the Promoters, do you?

  11863. MS KHELA: Yes. We would like the Committee to recommend those because if this Bill is passed in its present form we believe we will suffer unnecessarily with this alignment.

  11864. CHAIRMAN: I do not mind about the reasoning. What I want to know is, are you asking us to recommend all these undertakings?

  11865. MS KHELA: I apologise.

  11866. CHAIRMAN: You could have told us this, you know, over an hour ago.

  11867. MS KHELA: Unfortunately as we are here presenting a matter which we thought was very important and which we believe will not go away for the Spitalfields community we thought it prudent to raise it. (After a short pause)

  11868. The undertakings are listed on pages 2 to 3. I was merely putting forward the reasons why we are requesting those undertakings. I am not sure if the Committee would like me to proceed?

  11869. CHAIRMAN: Mr Elvin, have you got a copy of this document?

  11870. MR ELVIN: My Lord, I have the additional ones dated May this year. What your clerk has handed me is dated 31 January 2007. Mr Carpenter has whispered to us what they are referring to are undertakings that were requested on behalf of Spitalfields by Ms Jones when she presented—

  11871. MR CARPENTER: No, I am sorry, they are not. I am sorry.

  11872. MR ELVIN: My Lord, I am not going to confuse matters. Clearly we are looking at the wrong document and unless the Petitioner can identify it, I cannot assist. If someone tells me what it is I may recognise it.

  11873. CHAIRMAN: It was presented to a Select Committee on 31 January 2007.

  11874. MS KHELA: Yes, that is correct.

  11875. CHAIRMAN: It must have been in the House of Commons.

  11876. MR ELVIN: That was presented to the Commons. If it is that which is being referred to, I have a copy of it.

  11877. CHAIRMAN: That is what I think Ms Khela is talking about. We know what the House of Commons said about that.

  11878. MR ELVIN: I am sorry. Mr Carpenter gave us an alternative version and I apologise for confusing matters. I will stick to 31 January 2007.

  11879. MS KHELA: If I may be permitted to read through the reasons why we are requesting these.



 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008