Select Committee on European Union Written Evidence


Memorandum by Food Security

  1. The likely impact of the changes is that history will repeat itself, in that England will be treated unfairly and there will continue to be an unlevel playing field. The end of this road is not only ruin for English farmers, but ruin for the whole of the UK.

  2. Our ability to organize our own affairs with regard to energy and water supplies also appears to be endangered by the possible switch to co-decision on these and other matters. This is not an insignificant consideration—these are life and death issues.

  The explicit taking over by the Union of "the conservation of marine biological resources under the Common Fisheries Policy" is extremely worrying. Do we really wish to risk the lives of our 60 million people? Have we not got the courage to protect our food supply?

  The amended budgetary provisions appear to reflect the reluctance of the EU to spend money of food production. The UK Government's own stance on this is alarming—Lord Davies of Oldham said in the House of Lords on 23 May 2007, "We are continuing to bear down as best we can on what is still an inflated budget spent on agriculture".

  The conferring on the Union of exclusive and shared competencies is of great concern. So many decisions taken by the EU and accepted by the UK (eg Nitrates Directive, and now cost-sharing with regard to animal diseases) are gradually eroding our ability to feed ourselves, and therefore to defend ourselves. We have noted that, under questioning by the EFRA Committee on 10 December, Lord Rooker admitted that this cost-sharing concept is an EU regulation. We wonder why this Government has led us, up until now, to believe that Defra simply considered it a good idea.

  We are concerned that the establishment of an internal market and the inclusion of a solidarity clause will disadvantage Britain and may lead to the seizure of our assets by Europe (eg our armed forces and our natural resources, including our oil).

  Does any sober-thinking person really want the consequences of Article 2? Will the democratically elected Government of the UK allow our sovereignty to be eroded yet further? Where are the politicians with the courage to stand against disaster?

15 December 2007



 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2008