Select Committee on the Crossrail Bill Minutes of Evidence


Examination of Witnesses (Questions 11900 - 11919)

  11900. CHAIRMAN: I am not going to stop you giving evidence, if that is what you are doing. I thought you were in fact presenting a petition rather than giving evidence.

  11901. MS KHELA: No.

  11902. CHAIRMAN: You are giving evidence?

  11903. MS KHELA: I am quoting from something which I believe is relevant.

  11904. CHAIRMAN: Are you giving evidence or are you presenting a petition?

  11905. MS KHELA: I am presenting a petition on the basis of information which I believe is pertinent.

  11906. CHAIRMAN: It is no use quoting a lot of other people, what they said, unless you call them to give evidence. Are you going to call them?

  11907. MS KHELA: I think it is relevant because this report—

  11908. CHAIRMAN: Ms Khela, I am going to tell you what is relevant and what is not. If you want to quote from what other people have said, they have to come and give evidence.

  11909. MS KHELA: Even if they have recommended that this report should be followed by other major projects and this Committee has heard about—

  11910. CHAIRMAN: It does not make any difference what they recommended. If you want to quote from them, as the presenter of a petition, you call them to give evidence.

  11911. MS KHELA: On the basis that this Committee decided on the Channel Tunnel Rail Link—

  11912. CHAIRMAN: I am sorry; we are not interested in what they did.

  11913. MS KHELA: On the basis of the Community Liaison Panel, information was received by this Committee and I did not hear anybody hearing evidence on the basis on which it was determined that that tripartite arrangement was not more than what we are claiming it to be, but we do have the report from December 2006 which explains exactly how that tripartite arrangement worked and we would like—

  11914. CHAIRMAN: Is this the Channel Tunnel Rail Link?

  11915. MS KHELA: Yes, it is, but it is the Camden Council Report.

  11916. CHAIRMAN: Have you ever seen this, Mr Elvin?

  11917. MS KHELA: We have sent it to both parties. Unfortunately nobody seems to acknowledge emails any more.

  11918. CHAIRMAN: One of the fairly basic procedures in these sorts of events is that if you are going to start quoting from documents you should show them to the other side, not now but plenty of time before, so they can consider them. It is no use Mr Elvin starting now to look at this.

  11919. MS KHELA: We have been quoting the arrangements of the King's Cross residents since 2007.



 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008